A soldier at the military service in the Archaic Greece, bring his own weapons?

Or did the state give them the material?

I remember that the wealthy ones could go to better units because of the equipment they had, but I don't have any source for it.

1 Answers 2015-07-15

What animal might this be referring to?

From Collins' History of Kentucky, in the annal section for 1751. It's discussing English relations with the Shawnee on the Ohio:

Wednesday, March 13 - Gist meets two men belonging to Robert Smith, from whom he obtained a jaw tooth, over 4 lbs. weight, which, with other teeth, and several rib bones, 11 feet long, and a skull bone 6 feet across the forehead, and several teeth which he called horns, over 5 feet long, and as much as a man could carry.

Is this a reference to mammoth bones? Or to a fossil? Or is there some other megafauna that I'm missing?

As a follow up, would the English explorers have believed that this creature was still extant, with the bones as evidence?

1 Answers 2015-07-15

If the south only cared about keeping slavery, why did they continue to secede after Lincoln proposed the Corwin amendment?

Been doing some reading and see that Lincoln didn't care about freeing the slaves. If not for slavery, why did the south continue to secede?

2 Answers 2015-07-15

How does destruction of heritage during the Chinese Cultural Revolution, compare with Islamic State's current destruction of heritage in the middle east?

Specifically, I am referring to destruction of ancient structures, artworks, sculptures, temples, buildings and so forth. As a non-specialist, the two eras seem to have a lot in common. Did both periods of destruction lead to a similar volume of destruction of priceless artifacts, or did one period cause more loss than the other? What are some further examples of such cultural destruction in the last 100 years? How do they compare? Any suggestions or ideas will be greatly appreciated, thanks.

1 Answers 2015-07-15

In the later stages of WWII, the Soviets emptied their prisons to fill their ranks. How did all these trained and battle-hardened convicts affect post-war Russia?

Listening to Dan Carlin's Hard Core History and reading a few other sources on the Eastern Front I learned that in the later stages of WWII the Soviet Government was scraping the bottom of the barrel of able soldiers and emptied more than few prisons to boost their manpower. Once the war was over how did they deal with these convict-soldiers who had been given training and many of whom now had combat experience and possibly a taste for blood after the sacking of East Germany. Did they cause significant trouble for post-war Russia? Did they receive pardons in exchange for service?

1 Answers 2015-07-15

How valuable was a strong artillery- relative to the rest of a country's military- throughout the 20th century? Are there victories attributed (almost) entirely to a nation's artillery force?

1 Answers 2015-07-15

Aren't bows and arrows vastly superior to powder rifles in terms of accuracy, range, and rate of fire? Are there other reasons why rifles were widely adopted?

Even with barrel rifling and the minie ball, I feel like a trained archer or crossbowman would be more effective in combat. Was the loudness of rifles effective in instilling fear?

2 Answers 2015-07-15

Do third world countries/mass poverty come from colonialism and its effects, or is it a natural transition from less developed civilizations to the present?

Or in other words, what would these countries (Sub-sahara Africa, India, certain South America/Caribbean countries) look like if Europeans never colonized? Would they be happily living within the means that their area can provide them? Would they be over populated and in need of aid like they are now?

1 Answers 2015-07-15

Did the Western NATO members ever explicitly or implicitly promise to the USSR that they would not expand the alliance to former Warsaw Pact members?

There seems to be a running narrative in Russia about the betrayal by the West. I've been looking around for information on this, as Putin has made statements about the broken promises of the West with regards to NATO enlargement. The NATO website has some good information, but they obviously have a stake in this issue. So did NATO leaders ever make explicit (or heavily implied) promises not to expand to former Warsaw pact members?

I realize this may butt up against the 20 year rule- but I'm mostly asking about the behavior of Western leaders in the time before the big NATO expansions in 1999 and 2004.

2 Answers 2015-07-15

How good were British tanks in terms of reliability, ease of maintenance and repair, combat performance, cost and ease of production?

