In the time of the fall of the Roman Empire, how did the invaders treat already present buildings? How long did it take to do a complete takeover of the Empire and lastly, what were the "true" last remnants of the Western Roman Empire?

By "true last remnants" I mean the last true Roman citizens and towns to get captured.

2 Answers 2015-09-12

It seems like a fair amount of sieges ended when the attackers scaled the walls and opened the main gate from the inside, or through treachery that achieves the same. Did defenders ever take measures to prevent gates from being opened from the inside during sieges?

4 Answers 2015-09-12

History Teacher Needs Help

Hello AskHistorians, I've recently taken a position teaching full time U.S. History and after getting through last year as a part time U.S. teacher, I'd really like to step my game up and really take a step forward with my content base. I've already read both of the textbooks and any AP book I can get my hands on to increase my base but these are all generally related to testing. I finished Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States this summer but I'd really like to find more books or articles that I can read and prep with. I've planned on using the Popular Questions (FAQ) that relates to the course content I'm teaching, I just would rather take the time to learn the answers that you all have instead of "borrow" the ideas on those questions.

Also not sure if this is the correct subreddit, I tried looking at American History but that sub is practically dead.

Thank you for any help you may be able to offer.

EDIT: Thank you everyone! I'll start checking off these books one at a time, very grateful for the amazing response!

4 Answers 2015-09-12

How did English evolve?

How did English go from "þes sy englisc" to "This is English"? Where did the extra characters go? How did the words change?

I understand it wasn't instant, but what caused this huge change?

3 Answers 2015-09-12

Was ale/beer carbonated before the 20th century? If so, how did they do it? How far back does carbonated beer (or other spirits, like champagne) go?

2 Answers 2015-09-12

Vikings in Australia?

I found this article. I can't find any good references. Is this confirmed or is it a hoax?

http://worldnewsdailyreport.com/australia-archaeologists-unearth-ruins-of-viking-trade-center/

1 Answers 2015-09-12

What is the evidence that Adolf Hitler disliked Jews?

Throwaway account because this is such a touchy topic.

Pretty much what's in the title. I understand that certain men around him, like Goebbels, had made anti-Jewish expressions, but I'm interested in the primary sources that made the world realize Adolf Hitler himself was against Jews.

1 Answers 2015-09-12

Did Sparta ever have a realistic chance of regaining relevancy post-Leuctra?

2 Answers 2015-09-12

Was the perception of malaria as a serious threat in the U.S. during the first half of the 20th c. overblown?

This Disney video, which was apparently commissioned by the federal government, certainly implies that malaria was a major concern. The CDC's website has a brief writeup that includes some statistics, but I can't tell how serious the problem actually was from their information.

Was the apparent concern justified as far as historians can tell or was it just overblown? And if it wasn't a real problem, did officials genuinely believe that it might become one or has there been speculation about what ulterior motives might have played a part?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2015-09-12

There seem any number of historical men who are often assumed or said to have been gay. There seem remarkably few women who are popularly supposed to have been gay. Is there a reason for this beyond "there are just more famous males in history than famous females"?

The only woman I can think of off the top of my head who's popularly supposed to have been gay is Queen Anne of the United Kingdom.

My wife suspects this is simply because there are massively more famous male historical figures than female, more "great people" to "claim" as it were. But is there more to it than that? I mean, never-married, strong female Elizabeth I would seem a good candidate for such a debate, but I rarely see it mooted.

7 Answers 2015-09-12

Can anyone translate this receipt?

I was given a slip of paper and was told that it was a receipt from the 13 or 1400s, I was hoping someone might be able to tell me what it says and what it's significance would have been.

Image

4 Answers 2015-09-12

What where the effects of Caracalla's edict of citizenship on the legions and the auxilia?

Before the Constitutio Antoniniana, legionaries were recruited from citizens and auxiliaries were recruited from non-citizens, but that policy must have stopped after citizenship became universal. What exactly happened to the legions and the auxilia, and how did recruitment change afterwards?

1 Answers 2015-09-12

Can anyone help me understand presentism and morality?

Howdy folks,

So, when i was searching the sidebar before asking this question, i found this in relation to the concept of presentism:

Academic rigor is a slipping in this sub, and will be addressed. For those of you who may not understand. If you want to criticize Churchill, Gandhi, Columbus, Caesar, George Washington on moral issues, the decisions they made, and why they made them, you must consider what they knew, when they knew it, and why it was that way. Don't criticize Columbus for human rights concepts that wouldn't exist for another 250 years. Don't get upset at Gandhi for doing something that was perfectly normal culturally for him. Don't criticize Churchill for acting completely within the Victorian value system he was raised in.

