What was the process of the Romans appropriating Hellenic religion and culture, and how did the Greeks respond?

1 Answers 2016-08-02

What would a German ww1 victory have looked like? Was it as scary as a German victory was in ww2?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-08-02

Can anyone recommend me any books on the history of Egyptology?

To be specific, I'm looking for books on the history of the re-discovery of tombs and major monuments over the past few centuries, not books on the ancient history of Egypt itself. Pretty much everyone knows about Howard Carter and King Tut, of course, but I confess I didn't know much more than that; I was at the Fields Museum in Chicago earlier today, and learned about the cache of mummies at Deir el-Bahari, and found it fascinating. I've been looking around for any books that cover this topic as a general overview, and not having a lot of luck, so any recommendations are appreciated - general overview, or a book covering a specific find that you think is interesting. Anything from the finding of the pyramids onward, basically. Thanks much!

1 Answers 2016-08-02

What did the "typical" American accent sound like in the 1800s?

I have always wondered this question.

First I realized that all the founding fathers had British accents, then wondered what the generation or two in America after them sounded like.

I assume the older generation still had a bit of a British accent, and with the mass waves of immigration there was probably a ton of accents in the country. Was there a unique "American accent" at one point in the country's history?

And is the current American Accent just a bastardized version of all the other accents?

2 Answers 2016-08-02

Did ancient/medieval Kings or Queens have military parades as a show of force?

Similar to what occurs now in states such as North Korea?

1 Answers 2016-08-02

I'm a rural Catholic priest in England at the time of Henry VIII's break from Rome, do I know I suddenly belong to the Anglican Church and not the Catholic Church? How long before I learn this information? What ways might I react?

6 Answers 2016-08-02

Slavery numbers in America

Someone told me today that roughly 20M slaves were brought into New Orleans, but only about 500,000 were brought into America and that the rest were sent to South America and the Caribbean. Is this true?

1 Answers 2016-08-02

Imperial China is often called isolationist or inward-looking, and yet the Han Chinese diaspora appear to be very successful immigrants to whatever nation they move to. What were the reasons for such a major cultural shift?

A lot of popular history, and even my own undergraduate courses twenty years ago strongly imply the Han Chinese culture was very inward-looking, largely unconcerned with other cultures except to keep invaders at bay. When the Chinese Empire expanded its territory, it was mainly during the rule of non-Han dynasties like the Yuan and Qing (Tang being the notable exception). Han dynasties seemed content to rule over a mostly Han populace within the borders originally united by the Qin/Han dynasties. This line of thinking will bring up events like the Ming dynasty court ending Zheng He's far-reaching expeditions as examples of this mindset.

However, in the last century and a half, Han Chinese have emigrated to almost every corner of the globe, and appear to be successful almost every where they settle. Chinatowns are found in major cities all around the world, many small business are owned and operated by Han Chinese, and later-generation immigrants excel in higher education and professional vocations. At least, this is the popular perception; e.g. the "model minority".

What caused this cultural shift from isolationism to successful integration?

2 Answers 2016-08-02

What punishment would the American founding fathers have received had they been captured by the British?

Hello all! In the timeless film National Treasure, Nicolas Cage's character mentions that the founding fathers were committing high treason against the british crown, and had they been caught, they would have been "hanged, beheaded, drawn and quartered and, my personal favorite, had their entrails cut out and burned!" is this accurate? Would the founding fathers have received such a brutal execution, or even capital punishment in the first place?

2 Answers 2016-08-02

Why did many academics deny the Cambodian genocide in the 70's and 80's?

Several prominent Southeast Asian academics during that time downplayed or denied the Cambodian genocides as exaggerated and blown out of proportion by the foreign press and Cambodian refugees. Gareth Porter, Noam Chomsky, George Kavin, and other respected academics of Southeast Asian history and more publicly defended the Khmer Rouge .

Were the eyewitness accounts really that unconvincing and contradictory? It seems obvious now that the Khmer Rouge was behind several mass killings and atrocities in Cambodia; what motivated the large amount of skepticism?

1 Answers 2016-08-02

Do all Black people originate from Africa?

Sorry if this is a stupid question but I can't really find the answer with google. What I want to know if there are communities of people with black/dark skin that did not originally come from Africa via immigration, slave trading, or human trafficking.

Sorry if this isn't the right subreddit

1 Answers 2016-08-01

How to catch up with the latest historiography

As a lay historian who has only taken one class in history at the college level, I find that not only am I not really aware of the latest developments or seminal works in the fields I'm interested in (Mostly Ancient Mediterranean Military history and Byzantine history), I don't really know where to look. I'm aware of databases like JSTOR, but I don't really have the background knowledge necessary to search for and evaluate sources with any kind of ease. In general, how do you recommend those of us without formal education in the field keep abrest of the important works in the field, and specifically, what are some books/journals that everyone in my field of interest should be reading or following. (Mostly talking about secondary sources here, but if there's a primary source you think might be obscure enough that I haven't heard of it, feel free to recommend away) The second half of the question is more relevant for the Byzantine history part of my interests, as the reading list provided is a bit spare.

2 Answers 2016-08-01

WWII Nazi Artifact Identification

My grandfather fought in WWII for the U.S. After he died we found a collection of things he picked up during the war. I would like to know more about his book of his I found. It seems like some kind of Hitler biography. The photos are all pasted in, on real photo paper, not printed in the book itself. Any ideas of what I'm looking at, and possibly what it's worth? photos of the book

1 Answers 2016-08-01

What are the primary sources for the existence of historical figures in Roman times?

