In 1871, the British Army, which had been using breechloading field artillery since 1859, reverted to using muzzle-loaders. What lay behind this change, especially given the demonstrated effectiveness of Prussian breechloading guns in the Franco-Prussian War the year before?

1 Answers 2021-11-26

How did Ancient Greek Texts or Books look like

I recently found a document which states that in ancient Hellas only uppercase letters were used and that the lowercase letters were only developed later on in monasteries. So if I stumbled across Plato's Apology in the fourth century b.c. what would the thing have looked like? A scroll with only uppercase letters?

1 Answers 2021-11-26

Careers in Paleontology

So I've been thinking whenever people ask me what I want to be I don't have a definitive answer. I always say something to do with History more specifically Paleontology But further, than that I have no answer. I know I want to work with dinosaurs but I do not know the options. Btw this is just so I can further my knowledge in the field I'm not choosing a career.

1 Answers 2021-11-26

How much of a return on investments would traders who travelled to Asia in the 17th Century expect?

I'm sure it varies wildly depending on context, but in general I can imagine investing in long distance trade between Europe and the eastern indies in the 17th Century would have been extremely costly and risky, since it took a lot of time to travel around Africa and the possibility of a shipwreck was very real.
So, as a very general ballpark, how much would an investor expect to gain from such an investment to make it worth the risk? Would it be 120% of the gold they spent? 200%? 1000%? Does it even make sense to pose the question in these terms, or were their economic systems too different to compare?

1 Answers 2021-11-26

Harvey Milk was the first openly gay elected official in the history of California. What ideologies or policies did he support? Why did he feud with the local LGBT political group, the Alice B. Toklas LGBT Democratic Club?

1 Answers 2021-11-26

What year did Plato think it was?

According to our modern calendar, Plato lived between 428-348 BCE. But, the Gregorian calendar didn't show up till much later.

What year did Plato think it was? What was being used before Christ came along?

1 Answers 2021-11-26

The USSR economy

Hello all, my question is about the USSR’s economic system how it worked in the beginning and in the end, what they did right and what they did wrong. I’ve heard it said that they were one of the biggest economies and that they lifted the most people out of poverty so any reading I can do on the subject is most welcome! Thank you

1 Answers 2021-11-26

How powerful was the hittite empire during it's final years, around the bronze age collapse?

1 Answers 2021-11-26

History Matters Rome and China

https://youtu.be/5e8Yde6qXrI How accurate is this video in some of its more questionable statements? It claims the Romans saw China as "utterly inferior", "a hostile empire even if it was a world away" and that "they saw it as Rome's eventual destiny to conquer China". How true is this? They have sources in the description but no page number or such listed. I can't find anything that indicates such a negative view from the Romans.

1 Answers 2021-11-26

What Native American tribes were active in the areas Vikings made landfall?

Specifically I want to know who they might have been and what their languages and customs were. How they lived. How they worked. How they hunted. What tools they used.

More generally I'd like to know where in the US and Canada these encounters might have taken place. What years they might have happened. How the encounters might have gone down.

Thank you for your time.

1 Answers 2021-11-26

How much of the widespread poverty throughout the USSR was real, and how much was western propaganda?

I feel like we have lost a lot of nuances discussing the USSR. But based on what several people from ex soviet countries have told me, the assuption that practically everyone was living in poverty at the time isn't really correct. Where some soviet countries significantly better (or worse) than others?

1 Answers 2021-11-25

Were ancient libraries public?

For example, could a regular citizen in Alexandria just walk into the library and take out some scrolls to study or were libraries reserved only for certain classes of people?

edit: also, could those people permitted at the libraries remove materials and take it home with them or were the scrolls only available for use on the library?

1 Answers 2021-11-25

History of the Western University System. (Thursday Reading & Recommendations)

I have been trying to find texts concerning the Western university system. I am interested all of it from ~1100AD, but in particular the modern period from about 1800 till today. I am trying to rationalise how we ended up with what we presently have. I also realise even this time span can be split into different periods. Using Google is hopeless as using search terms like 'history of universities' just gives university departments. The few texts I have read all seem to contradict each other. Any help will be greatly appreciated.

(Every post I post here gets deleted, just hope this one makes it. Interpreting rules isn't my strong point)

2 Answers 2021-11-25

Lectures on youtube about WW1

I really liked Stephen Kotkin's lectures on Stalin, they are amazing. Are there any lectures like his, that are very entertaining and interesting about WW1 or perhaps the aftermath?

2 Answers 2021-11-25

I don't know much about Native American history myself, so fill me in. Is there a reason why Trail of Tears caused by Andrew Jackson gets more scrutiny than the Long Walk of the Navajo caused by Abraham Lincoln?

Both seem to be tragedies that surround Native Americans, so why is Jackson getting more hate for it than Lincoln does?

2 Answers 2021-11-25

How did tanks reach the shore in the Moroccan landings of operation Torch in 1942?

