Well-known is the US's active intervention in 20th-century Latin American politics, such as in Chile in the 1970s. Did the US intervene in the politics of its neighbor Mexico in the 20th century? If so, how?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

Having trouble with Thucydides

"It appears therefore that the several Hellenic communities, comprising not only those who first acquired the name, city by city, as they came to understand each other, but also those who assumed it afterwards as the name of the whole people, were before the Trojan war prevented by their want of strength and the absence of mutual intercourse from displaying any collective action.”

I'm not sure what this means.

2 Answers 2017-10-06

Was General Douglas MacArthur the reason for the Korean War stalemate?

I was watching a documentary on the battle of the hochin reservoir which was where the Chinese intervened and the Americans were forced into a retreat after killing tens of thousands of Chinese human waves.

During the documentary they kept saying how arrogant MacArthur was to be pushing so hard into North Korea and how he ignored intelligence saying the Chinese were planning an attack.

If he had heeded the warning and began to push more steadily with overwhelming numbers, could the Korean Peninsula been united under a democracy today?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

I'm a well off unmarried princess living in Britain around 1000CE. What is my life like? (Specific questions down below)

I have a few more specific questions as well:

1)What type of education would I have? Would i be expected to know how to cook and clean like a peasant woman would, or would I have servants to do that for me?

2)What would I do in my spare time?

3)My father has decided I should marry. How much choice do I have over the matter, both in regards to my choice of spouse and whether or not i will marry at all? What would happen to me if I refused to comply with my father's wishes?

  1. What type of medical care would I have in regards to feminine issues, ie menstruation, childbirth ect..,

5)Say I do marry. Who would be a likely candidate for my bridegroom?

6)If my future husband dies, what will happen to me? I assume there is some difference in what happens regarding whether or not I have had children

Thank you!

1 Answers 2017-10-06

How do my arbitrary division of American History look?

I am trying to write a high school American history curriculum, and could use some input. I want to divide American history into 5 distinct eras. I realize this a bit arbitrary and sloppy, but I have a pedagogical reasons that makes it necessary.

If I could get some input I would appreciate it.

  1. Pre-Contact & Colonial America (Land Bridge through End of American Revolution)

  2. Young Republic (Articles of Confederation through Reconstruction)

  3. Industrial America (Gilded Age through WWII)

  4. Post World Wars America or Cold War Era(1945 through Fall of Soviets Union)

  5. Modern America (1991 through Today)

My rationale for the divisions is that everything in the an era seems to lead to the concluding event. After the concluding event America is different.

So you can pin my knowledge level. I have a BA in US history focusing on colonial America. My knowledge of anything post WW2 is inadequate right now.

Any help would be appreciated, and I hope this is the appropriate place for this post.

1 Answers 2017-10-06

Is it fair to in broad strokes characterize the Allied (mostly, US and Soviet) forces as experts at Strategic/Operational levels but poor at the tactical level, and characterize Germans as experts at the tactical level and poor if not outright incompetent at higher levels?

2 Answers 2017-10-06

What military advantages did the Greeks have over the Persians?

I used to think that Greek victories despite being outnumbered (at Marathon and Plataea) and moral victories (Thermopylae) were due to the close order hoplite formation. Rugged, disciplined men clad in bronze with overlapping shields, each fighting for the freedom of his Polis and the man next to him would tear lightly armored Persian skirmishers with wicker shields and short spears.

Obivously that's an exaggeration- I knew that Greek hoplites didn't all have Bronze armor, and Persians weren't all lightly armored skirmishers- but that what I thought in broad strokes.

Lately, I've been exposed to some of Hans Van Wees' works, and some of /u/Iphikrates 's posts and learned the 'heretical' model of hoplite warfare. That hoplites were essentially untrained militia and rarely, if ever drilled together. They fought in looser order than we used to think, and the armor was not necessarily any better than what the Persians had. Why then did they win so many battles against the Persians while outnumbered?

I understand that the Persians were at the end of their logistical rope, but that should explain why a campaign stutters out after a sack or two, not why they'd get trounced in battles where they outnumbered the enemy?

Did the Persians not actually have any numerical advantage? Did the Greeks just get lucky?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

Veganism

Was there ever vegans in history? Was there ever people in history who wrote in their diary or whatever six hundred years ago or something and said 'I think it's cruel to eat meat'. If not, what changed in modern times? Not sure if this is better to ask a sociologist/anthropologist or something. Basically what I am asking is, is there a 'history of veganism'. Thanks, I hope this is clear enough.

1 Answers 2017-10-06

How did official state Churches work in the Early Republic period, and what caused them to eventually decline?

As I understand it, about half of the original 13 states had state churches, but I know very little about how this worked in practice, so have a few questions about it:

  • What did this mean in practical terms, especially as regards the Churchs' involvement in state politics, as well as freedom of worship for members of different denominations?
  • Although this was in the pre-Incorporation period as regards the Bill of Rights, how much opposition was there to state-level establishment of religion, and were there supporters of an Incorporationist understanding of the First Amendment at the time?
  • Why did they all die out? My impression is that they were mostly gone by the mid-19th century, so it was well before the 14th Amendment, let alone Everson in 1947.

1 Answers 2017-10-06

Were there ultra-wealthy people in the Soviet Union?

