So, what is the latest opinion among historians about Nicholas II, last tsar of Russia?

So, I've been watching recently some documentaries about Nicholas II, the last tsar of Russia, and all in all this guy as his grandfather seems among the most honest and progressive leader Russia had.

While many of his policies could be considered anachronistic, it has to be said that the man really loved Russia and its people. He not only abdicated but he didn't even flee Russia after the revolution.

His reign seems a succession of very bad luck and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khodynka_Tragedy wrong decisions, but all in all Nicholas II seems to be one of the few Russian leaders that did really care about Russia and Russians. He actively promoted peace in Europe and was nominated for the Peace Nobel prize for his efforts in Hague and he actively pursued the development of Russia's far east.

He can definitely be called out for being often not competent enough to take the right decisions and too stubborn aswell.

What's your opinion?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

How does History differ from Anthropology and Archaeology from an academic point of view?

Four years ago my dream of finding the mythical city of Raphta on the East African coast was dashed upon reading the brochure from the University of Dar es Salaam. It basically said one needed a background of science in high school to be eligible to join their Bachelor of 'Arts' in Archaeology program, effectively dealing a crushing blow to me having a background of arts from high school in History, Geography and Language. So now i can ask how do History, Anthropology and Archaeology differ and why does one need a background in science to study Archaeology?

4 Answers 2016-01-26

Early States of Kiev and Moscow

I'm doing an oral presentation on the early russian states of Kiev and Moscow. Looking for primary sources to immerse my audience in the time period. Anything from the cities' foundation, to the rise of the Czars. Any suggestions would be great! thanks guys! P.S. Mongols always make presentations more interesting!

3 Answers 2016-01-26

[Meta] "History buff" historians, how did you get interested in your favorite topic or era?

To be clear, the distinction I want to draw is NOT between flair and not-yet-flaired. I'm interested in hearing from people who have no formal training in history or a closely-related field, at any level (including undergraduate or career-only, well, beyond required intro classes), and don't plan on it.

If you are interested in "history in general," I'd love to know what draws you to the past and especially to hang out in this sub.

Thanks!

49 Answers 2016-01-26

When the Steller's sea cow was discovered in 1741, it was hunted to extinction by sailors just 30 years after its discovery. Why didn't this happen to Manatees or Dugongs?

More specifically, the Steller's Sea cow was discovered in the North Pacific, near Alaska.

EDIT: Also, what was European contact like, in the area, where the Steller's sea cow was discovered? (Discoveries, major events, settlements etc.)

EDIT: Wow! So many upvotes! Was surprised this question would have so many people interested in it. :D

2 Answers 2016-01-26

How was the Roman Empire's Territory organised and governed?

Okay so it that is a really broad and ambiguous question so I'll do my best to fine-tune it here. This seems like a question that would already have been asked, but I couldn't see it so I'm asking it. If you refer me to another post or website, could you make sure it covers the specific questions I ask below, thanks.

Looking on a map, the Roman Empire looks like a single entity, but I at least know it wasn't. I am wondering how the territory within the Empire was organised and governed. As far as I know there was either directly governed imperial territory and then client states that payed tribute or were not directly governed by Rome. Is this right?

My starting point is this map. It shows Roman provinces and then only a few client states on the edges of the empire. Was all the territory in these provinces controlled directly by Rome and considered 'Roman' territory? Or were there areas within these provinces that still had some autonomy and independence?

Thanks guys

1 Answers 2016-01-26

In the days when the average Life expectancy rate was 25, what factors led to some living to a ripe old age?

Wealth? Physical Exertions? Living Conditions?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

Would any of you know what country these gentlemen are from?

Thanks in advance! http://imgur.com/QmaZM1J

1 Answers 2016-01-26

Epirot or Epirote?

Is it Epirot or Epirote for someone from Epirus? I've seen it both ways but I'm not sure if one was more the 19th Century way of spelling things.

1 Answers 2016-01-26

Did Elizabethan theatres allow women to participate in any part of the off stage production?

I understand that women weren't allowed to perform on the Elizabethan stage, but I have always wondered whether there were any instances of women participating in other areas such as costume design, financing or promotion.

1 Answers 2016-01-26

Why do wizards wear robes and pointy hats?

When I Google Image search "wizard" (http://imgur.com/ssldJUy), most of the figures are dressed in blue or purple robes, often with stars, and usually with a matching pointy hat. Have wizards always been depicted this way? How did this tradition get started?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

Blind European King with Flail

One of my teachers told me a story of a European king or Lord or something who was blind. He would ride into battle, swinging his flail around blindly, while a squire would lead his horse forwards. The horse was trained to keep its head perfectly straight, otherwise the flail would hit it. He had multiple horses at ready at the edge of the battlefield incase his horse was taken out by the enemy, or if he took it out with his flail. At the end of the battle, the enemy King found his body, dead, surrounded by bodies he had killed. The King, with incredible respect towards the blind king/lord/guy, took his coat-of-arms as his own. This story sounds awesome, but a bit too amazing that I've never heard it from anywhere else. There's also a lot of stuff that seems, odd. For example, why did no archers shoot at him, being the general. Or how did he get back on a horse being blind and in a battlefield? The teacher is a member of HEMA and has a lot of experience under his belt (was a 'King' at one point), but is this story true?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

How did the idea of an Indonesian nation come about?