Despite the context I'm about to give, this really is a historical question and not a religious one: I sometimes find myself in debates about the historicity of Jesus. There is an argument against the historicity of Jesus based on the sparse-to-non-existent (depending on what sources you accept) contemporary mentions of him. The counter-argument is that there is only sparse-to-nonexistent contemporary evidence of any historical figure going that far back. This seemed implausible to me, but I thought I would ask the pros: what are the primary sources for this historicity of people in Roman times?

1 Answers 2016-08-01

When did mirrors become a household item? How long has the average person known what their own face looks like?

1 Answers 2016-08-01

In "1493" Mann states Japanese samurai helped protect silver shipments from highwaymen near Acapulco in the 1600s. Is there any evidence to support this story?

The story in question is on page 414.

I admit, I would love to watch a movie about 17th century samurai protecting silver caravans through the mountains of Mexico, but I'm having a devil of a time verifying Mann's claims here. Demographically, we know Eastern Asian migrants added to the growing multicultural landscape of post-contact Mexico, but the samurai claim seems too good to be true. I wondered if one of our Mexican or Asian specialists can shed light on the story, and if it has any basis in fact.

Are there stories of Asian mercenaries fighting in the wars of conquest in the Americas? Stepping back even further, where did the earliest Asian migrants to the Americas come from, and where did they settle in this New World?

Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2016-08-01

During the middle ages, how likely was a charging knight to be killed or seriously injured by the fall if his horse was shot out from under him?

A lot of us are probably familiar with this scene from Lord of the Rings where horses are struck by arrows and flip their riders at high speed. But in Roger Williams' Brief Discourse on War he claimed that armored horsemen charging into a hail arrows on unarmored horses would have no worry about being killed, only captured if his horse is killed. I realize that he is heavily biased against the effectiveness of archers though, so how common really were injuries due to a knight falling off his horse? Did a knight's armor really protect that well against a concussion or a broken neck?

1 Answers 2016-08-01

Where can I read the full translated writings of Ahmad Ibn Fadlan?

The only thing I can find is the small excerpts about the Vikings and Rus but did he write more about his travels?

I'm really interested in reading about his entire travel through europe from start to finish.

1 Answers 2016-08-01

Did the USSR fail to support the Warsaw Uprising on purpose, in order to let the Polish rebels be crushed by the Nazis?

Although the Uprising was timed to coincide with the Rev Army's advance toward the city, the Red Army suddenly stopped short during the critical moments, and would not allow either British or American air support to use its airfields in support of the Uprising. Was this a purposeful effort on the part of the USSR to see Poland crushed? If so, why did they support the Uprising in the first place?

3 Answers 2016-08-01

What would an ancient Greek prayer sound like?

I understand that the main ceremonies in Greek temples were animal sacrifice. What would be an example of a prayer done during one of these sacrifices? I am also curious as to what other purposes a temple would serve.

1 Answers 2016-08-01

Friends and I were talking about our various sports injuries in the past, and it occurred to me, what happened to you if lived in Rome during the Roman empire and you tore your meniscus or ACL, or Constantinople in the Byzantine empire, or Venice, etc. etc.

I know some basics, such that Roman combat medicine was actually pretty effective, and things like that. But it's hard to find information on the medical procedures we take for granted these days. A friend of mine tore his miniscus and is having a surgery to remove some of the scarred tissue so that it can heal, but that type of surgery is a relatively new procedure, as is a lot of our current sports medicine. So what happened earlier in history when you got "sports injuries" in the past, such as torn ACLs and MCLs, or other stuff like that where it can take you up to a year to heal even after surgery?

1 Answers 2016-08-01

What do we really know about Vlad the Impaler?

Vlad the Impaler is a notorious person, for obvious reasons—there are many primary sources describing how he brutally killed tens of thousands of turks and ottomans during his reign. However, I've been trying to separate fact vs myth about the person, notably whether he distinguished between enemy combatants (men) and women/children. In particular, wikipedia cites a passage from german pamphlet written in 1521: "He roasted children and forced their mother to eat them. He cut the breasts from the women and force their husband to eat them. Finally he impaled them all."

Is this accurate? Did he engage in forced cannibalism, of torturing women and children in this manner? Are there any primary sources for this? If so, is there any indication of how prevalent this practice was or why he did it? I suppose it could be considered a type of total war, albeit a particularly brutal and psychological version.

Anyway, I'd appreciate any and all insight or material that y'all can provide.

1 Answers 2016-08-01

If I joined the US army at the outbreak of World War 2, how was it decided which division I would be assigned to?

If I joined the US army at the outbreak of World War 2, how was it decided which division I would be assigned to? I assume I wouldn't get a choice in which division I join, So who decided? was it based on location? and as a small follow up, were soldiers that enlisted in groups split up or would they be assigned to the same unit?

1 Answers 2016-08-01

Who was the Marcus Aurelius mentioned in the preface of Vitruvius' De Architectura?

Obviously he wasn't the emperor, as the work was written under Augustus. Do we know much about this individual? Was there any relation to Antoninus?

1 Answers 2016-08-01

Boxing History: I'm doing research for a historical Boxing film (late 19th century - 1950s) and I'm looking for video and photo resources that depict prominent boxing styles and emerging techniques. Any leads to archives of teaching videos or helpful organizations would be greatly appreciated!

My research is focused on the heavyweight classes and primarily on prominent fighters in the U.S and U.K.

Names of pioneering technical fighters are also welcomed!

I thought this article was fantastic, but I need more videos and photos. http://coxscorner.tripod.com/hunnicut1.html

Thank you!

1 Answers 2016-08-01

⯇ 4073 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start