I'm trying to create a basic comparison guide on the tanks of WW2 I have managed to gather some info on British tanks and put together a small presentation. Any correction and/or addition to it is very welcomed. Thank you!


British Tanks

Moved to /r/TankPorn/wiki/ww2guidebritish

2 Answers 2015-07-15

Historical Investigation

1 Answers 2015-07-15

What are some of the most important and surprising military upsets and how did they effect both the victors and losers afterwards?

1 Answers 2015-07-15

When/how did Chinese settlers spread to Southeast Asia?

If you look at countries like Singapore, Thailand, or Malaysia, you will find large populations of Chinese people. When was there a mass exodus of Chinese or was it small amounts over time?

1 Answers 2015-07-15

Mao Zedong or the Ottoman Empire?

2 Answers 2015-07-15

Is there any evidence where, during the Third Reich, a German has been punished for not participating in the genocide or war crimes?

Today, 94-year-old Oskar Gröning was sentenced to 4 years in prison for complicity in murder in 300.000 cases.

One of the main arguments against such a trial is the apparent fact, that any objection a German soldier would have had against participating in such crimes would have been followed by a hard punishment. This is often articulated in posts like: "He should not be punished, because he had no choice."

Having googled a bit, I somehow get the feeling that this is a myth created in Germany in the 50s and 60s.

Is there any evidence of someone being punished for not participating in a war crime during the Third Reich?

1 Answers 2015-07-15

Wednesday What's New in History

Previous Weeks

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

3 Answers 2015-07-15

What was used as toilet paper in the early 1800s?

Specifically for the wealthy in society; they would have done their business in a chamber pot, but what then? Did they use newspaper, rags, or just have streaky laundry? (odd question I know, but prompted by a scene in Master & Commander [the book, not movie] where a distinguished gentleman takes out a chamber pot in the drawing room in the middle of a group conversation, sits down for his business, then puts the chamber pot back in its cupboard with no mention of cleaning; was he sitting down to pee in order to be polite in front of guests or what?) Thanks!

2 Answers 2015-07-15

Were there Russian troops in Austria around 1950 or was that Hungary? (debate over mom's ancestry)

Ok can you help me settle a debate with my mother? Here is the story - my mom was born in the US in '43, after her mother emigrated from what my grandmother always called Austria. But here's the catch - when my mom was 8ish (call it 1950) they went back to my grandmother's "Austrian" hometown, where my mother has vivid memories of having to hide from the RUSSIAN troops in town. I'm figuring that this means my mother was actually in Hungary? And perhaps this confusion is that while my grandmother is from Hungary (my theory) that given the recent (then) fall of the Austro-Hungarian empire my grandmother may have been confused about where the actual border was?

2 Answers 2015-07-15

Why is the British Home Guard in WWII commonly thought of as Dad's army? Surely there would have been WWI vets everywhere.

pls delete if in the faq

1 Answers 2015-07-15

How did people from the Middle Ages smell?

From the lowly peasant to the rich noblemen. For some odd reason this always is on my mind when I think about the Middle Ages.

3 Answers 2015-07-15

Do Djinn legends predate islam? If so did they survive the conversion to islam in some form?

3 Answers 2015-07-15

Why was Hitler described as a 'lazy dictator'?

1 Answers 2015-07-15

Why was the American government so violently protective of their weather balloon that crashed in 1947?

Did they really need to threaten people for talking about a weather balloon?

1 Answers 2015-07-15

Why are there no known Islamic explorers?

I just watched this visualization of the spread of religion.

It made me wonder why there were no Islamic explorers? Surely they had the means. Lack of motivation perhaps?

Imagine how different a world we would be experiencing.

2 Answers 2015-07-15

What are some examples of 'trolling' and notable 'trolls' pre-internet?

2 Answers 2015-07-15

5184 / 7255

Back to start