I just bought two history books by Plutarch - "Greek Lives" and "Roman Lives: a Selection of Eight Roman Lives" - what is the best approach to reading these histories written almost 2000 years ago?

  • Is there any context that I should know before reading through these books?

  • From what I know, "histories" up to a certain period cared less about accuracy and more about communicating a message about the people they talked about, is that correct, and does that apply to these books?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-12-07

Why did the Japanese think they could win a war with the United States?

I understand the reasons that drove them to do it, like the embargo, need for expansion, cultural drive of superiority, and resources. The attack on Pearl Harbor was planned extraordinarily well, except for the fact that they forgot to hit our oil and that 3 carriers were gone. But an attack like Pearl Harbor would only set us back a few months. I feel like they had to know that

Did Japan really think it was capable of invading the US? Were they hoping for a few land grabs and then a peace treaty? I'm trying to grasp what their end game was in the war. Didn't it turn into defensive war relatively quickly (battle of midway)?

2 Answers 2016-12-07

An allied ww2 vet told me once that if your plane was shot down in the western front (Italy?) it was better to be found by the Luftwaffe than the civilians. Is this true?

1 Answers 2016-12-07

[LHF] Was Alexander the Great Macedonian or Greek?

I hear both, they seem to be confounded. Or I am confounded.

1 Answers 2016-12-07

Have their been any instances of political leaders using their power to add or subtract words from a language?

1 Answers 2016-12-07

Has indoor tobacco smoking damaged the interior of monumental buildings to great extends?

I was watching 'The Crown' on Netflix and there's a lot of indoor smoking of cigarettes/cigars in beautifully decorated mansions, castles, palaces etc that contain decorated rooms that date back hundreds of years. I'm wondering whether smoking has damaged the interior of these monumental buildings by any significant amount, as I'm pretty sure that tobacco smoke can be harmful to for example your walls.

N.B: I'm specifically talking about paintings and other art/forms of decoration that has been damaged.

1 Answers 2016-12-07

How much protection would chainmail give a warrior in the earliest medieval period?

Just to bound the question in time and place, let's say a Saxon in England c. 500 AD or so -- not long after the Roman period, but probably long enough they're making their own mail shirts.

2 Answers 2016-12-07

What was life like in fascist Italy?

2 Answers 2016-12-07

Comparisons Between Theodore Roosevelt's "bully pulpit" approach and Donald Trump's Twitter blasts

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-12-07

In the Bronze and Iron Ages, would a normal person consider the Pantheons of other tribes to be the same as their own (with different names) or physically different? E.g. would a Roman consider Jupiter and Zeus(pater) the same deity? Would a Teuton consider Tiwaz the same as Zeus and Jupiter?

1 Answers 2016-12-07

When hitler came to power when did people begin to realize they fucked up

Learning about Hitler in school and when they said he got elected just wanted to know

thanks,

  • Daniel

1 Answers 2016-12-07

What books would you recommend to a beginner in japanese history?

Hello askhistorians, I've recently taken an interest in japanese history and would like to expand my reading beyond the Wikipedia and Samurai Archives Wiki articles I've read so far. So, what are some good beginner-friendly books about this subject that you would recommend? My main area of interest is pre-Edo japan, especially the Heian and Muromachi periods, but I would gladly read anything about earlier periods as well. I am also very interested in cultural history, so anything focusing on religion, philosophy or art and literature throughout the periods would be nice too. Thanks in advance!

PS: I've done some researching and found some titles like: A History of Japan to 1334 and A History of Japan, 1334-1615 by George Sansom; Japan in the Muromachi Age by John W. Hall and Takeshi Toyoda; and A Companion to Japanese History edited by William M. Tsutsui. Are those any good? Are there better or more up-to-date books out there?

1 Answers 2016-12-07

When did the concept of a fictional canon originate?

I'm referring to works like the Star Trek series, or the Cthulhu Mythos, where consistency within a fictional universe is considered important.

1 Answers 2016-12-07

When did Jews begin to view themselves as a race instead of a community united by a common religion? And was there any particular reason behind d this dramatic change?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-12-07

When and why did Hindus stop eating beef?

Or does this practice date back to Vedic times?

1 Answers 2016-12-07

What could the later Roman emperors have done to prevent the fall of the empire?

If you were an emperor in the late imperial period, what could you have done better? Could a string of gifted emperors restored the empire to its height or was it destined for failure no matter what the emperors did?

1 Answers 2016-12-07

Around which time frame did "graphic" novels such as comic books gain popularity as compared to textual novels?

By graphic novel, I refer to illustrated texts supported by images and visual representation, not necessarily a comic book but rather one which relies on its imagery as much as it's text to convey itself. Also, what would be an example of a prominent comic book, that gained mainstream attention during the time when comic books were relatively unknown or unheard of?

1 Answers 2016-12-07

AMA about Eisenhower at the Dawn of Space, the development of US space policy, and what happened the last time a political outsider was elected to President of the United States

Hi, I'm Dr Mark Shanahan and I'm a lecturer in comparative politics at the University of Reading in England.

My new book (Eisenhower at the Dawn of Space) is out now but my expertise includes the formation of NASA, early space race, and what happened the last time a political outsider was elected to the highest office in the United States.

I talk about politics and history for a hobby and a living and I'm looking forward to talking to you from 7pm GMT - roughly 2.5 hours from now. I've spent the day driving a bus load of my Politics students to and from Wales to meet Members of the Welsh Senedd so please shout if I nod off.

Dr Mark Shanahan, Department of Politics and International Relations, University of Reading, @LeapfrogMark

22 Answers 2016-12-07

What was food like in Imperial China during the latter part of the Qing Empire?

I've read that the Qing Empire was so short of money towards the end that they had to pawn the Guang Xhu Emperor's robes and the Imperial Collection for funds. Did this shortage of funds manifested in the food of the Imperial family and their servants? What other methods did they try to raise money?

1 Answers 2016-12-07

Why did the Vikings bother massacring defenceless monks at places like Lindisfarne?

I've been watching the TV series Vikings recently, and one thing that struck me was the apparent pointlessness of massacring - if the series is accurate - monks who did not put up a fight.

What was the Viking rationale behind this? Did they believe in the honour of killing even non-combatants? Or was it to intimidate the Kingdoms they raided?

1 Answers 2016-12-07

Due to the anniversary, can anyone explain the Japanese reasoning behind launching the Pearl Harbor attacks?

1 Answers 2016-12-07

On Apr 2, 1917, the US declared war on Germany. It declared war on Austria-Hungary on Dec 7, 99 years ago today. Why the long delay? Was there hope that the Central Powers could be divided? And what were US relations with Bulgaria and the Ottomans?

Was the US planning on playing a role as a potential mediator between the other warring nations? I only see declarations of war for Austria-Hungary and Germany.

1 Answers 2016-12-07

After World War I, did the Allied powers ever talk about a break-up of Germany?

Germany wasn't even half a century old in 1918. You could argue that its creation was one of the factors leading to the Great War. Breaking up Germany (and of course Prussia in different parts, like Brandenburg, Silesia, Posen, etc.) would return the equilibrium in Europe to the pre-1871 state. This would have benefited France, the UK and Russia a lot in my opinion.

1 Answers 2016-12-07

I'm a 6th century Saxon wearing chainmail armour. How much defense does it give me?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-12-07

Please help me confirm whether a story of an ancient wall made of cardboard to fool invaders is true!

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-12-07

⯇ 3767 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start