Just from what I know from history Indonesia has not existed for very long as a unified state. As far as I know there was not any unified language or shared cultural identification until recently. The closest historical counterpart I know of would be the borders of Majapahit. Did the conception of modern unified Indonesia as one nation come from these Majapahit borders, or from some other source?

2 Answers 2016-01-26

Did all colonialists treat their subjects the same way?

I'm under the general understanding that most colonists didn't treat their subjects very well, and by that I mean a huge disregard for human rights. In the sense that colonists are the reason there are so few aboriginal people in North America and Australia. Colonialism is also the reason why Japan has had a hard time dealing with its past until making recent diplomatic progress with South Korea last month on the subject of comfort women.

What about the British? I'm under the general understanding that it was much better to have been living in Hong Kong than in Mainland China at seemingly any time during the last 100 years, other than during wars of course.

So, did all colonialists treat their subjects badly? Did some simply "merely" take away a peoples rights to self-govern? I'm thinking mostly about the 1800-1940's period.

2 Answers 2016-01-26

In WWII, were captured German Army, Navy, Air Force, Waffen-SS and Gestapo personnel put in the same POW camps or were they segregated?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

Did Hitler kill himself in his bunker, and if so what became of his remains? (a bit more detail inside)

Without sounding like a conspiracy nut, I just want to ask the following question: is there any hard evidence to corroborate any of the many reports of what happened to Hitler or his remains?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

Franklin Delano Roosevelt pursued policies of economic stimulus that would today be considered socialistic, while also recognizing the legitimacy of the Soviet government and allying with Russia in World War 2. How did he avoid accusations of being a communist?

Throughout his eight years as president, conservative detractors have accused Barack Obama of being a socialist due the passage of the Affordable Care Act, a staunchly private-sector piece of legislation that did not include any legitimately socialized healthcare.

Franklin Roosevelt's policies would be almost unthinkable today, especially his massive tax increases and major public works projects to stimulate the depressed economy. These policies are certainly much more "socialist" than any that Obama has seen through, and the decision to affirm the legitimacy of the Soviet government would also be quite radical today. Was FDR considered a "closet communist" by many 1930s conservatives?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

Dalmatia and the break up of Yugoslavia

How did Dalmatia, in particular the islands such as Hvar and Vis but Dalmatia broadly, experience the break up of Yugoslavia and the subsequent wars. Was there much conflict over borders, were the islands insulated from the conflict, was there much of a population mix outside the border regions..?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

What was the population of Gaul before the Roman conquest?

3 Answers 2016-01-26

Today, My Prof Emphasized that the debate over Slavery was Only a small part of the Secession and reasoning for the American Civil War. Is He Accurate in Any Way?

2 Answers 2016-01-26

Western pirates hoisted the Jolly Roger. Were there similarly traditional pirate flags used by pirates of other cultures?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

Why did "Roe v. Wade" become synonymous with abortion law in the US rather than "Doe v. Bolton"?

As far as I can tell, they are essentially the same case, set the same legal precedent, and were even decided on the same day. So why is one case cited while the other is not?

2 Answers 2016-01-26

Edward II and Piers Gaveston compared to Henry II and Thomas Beckett

I have been reading Dan Jones' books about the Plantagenet kings and queens of England as well as watching various documentaries on Youtube since this is something I knew almost absolutely nothing about -- being an American from the public school system the extent of my knowledge was that William the Conqueror conquered England, King John signed the Magna Carta, Henry VIII killed all his wives, and Richard the Lionheart was a crusader.

Dan Jones and others cover the relationship between Henry II and his chief aide Thomas Beckett who was not from the nobility but who was basically made one of the most powerful men in the kingdom until he joined the church and the two had their big falling out.

Later, Jones covers Edward II. He suggests or implies that the problem Edward II faced was that Piers Gaveston was an outside made too powerful and too close to the king. The nobility grew to resent this relationship. (With the same being said for Despenser) However, it seemed to be a fairly similar relationship to Henry II and Beckett.

Jones addresses the possibility of their being some sexual dynamic to Edward II and Gaveston, but I am skeptical that this was the major cause for the strife during Edward II's reign. I understand that the allegations arose years later and were not contemporary, and it also seems strange that the greatest critics of the king did not have use his sexuality to attack him politically when had there been any substance to these claims.

TL;DR: What, if anything, was the major differences between Thomas Beckett, a commoner and favorite of the king with inordinate power compared to his class and Piers Gaveston?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

What kind of weapons did the ottoman empire use during WW1?

I heard that the ottoman empire was the 'sick man of europe' since the early 19th century. Did they produce any of their own weapons for WW1? If not, did they purchase weapons? Or were they very unmodernized compared to other nations?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

Did an army of wolves really attack Paris in 1450?

I was reading Braudel's Structure of Everyday life and there is a passage describing an army of wolves that took over the city. I think this wiki page describes it too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolves_of_Paris . I'm just wondering if there's any more details I can find about this? Was this sort of massive wolf attack common? Could this story be any more cool?

1 Answers 2016-01-26

4588 / 7255

Back to start