After the Mexican-American war, why didn't the United States annex all of Mexico?

1 Answers 2015-04-27

I speak American English, how far back in time could I go before I could no longer converse with locals?

1 Answers 2015-04-27

Why was Nepal not incorporated into British India? How/why did Nepal remain independent?

1 Answers 2015-04-27

There is an IAmA going on right now with an author and historian seemingly claiming that Jefferson Davis was connected to John Wilkes Booth's assassination of Lincoln. Is there any real evidence this might be true?

Here is a link to the IAmA

I have to say I am extremely skeptical about this, but I'm not a professional historian by any means. I know you can't prove a negative, but is it at all credible?

1 Answers 2015-04-27

How did Detroit go from an important industrial city to the state its in now? Were there any specific policies or events that caused this?

Not sure if this breaks the 20 year rule, because I'm not sure when/ if the things that caused Detroit's current state happened.

1 Answers 2015-04-27

Were the Celts really anarchists for 1000 years?

I've been referred to posts such as this in favor of the argument, but it's pretty thin on sources and sounds a little hagiographic. It's missing the discussion of women's rights, ethnic tensions or homogeneity, resource conflicts, or any of the troublesome issues that an anarchist society of the day would have to deal with. What was up in Ireland before Cromwell? It what ways was it an anarchist system of government? How was this system tested? How were disagreements settled?

2 Answers 2015-04-27

Mormons?

What are the ways that mormon teachings differ from catholic teaching? And why did mormons have such a negative stigma attached to them?

1 Answers 2015-04-27

After his assassination, was it ever considered to make John F. Kennedy a Saint?

Did Catholics, in the US and elsewhere, support this?

2 Answers 2015-04-27

Why were Nepal and Bhutan separate from the Indian Empire?

I'm curious why Nepal and Bhutan remained nominally separate from the British Indian Empire. They were both under British influence, so what distinguished them from the other native monarchies like Kashmir and Hyderabad?

(I'll preemptively link this thread; the responses there only seem to address the fact that Nepal and Bhutan, like the other native states, weren't under direct British rule.)

3 Answers 2015-04-27

European disease in the New World

When Christopher Columbus and subsequent Europeans made it to the Americas, they brought with them diseases, such as small pox that devastated the native populations.

Why does there seem to be no record of those same disease being brought over by the vikings who arrived centuries earlier? I understand that they did not have as much contact with as many peoples and were not present over nearly as large of a geographic area. However, it seems like there would be records/indications of plague in the North East that might have spread outwards to some degree.

The question seems to also apply to the theory/hypothesis that Chinese explorers might have landed on the Pacific Costs of the Americas. (Although if they didn't that wold explain why there were no accompanying diseases.)

1 Answers 2015-04-27

Where and when did the notion of a "white flag" signalling surrender first appear in history?

Was looking through the popular questions FAQ and was wondering if anyone could shed any light on this, cheers.

1 Answers 2015-04-27

Why do American schoolchildren learn about Thomas Edison?

Hi, I'm wondering how Thomas Edison became canonized in the American consciousness to the point that he's part of a standard elementary school curriculum. Why teach children about him over all the other inventors and/or businessmen in American history?

1 Answers 2015-04-27

Was Napoleon regarded as Hitler before Hitler?

Look how much death was caused by the Napoleonic wars...

2 Answers 2015-04-27

How many soldiers did Germany lose on the territory of modern Ukraine in WW2?

1 Answers 2015-04-27

Know of any good history classes available online?

Does anyone know a good website for taking history classes? Interested World History, and Military History. Free is great, but I dont mind paying up to $100 if the class is of good quality. No interactive teachers needed, but would like something with good powerpoint/slides like Kahn Academy. If the quality is good with a lot of visuals I would consider higher prices

1 Answers 2015-04-27

Monday Methods- describing Empire

Welcome to this week's Monday Methods thread.

Inspired by the success of the thread that discussed Tribe from three weeks ago, today's post will take a similar approach to the subject of Empire.

Some questions to consider:

  • What separates an Empire from a Kingdom, or some other form of state?

  • Does Empire go hand in hand with an Emperor/Empress? Can a republic also be an empire?

  • What is the role of military in empire-building? And are Empires necessarily formed through coercion/force?

  • Was the leader's (the Emperor's?) role viewed as a military one, or as a "head administrator"?

