When/why did the Arthurian myths shift from being Welsh to being British?

Whenever I read about the Arthurian myths modern sources seem to regularly call it Welsh, but culturally (in the United States at least) it seems more associated with Britain as a whole.

When/why did this transition happen, or is it just an artifact of America's ignorance of the nations of Britain?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

Did anyone survive one of Pinochet's famous Helicopter executions?

Dropping someone out of a Helicopter seems like a very imprecise execution method, so was there anyone that experienced the Death flights and lived to talk about it?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

In old books, why the last word at the end of page is same as first word on the next page ?

I was reading the original pdf of a book published in early 1800s. I noticed this little oddity on very page. My first guess was maybe binding was fragile at that time, so it was included to not lose the flow of text. But then every page was numbered, rendering this last word's use useless.

Any idea why this was used, and not used in our contemporary books ?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

Why didn't US forces directly fight Chinese communists in mainland China in 1945-1949?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

In the musical "Chess", the song "The Story of Chess" purports to be a full history of the board game from its invention to its modern form. How accurate is it?

The musical Chess originated as a concept album in 1984 and made its stage debut in London in 1986. The music was written by Benny Andersson and Björn Ulvaeus of ABBA fame, and the lyrics were written by Tim Rice.

The musical primarily uses chess as a plot device and as a metaphor for the Cold War rivalry between the United States and Soviet Union. However, one song in the production called "The Story of Chess" purports to be a full abbreviated history of the board game from its invention to modern times. This song is usually the first song in the production and performed by an ensemble of pseudo-narrator characters (although this varies from staging to staging).

The full lyrics are here, and a recording from 2008 can be heard here. In summary, the claims the song makes can be summarized as follows:

  • Chess was invented about 1,500 years ago in a Hindu kingdom on the Indian subcontinent.
  • According to a "fairly vague report" (i.e. legend), two children of a reigning queen fought for the right to inherit the throne, causing one to be killed. The surviving brother consulted with wise men, who invented chess as a way to demonstrate that it was the other brother's own fault that he died.
  • Chess first gained significant popularity outside its country of origin after spreading to Persia ("boosted in the main by what is now Iran").
  • After that, "the Arabs" refined and redesigned it.
  • As of the Fall of Constantinople in 1453, chess was already widely popular in the Byzantine Empire (since "every other refugee included in his bags a set").
  • It spread quickly in Europe during the Renaissance, owing in part to the influence of the "leading figures" of the time.
  • The game took on its modern form in Europe during or after the Renaissance.

How accurate is this account? Are there any significant parts of the real history that are left out or glossed over? And when did the game become something we would recognize as at least resembling modern chess? I've seen a fair bit of conflicting information online, so some suggested sources for further reading would also be helpful.

1 Answers 2020-05-07

Announcing the Best of April Award Winners

Another month has passed us by, and the votes have been added up.

For April, the nod for the 'Users' Choice' went to /u/J-Force, who catapulted themselves into "How do I join a trebuchet crew in late medieval France? Is it a family thing, are there interviews? What are some of the risks and benefits of my new career that are maybe less known?".

Things stayed medieval with the 'Flairs' Choice' as well, with the panelists bestowing the honors upon /u/WelfOnTheShelf, who took us on a journey with their answer to "What was Crusader ‘Tourism” like? Where the knights and lords who participated ever in much danger, or was it more fixed and showy like much Tourism today?".

For April's 'Dark Horse' Award, recognizing the top-voted non-flair, it was close fought between several worthy candidates, but /u/wilymaker in the end edged out the competition with their answer to "What was the effects of muskets during a battle, if bow and arrow were superior?".

This month's 'Greatest Question', voted upon by the mods, went to "When did lesbians, gay men, and transgender people come together to form the LGBT community?", asked by /u/Lurk_Puns. It unfortunately remains unanswered, but hopefully will still get the one it deserves.

Finally, April's Excellence in Flairdom award goes to /u/J2quared! You might recognize J2 from the excellent questions you've had the privilege to read the answers to, or maybe even to answer yourself! Even better: their recent questions, in particular, have made a major effort to draw attention to less popular areas of history, especially African-American studies. Thanks for being a bright presence in the sub, /u/J2quared!

As always, congrats to our very worthy winners, and thank you to everyone else who has contributed here, whether with thought-provoking questions or fascinating answers. And if this month you want to flag some stand-out posts that you read here for potential nomination, don't forget to post them in our Sunday Digest!

For a list of past winners, check them out here!

3 Answers 2020-05-07

How did Japan go from a war-torn country to one of the most developed and technologically advanced in a span of 40 years?

There was an article on the front page yesterday about how outdated and inflexible the current Japanese business and bureaucratic systems are in their response to Covid, and commenters were bringing up stories about the high levels of inefficiencies when dealing with Japanese businesses (e.g. international representatives having to phone home to consult their superiors for every decision) in general.

The current "outdated and inflexible" systems must have worked at some point in the past for Japan to have gotten to where it is now, right? How did these business and bureaucratic norms form in the first place, and what roles did they play in rebuilding Japan in the post-war era up until the present?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

How well prepared/trained was the Argentine military during the Falklands War?

I have heard that the war mas an attempt of the dictator of that time to legitimize himself and appear powerful, but that in reality hus army consisted mostly of unpreprared teenagers. Is this true?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | May 07, 2020

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

10 Answers 2020-05-07

Did Renaissance Sculptors have Silicosis or other Lung Problems?