The billionaires created by the fall of the Soviet Union and privatization of public industries are notorious. Were there people that wealthy in the Soviet Union? If so, how did they get their wealth and how did people view them in light of the fact that they were living in a communist country?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

Friday Free-for-All | October 06, 2017

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

12 Answers 2017-10-06

When did Egypt become a vassal of rome?

I understand that Octavian invaded it in his war with Antony, but prior to that it was already some sort of client state, hence Antony staying there, when exactly did this happen?

2 Answers 2017-10-06

What was traveling like in ancient times?

What were the means of transportation then? Did people travel a lot? Did people emigrate? Did tourism exist back then?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

How widespread was communism in Hollywood pre-blacklist?

Obviously McCarthy and HUAC was over the top. But was there actually a significant amount of communists and other radicals working in Hollywood prior to the blacklist? I know of a few, like Dalton Trumbo. But were there any more, and did their ideas ever get into the films being put out?

My own feeling is that while there were communists here and there, they did not have a significant influence on studio output; most of the films they made were just broadly apolitical and not at all leftist, like most Hollywood films of the time. Aside from some pro-USSR/Stalin films made during WWII, there was not much communist content in Hollywood. Is that accurate?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

What is the most accepted date of the beggining of the Second Industrial Revolution?

I researched a lot; some sites say it's 1850, some 1860 and others 1870.

1 Answers 2017-10-06

San Francisco has trolleys/streetcars but I have never heard of any other place that has/had them. Were the ever anywhere else?

Where they just not popular, did they get phased out, were they just never built anywhere else?

If they weren't in other cities, why did they catch on in San Francisco but virtually nowhere else?

If they were in other cities why are they so iconic for San Francisco when they were basically just city buses?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

AskHistorians Podcast 096 -- European Military Orders and their History

Episode 96 is up!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make /r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via iTunes, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. You can also catch the latest episodes on SoundCloud. If there is another index you'd like the cast listed on, let me know!

This Episode:

This week we have a great interview with /u/Rhodis on the military orders, like the Knights Templars, Hospitallers and others! Today he will be gong us a thorough and factual history of these military orders, which often swirl with myth and legends and provide fodder for thousands of fantasy authors. Expect a special bonus episode next week on the military orders in Scotland.

Questions? Comments?

If you want more specific recommendations for sources or have any follow-up questions, feel free to ask them here! Also feel free to leave any feedback on the format and so on.

If you like the podcast, please rate and review us on iTunes.

Thanks all!

Previous episode and discussion.

Want to support the Podcast? Help keep history interesting through the AskHistorians Patreon.

6 Answers 2017-10-06

It is often insinuated that native populations in North America lacked an understanding of the "concept of property." How accurate is this?

To me, the reductionist view that native populations (already a generalization) just didn't conceptualize property seems to be rather stereotypical and a way to diminish native populations. Is this accurate?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

When did the Chinese learn that the Earth is round? How?

How well accepted was the round earth view in China?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

Was the 'Scopes monkey trial' just a show trial? Were the two sides truly adversarial? Was there a preexisting relationship between William Jennings Bryan and Clarence Darrow?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

Nowadays, smart people are referred to as an 'Einstein'. Before that, did people say 'He's a Newton' or another famous scientist?

3 Answers 2017-10-06

Why did his duel with Alexander Hamilton end Aaron Burr's career?

I know that Hamilton wasn't exactly popular so why did his duel with Burr cause a lot of grief for Burr?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

After the fall of the Byzantine Empire, how much Byzantine/Roman "nationalism" (for lack of a better word) was there in the region? When did the people living in the region stop thinking of themselves as Byzantines/Romans and start thinking as themselves as Greeks?

I realise that using the term nationalism to describe basically anything before the 17-1800s is rather iffy. I mean how much of a Roman "identitity" or seperatist/restorationist sentiment was there in Greece after the Byzantines fell?

1 Answers 2017-10-06

A few questions about Roman mid-republic 'Polybian' military, as well as the Socii system

I was reading Adrian Goldsworthy's 'The Complete Roman Army' and came across a sentence where he says that in the consular army, there were usually 2 Roman legions and 2 Ala from Socii allies, he says that the Ala usually had the same number of infantrymen, but around 3x as many cavalrymen. This leads me to a few questions.

  1. Why this difference in composition? Was it to provide more discipline for the regular men since they weren't fighting for their own tribe/city-state?

  2. Why were the Socii willing to field disproportionately larger amounts of their wealthier citizens?

  3. Was this composition reflective of a difference in the distribution of wealth in Roman society and that of the Socii, i.e. were there more wealthy people amongst the Socii who could afford their horses, etc.?

  4. Was there a system of dividing up plunder, spoils of war, etc? If so, would it be shared among the Socii as well? What sort of proportions?

  5. From what I recall reading elsewhere, the Socii system persisted until the end of the social wars, whereupon Socii were awarded Roman Citizenship. Is this correct? After that point were they considered 'Romans' in all manners? Was there a period of animosity by 'true' Romans against these states/people from these states? Did 'true' Romans retain any rights not granted to former Socii?

Sorry to ask so many questions at once, I hope I'm not breaking any rules.

1 Answers 2017-10-06

Is there any archaeological evidences of Giants? {REPOST}

Giants like what's the bible and Quran talked about Every time i see for photos about them,i see the usual photoshop images and unverified newspapers like the start of this video https://www.liveleak.com/view?i=0d3_1502618190

1 Answers 2017-10-06

⯇ 3086 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start