  • Did the empire you study look to prior or contemporary cultures as archetypes for what empire means?

  • How were subaltern groups treated in the culture you study?

Feel free to raise further questions for consideration.

Here is our list of upcoming and past topics. If you have a suggestion for a topic, please let us know.

7 Answers 2015-04-27

How did Talleyrand survive the various regime changes of the French Revolution era? Where did his true loyalty lie?

Guilt by association ate many of the revolution's children, yet foreign minister Talleyrand survived association with everyone from the ancien regime to the Legislative assembly to Napoleon to the Bourbon Restoration. Why did everyone let him keep his head, let alone let him remain in high government office?

What motivated Talleyrand to stay in politics as each successive regime he served was gruesomely ousted? Which master was he loyal to, and why did he not die with that master? If he was loyal to none of his masters, why did he bother serving for so long?

1 Answers 2015-04-27

Do Civilizations Without a Written Record Influence Socities Today?

History is not my chosen discipline so I apologize in advance if the question is ill phrased or my understanding of how the study of history operates is flawed.

I've been trying to discover more about the Scythians and have found that besides not being a proper empire, we know very little of them compared to the more famous civilizations of antiquity like the Hellnic people and the Hebrew tribes. In fact, much of what we know descends from what the Greeks have chosen to write of them (same for the Philistines in relation to the Hebrews). One common theme of these celebrity civilizations is their devotion to the written word and their liberal use of it from recording important events, tracking business transactions, and for purposes of leisure. We can detect historical figures like Aristotle, Heraclitus, and Moses and track their direct influence to the present day. Not much the same with those societies marganiziled by historical record.

My question is how much do these forgotten tribes influence the daily lives of people today and could we tell if they do? Are their any aspects of social interaction, law, science, religion, or other aspects of the human experience that can be directly attributed to the Scythians or to other such people who did not value written language?

2 Answers 2015-04-27

How did the fall of the Soviet Union affect Russian Jews?

To clarify what was life like for Jews in the Soviet Union before the fall and how does that compare to their life after the fall?

1 Answers 2015-04-27

What are the origins of the Magpie Poem?

You know the magpie poem which is supposed to dictate what kind of luck you'll get depending on how many magpies you see

"One for sorrow, two for joy, three for a girl..." etc.

Where did that originate, and why were magpies specifically surrounded with so much superstition?

Also how many variations where there? I'd heard there was a bunch of regional variations in Britain before a T.V show used a specific version as its theme song.

1 Answers 2015-04-27

In Game of Thrones, the Unsullied patrol the streets with spears. Was this a common choice of weapon for street patrols?

I guess they'd be good for riot control, but wouldn't a sword be better for fighting in close quarters? Did any civilisations use spears? What are the more common patrol weapons in medieval Europe? What about Ancient Rome?

3 Answers 2015-04-27

Why Don't Americans Celebrate Independence Day on September 3?

I'm curious to read people's opinion on the matter. The Declaration of Independence was ratified July 4th and that remains the traditional celebration day.

However, wouldn't it be more appropriate--albeit perhaps less patriotically rousing--to celebrate US independence on September 3, the date that saw the signing of the Treaty of Paris which included formal recognition by Britain of the US as an independent sovereign?

Thanks to everyone.

1 Answers 2015-04-27

Alexander the Great was said to have slept with a copy of the Iliad under his pillow. Would this have been in the form of a bound book, or a scroll... or what?

2 Answers 2015-04-27

Lincoln, FDR, Their Generals, and Power

I'm currently reading Commander In Chief: Franklin Delano Roosevelt, His Lieutenants, and Their War by Eric Larrabee and I noticed that he draws some similarities between FDR and Lincoln in terms of how they used their generals/staff and executive power during their respective crises. I'm less familiar with the Civil War and Lincoln's generals than I am with 20th century military leaders and World War II and I was wondering if anyone could give me some more details into what Larrabee is referencing, as his statements are somewhat vague - for example, he says, "Roosevelt stretched the boundaries of executive authority (as Lincoln did)" (628) but doesn't give any evidence/context to show how Lincoln stretched those boundaries. If anyone could provide any insight on this, it would be much appreciated! Also, if you have any suggestions for further reading, I'd love to hear them!

1 Answers 2015-04-27

Who was the first man to attach a scope to his rifle? When did snipers with optics start appearing on the battlefield?

2 Answers 2015-04-27

5474 / 7255

Back to start