Working with stone creates a great deal of dust and other irritants. I imagine most historical craftsmen didn't wear much safety equipment. Over time, working around stone dust without proper safety equipment can seriously damage a person's lungs, causing scarring and breathing issues. Do we have records of renaissance or ancient sculptors struggling with this sort of lung damage?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

By the times Europeans got to Australia, what was the aborigines's relationship with dingoes? Were they being domesticated?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

How did the US react to Thomas Jefferson emancipating only three of his many slaves, all of which were known even then to likely be his children?

Looking into Jefferson is fascinating - his life is so packed with accomplishments, failures, great ideas, and horrific mistakes, and he is somehow very consistent in spite of being such a deeply contradictory person...

By the time he emancipated her children, the people of his time definitely knew of the allegations regarding his relationship with Sally Hemmings, questions about it having been publicly raised numerous times in the past. One would think that the Federalists would have used the emancipation to further reinforce the character questions they’d previously put forth about him, and that even Democratic-Republicans would have balked at the potentially nepotistic optics of the situation.

Did people at large generally not know about this action? Was emancipation a totally private happening? Am I using as a model too modern of a relationship between the press/public and the political elite of the time? It would be understandable if, in a time before universal education and suffrage, people were less informed or politically involved...but also, the salacious nature of the accusations would have been base enough for even the crudest American to understand...

I have a lot of questions about the morality of this time, the combination of what would now be considered extreme religiousness with such callous indifference to the suffering created by chattel slavery smacks of such deep hypocrisy to my modern mind that it’s almost unintelligible. Still, I can clearly see how even people as morally alien to my own sensibilities could find problems with emancipation of slavery based on a potential kinship. I would greatly appreciate any illumination that can be shed on how society reacted to learning that one of their founding fathers was giving preferential treatment to the products of a long term, inter-racial sexual relationship with a slave he owned; I think it might help some other, broader pieces of my understanding of the time fall more accurately in place. Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-05-07

Why was there no Japanese invasion of California?

In 1942, they bombed an oil field north of LA. Balloon bombs were launched, and 25 were found in CA, but none caused injuries. And then of course, various ships were attacked. Aside from these, it doesn't seem like there was any real attempt at attack or invasion. Why is this?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

In the Disney movie Aristocats, there was a system of pipes that ran throughout the house that were apparently used to communicate between rooms. Were pipes like these ever used in history, or is this just an invention for the movie?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

Please recommend me history books which feature many maps

I love looking at maps and learning history. I'm not picky about the historical subject, and am just as happy reading about Napoleon's adventures in the Po valley as I am reading about exchanges between colonial societies in the West Indies. I read history at a university level. Thank you.

1 Answers 2020-05-07

Nowadays Chinese dictionaries use pinyin and the Latin alphabet to order words. How did Chinese dictionaries get made before this given that Chinese is a pictoral language? Was there a precursor system to the modern day pinyin system?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

Native American accounts of visiting Europe?

I am looking for accounts from the perspective of Native North or South Americans of visits to Europe. We have lots of the reverse, Europeans describing the Americas, are there any historical records of the other way round?

2 Answers 2020-05-07

Why didn’t Britain declare war on the USSR?

Didn’t the UK have a deal with Poland that if anyone attacks Poland the UK will attack them? That’s why the UK declared war on the Third Reich. So why didn’t they declare war on the USSR since the soviets also attacked Poland?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

How much of a moderate influence was Robespierre during the Terror?

I've been hearing people say that, quite contrary to the idea that he pushed it to extremes, he was actually a moderate in comparison and tried to make sure there were no needless deaths. How true is that, and if so, how much of a moderate was he?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

Did the British colonize Australia with a goal in mind of establishing a trading port in the southern hemisphere?

I've seen claims to this but can find no evidence backing it up.

2 Answers 2020-05-07

Known named Pharaohs in Archeology

How would somebody find a list of the Pharaohs that are known by ancient inscriptions, monuments, tombs, pyramids etc.? In other words, which Pharaohs do we know about aside from written history (e.g. Herodotus, Manetho etc.)?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2020-05-07

What were the demographics of Sicily around the year 1000 AD and did it convert quicker then other Islamic conquests and if so, why?

So I've read that when the Normans conquered Sicily it was already majority Muslim. This seems like an awfully high conversion rate given that Muslims had only ruled the island for 120 years or so is there are reason the population converted so quickly. Additionally how divided was in the island in terms of Sunni versus Shia.

1 Answers 2020-05-07

What clothes, hats, etc. did men and women of the eighteenth century wear?

1 Answers 2020-05-07

Do historians think the popularity of the “parody history” genre like YouTube channels Oversimplified and Bill Wurtz serves to help or hinder the field of history?

3 Answers 2020-05-07

New Scholarship on the "Dorian Invasion" and/or Mycenae Collapse?

I have recently read through the first several chapters of Sparta and Lakonia A regional history 1300–362 BC by Paul Cartledge, and while as far as I can tell it does an outstanding job of addressing the topic above, really in quite specific detail as it relates to Laconia, and in general summarizes and engages with the existing literature regarding the topic in what to me appears to be a thorough and comprehensive manner, the lack of information available left a lot of unknowns and a lot to guess work.

Cartledge himself certainly provided, either through direct recommendation or his citations, plenty sources to look at for additional information and contrary opinions on the subject. But the book is almost twenty years old now, and my question is is there any new scholarship that has come out since then related to this topic that has been able to shed some new light onto this subject, or which has furthered the discussion in some way? I suppose if Cartledge specifically omitted or overlooked something glaring that wouldn't be bad to know either, though I would think someone would raise that in a publication in response, and therefore get lumped in with the new scholarship.

I certainly understand there just might not be anything new out there because nothing new has been found. And so far, I haven't been able to find anything since then on Google or Jstor.

Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2020-05-07

1353 / 7255

Back to start