This concept confuses me. How do historians avoid excusing the immoral actions of people in the past; to take the examples of Churchill and Washington, there were people saying that colonialism was wrong and that Bengal should be given food, and that slavery was wrong and the Natives were humans whilst they were alive. Yet the concept presented above seems to excuse their actions on the grounds that they didn't know any better, an idea i have difficulty squaring with the existence of alternative viewpoints during their eras. People were telling them this was wrong but they didn't listen.

What i'm driving at here is to what extent to historical personalities enjoy 'the benefit of the past' when we come to judge their actions and deeds? Why do we give the guys named in the quote a pass but not, say, Stalin or Mussolini?

Help me out here?

6 Answers 2015-09-12

What is the oldest joke in History that we know of?

1 Answers 2015-09-12

How accurate is Ben Carsons assessment of world history?

1 Answers 2015-09-12

Where did the association of pink for girls and blue for boys come from?

My daughter asked this today are a part of a larger discussion about gender stereotypes. Anyone have insight?

3 Answers 2015-09-12

During my last hike in the French alps I found seashells, now I know this is because of plate tectonics, but what did people think about the origin of these seashells in the mountains before plate tectonics were known?

1 Answers 2015-09-12

Why did the North go to war during the American Civil War?

I have seen a lot of discussion about causes of the Civil War. Usually talking about slavery, states rights, and things like that. But almost always, people are just talking about the reasons why the South was willing to go to war. These reasons don't fully explain the North's position.

To simply say that the war was "about slavery" would give one this flowery view that the white people of the North loved blacks so much that they were willing to go to war and die just so that the blacks wouldn't have to be slaves anymore. And I don't buy that for one moment. So what were the North's REAL motivations?

I've heard that the North just wanted to protect the union. But why was that so important to them? Why was it so important that they were willing to send their people to fight?

Could it also have been something similar to the wars that we have today, where the leaders simply tell the people that they are fighting for other people's freedom, but they are actually fighting to give more wealth and power to those in charge?

2 Answers 2015-09-12

My dad carried this photo in his wallet for years. Can anyone give me some context for its origins? Link in post.

Dad died three years ago. He was 80; and carried this photo in his wallet since we don't know when. Can anyone here help give us some context for it? He was born in 1932 in Spain's Basque Country. He never served in the Spanish or French militaries so we know he's not in it.

http://imgur.com/CnYmHuu

2 Answers 2015-09-12

In the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, did the Japanese planes approach the coast from over the Pacific, or over land?

1 Answers 2015-09-12

Biblical scriptures were altered by the Council Of Nicea, is there any evidence that other spiritual scriptures from Buddhism, Islam or Hinduism were also altered at some point ?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-09-12

For French folks: how is the Hundred Years War taught and remembered in France?

I'm a Brit. Understandably Agincourt is spoken of in legendary, almost mystical terms in the UK (on the same level as the Battle of Britain). But I wonder how it is for Frenchmen? Is the focus mostly on Joan of Arc and the final years of the war (a typical English education never really mentions what happened at the war's end--which I suppose is because "we" lost)? How do the French feel about Agincourt or Crécy?

1 Answers 2015-09-12

AskHistorians Podcast 045 - Regency Era Fashion

Episode 45 is up!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make /r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forum on the internet. You can subscribe to us via iTunes, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube. You can also catch the latest episodes on SoundCloud. If there is another index you'd like the cast listed on, let me know!

This Episode:

/u/ChocolatePot discusses clothing and the fashion scene in late 18th and early 19th Century France and England. Covering everything from links to the philosophy of Rousseau to nascent fashion magazines, this episode also examines how clothing and fashion fit into the overall discipline of history.

If you want more specific recommendations for sources or have any follow-up questions, feel free to ask them here! Also feel free to leave any feedback on the format and so on.

If you like the podcast, please rate and review us on iTunes.

Thanks all!

Coming up next fortnight: /u/kittydentures continues our discussion of fashion in this period, as we delve deeper into the scandalous Chemise a la Reine before discussing issues of historical costuming.

Previous Episodes and Discussion

2 Answers 2015-09-12

How did aircraft carriers continue to launch planes after their runways were damaged by bombs or kamikaze pilots?

Did they do quick repairs and patchwork to get back in the fight if the damage was sizable enough or would it have to be repaired at a dock? I saw a video of a carrier that appeared to have a roughly 10 foot wide hole in the middle of the launch deck and it got me curious.

2 Answers 2015-09-12

Any reliable news articles about Group B Rally Racing? Preferably a news source - Really want to know and write more about it.

I'm attempting to write a paper on the end of the iconic group B rally monster era. Being a huge rally fan, this time captures something that is missing in today's rally racing. Any help is greatly appreciated and I'd love to know more about this topic!

2 Answers 2015-09-12

4981 / 7255

Back to start