I have read that in the Algerian landings, a few early British LSTs were used. LSTs, Landing Ships, Tank, were typically 4-5,000 ton ocean going vessels with front ramps for unloading heavy vehicles directly onto a beach.

The Western task force apparently didn't have any LSTs. But accounts I have read mention tank battles fought before the French surrender. How did the U.S. navy get those tanks ashore? Were they all landed at piers or what?

I am particularly interested in the Port Lyautey landings. The tank skirmish in this area seems to have only involved Stuart light tanks, not Shermans. Did the navy have a landing craft that could carry a Stuart but not the heavier Sherman?

My main source for what I know about Torch is Atkinson's An Army at Dawn, but it was a library book I read maybe a year ago, and don't have in front of me now.

1 Answers 2021-11-25

The Inca were famous for their qullqas storehouses filled with enough food to see their subjects through years of famine. Were such vast food reserves particularly notable in the premodern world? Did European or Asian civilizations manage a similarly effective famine-fighting strategy?

In the Mantaro Valley, one of the largest fertile growing regions of the Inca Empire, archeologists have found 2,573 qullqas (storehouses). These could hold 170,000 square meters of goods. Some of this was for non-food storage, but a ton of it was dried potatoes, quinoa, etc. When the Spanish showed up, the Inca equipped and fed a 35,000 man army from the storehouses around the Mantaro Valley.

But these qullqas were spread around the empire, and other areas stored corn, seaweed, dried fish, etc.

I can't think of another civilization that had such huge reserves on hand to deal with emergencies. When I think of medieval Europe, famine and starvation seem to pop up every few years.

So was this unique? Did anyone else prepare for famines on this scale?

1 Answers 2021-11-25

What was the electoral system of the USSR under Stalin? Could it ever be called Democratic?

I’ve recently fallen into a rabbit hole of debate over the Democratic legitimacy of the soviet government, especially during the reign of Stalin.

Some love to argue that the USSR at this time was actually perfectly Democratic and Stalin was beholden to the will of the people and workers via a Democratic electoral process.

I would love to know what the system of distributing power actually was and if Stalin could have have been called a Democratic ruler.

From what I’ve seen, these people argue that citizens could elect fellow soviet members to the supreme soviet, but (if this is true) how much power did the standard citizen actually have?

Thank you

1 Answers 2021-11-25

Was Pumpkin Pie a symbol of abolition during the American Civil War?

A post has gone semi-viral on Twitter asserting that "Pumpkin pie became a popular dish during Civil War-era celebrations of Thanksgiving because pumpkins were grown on small farms, not plantations, making the pie a symbol of abolitionist virtue."

(Link to the Twitter claim: https://twitter.com/danielsilliman/status/1463570172808208387?s=20))

In the last handful of years, I've seen a lot of claims pertaining to the history of transatlantic slavery, and American slave culture, go viral on social media. In my experience, they end up getting widely promoted by well-meaning people until they become social media urban legends that...turn out to be either not true at all or grossly overstated/misrepresented.

So I'm wondering about this one. Is it true that pumpkin pie became associated with abolitionism? I'm also curious : if it is actually true, does that mean that pumpkins also become associated with class? i.e. working class subsistence farms versus gentleman farming of the aristocracy?

Related: If this was actually true of CWA-era Thanksgiving observations, when did pumpkin pie become flattened into a generalized American tradition? Is there kind of literature available on this?

Thanks in advance, and Happy Thanksgiving to those who celebrate it! (Happy Thursday to everyone else!)

1 Answers 2021-11-25

Why do some gun barrels have flared muzzles?

For example, on bofors anti aircraft guns and some japanese ww2 machine guns I've seen, the barrel widens out slightly at the muzzle. Whar's the purpose of it and why don't all gun barrels have it?

1 Answers 2021-11-25

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | November 25, 2021

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

5 Answers 2021-11-25

Could US forced have won the Pacific War before the end of the European front in 1945?

1 Answers 2021-11-25

Why did cricket never catch on in the US?

Ditto for rugby and soccer.

1 Answers 2021-11-25

If raw milk is so dangerous, how come people drank it and ate dairy before pasteurization was invented in the 19th century?

Between 1860 and the domestication of cows, sheep and goats, people had to handle raw milk and dairy made from it. How come they didn't get terrible infections from it?

2 Answers 2021-11-25

The Mexican Constitution states that any slave who enters Mexican territory is automatically free and a Mexican citizen. Was this ever relevant?

Mexico could declare escaped slaves were free all we wanted, that doesn't mean slavers would care, so I wonder, was there ever some sort of legal battle concerning this law?

I wonder if any point something like this happened:

A slave escapes into Mexico but is then found by USA authorities and brought back to the USA by force. However this person explains that since they entered Mexican territory before being captured again they are now free and a Mexican citizen, so capturing him is now illegal. Such a situation would have created the question of how the laws from other countries concerning slavery would affect slavery in the USA

1 Answers 2021-11-25

449 / 7255

Back to start