opera house fires

1 Answers 2015-02-04

Wednesday What's New in History

Previous Weeks

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

3 Answers 2015-02-04

Language requirements for advanced history degrees...

I'm currently finishing my last semester as an undergraduate history major. Recently I've decided that I'm interested in graduate school and getting PhD. After talking to my professors, the general concensus is that I need to learn the language of the area that I'm interested in studying. I'll be European history and at some point I would like to study Scandinavia because I'm fascinated by the Vikings. So my question is what language should I learn i.e. Norwegian, Danish, Icelandic, etc.

2 Answers 2015-02-04

Did the Arabic language change over the years? Is the formal dialect of Arabic still the same as it was 1000-1400 years ago?

1 Answers 2015-02-04

In academia, what do "ancient," "classical," and "antiquity" mean?

Colloquially, they're de facto synonyms. Any other terms, you'd like to clarify?

1 Answers 2015-02-04

How did this map from 1581, be pretty accurate?

https://i.imgur.com/koOLIqR.jpg

I'm shocked that it's actually kinda accurate to how the world is today. How did they compile such data? How long did it take?

2 Answers 2015-02-04

Were the US Supreme Court Justices prejudiced concerning eugenics, in Buck v. Bell (1927) ?

I know little of history, but want to know about any personal beliefs of the Justices, and whether personal biases affected their decisions. In Buck v. Bell (1927), the Court upheld a statute instituting compulsory sterilization of the unfit "for the protection and health of the state." Did any Justice believe in eugenics? I recognise that bad law is still law, but am dismayed to read 7 justices formed the majority. Since J Butler dissented, why didn't more do so? In particular, Justice Holmes's vilifications staggered me. I can understand the desire to prevent hereditary illness and suffering, but I don't know if J. Holmes circumscribed his vituperation? He could have softened his tone, at least, or clarified his intent?

Update n 2015 Feb 23: I just read http://chronicle.uchicago.edu/010315/alschuler-holmes.shtml

2 Answers 2015-02-04

During WW2, Germany carried out a large number of brutal anti-partisan operations. Did they achieve their stated goals or were they counterproductive?

During the course of the war, a large number of war crimes were committed in anti-partisan operations. Dozens of civilians were killed in retribution for attacks on Germans or sabotage.

Notwithstanding their moral horror, were those actions actually successful? Did they deter further partisan action? Or were they counterproductive and encouraged even more resistance?

Is there any way to know? Were there any 'natural experiments', maybe different policies in otherwise similar areas?

This obviously also happened in other conflicts and wars, so evidence from these is welcome.

1 Answers 2015-02-04

What happens after a war?

1 Answers 2015-02-04

Did (do?) the United States Strategic Command worry about nuclear armed ICBMs exploding on launch, as unfortunately occurs sometimes even in contemporary satellite launches?

Since most people have probably seen footage of a satellite launch gone wrong, where the huge rocket explodes into a massive fireball shortly after launch, I was wondering if the US military (or any other military, for that matter) worried about having X-thousand nuclear missiles in their arsenal.

Even if the launch failure rate was a minuscule percentage, one or two missiles exploding after launch with a nuclear warhead certainly wouldn't be welcome news. I was wondering if anyone here could give me some insight?

1 Answers 2015-02-04

What affects did the Industrial Revolution have on warfare?

1 Answers 2015-02-04

If so much Greek art/pottery depicts warriors holding spears above their heads stabbing forward and down, why do video games/movies show Greek warriors holding spears lower at their sides and just thrusting forward?

I'm sure they fought with both styles but I'm still curious about the major differences in portrayal.

This is what I see whenever I look at ancient Greek art and pottery: http://www.timetrips.co.uk/gw-hoplites-fighting.jpg

And this is how games/movies/modern art portrays them: http://cloud-4.steampowered.com/ugc/531747978942698104/FCD23DDD24784347CF41CBC88E5BF779CFA2192C/

Am I missing art and military memoirs where they are described to fight with the latter form? Was it just for the sake of the art style that they are depicted holding them above their heads? Or does pop culture mis-portray what a true Hoplite unit's formation would look like?

2 Answers 2015-02-04

What did a typical army of China look like from around Qin Dynasty to Yuan Dynasty?

What kind of uniform/armor, weapons, and general organization would the armies have during these times and how did they change as time progressed?

1 Answers 2015-02-04

Why was Napoleon supplied with soldiers, artillery and ships on his first exile?

I see many questions have been asked about why Napoleon was exiled instead of executed. That is not my question. Rather, why was he given these military forces? I know Metternich predicted in 1814 that Napoleon would be back within two years, but surely you didn't have to be a canny poltician to sense that equipping the man with everything he needed to invade Europe (again) was not a good idea. EDIT: I should add that my source is Jan Swafford's 2014 biography of Beethoven.

2 Answers 2015-02-04

What was the average literacy rate in medieval Korea?

Forgive me if I'm using the wrong terminology for "medieval" Korea. By "medieval" I'm mostly thinking about Joseon post Sejong.

I've read that King Sejong wanted to invent a language that was easy for the average Korean to read, to replace the complex Chinese characters used to write the language. The literati greatly preferred the Chinese and refused to use Hangul for years.

Having learned Hangul myself very quickly, I can understand how Hangul can be thought of as the "dumb man's alphabet" while Chinese is thought of as "higher" due to its complexity. At the same time, I've been reading a lot of Korean stories where it seems like literacy isn't as common in pre-modern Korea as Sejong had hoped it might be.

1 Answers 2015-02-04

What was education like in the Roman("Byzantine") Empire?

I have read these so far:

and it got me interested in knowing more about it.

2 Answers 2015-02-04

Why did Tehran emerge as a large city in Iran as opposed to cities along the Caspian?

2 Answers 2015-02-04

How is World War II taught in German high schools?

Is there anything significant that is left out, avoided, or in any way manipulated to downplay any wrong doing?

2 Answers 2015-02-04

I'm meeting with a guy who fought for South Vietnam during the American War. What should I ask him?

2 Answers 2015-02-04

How many primary sources do we have about Rome from 700 b.c.to 500 a.d?

I am always astonished about how much we know. And how many sources are preserved. Im curious about things like Cicero's works. Do we have many old decaying scrolls? Is most of what we have, including the accounts of sexual debauchery, the result of collection and preservation by the Catholic Church? How much was recovered from the Arabs during the Crusades? Or brought to Europe by Greek refugees from what was the Byzantine Empire? How many works do we have that the oldest copies come from the Medieval Period?

1 Answers 2015-02-04

Medieval agriculture

Hello everyone,

I turn to you with a (sort of) broader questions.

A little background first: I am trying to learn programming by working on a game that takes place in a fantasy medieval ages. However my goal is to create a realistic representation of the medieval life around the year 1000 and now that I have created a sort of OK system for weather generation and simulation I was wondering if anyone here has any idea or information about how medieval agriculture worked? Now I checked wikipedia and several books in the past few weeks but I still am not sure about answers to these questions (the game will take place in a tempered climate):

a) What factors went into medieval agriculture? Obviously one is weather but at what time did peasants what? What weather was desirable at which month and what weather was really, really bad fir them? How much rain was good, did they like snow and wished for cold winters or preferred mild as far as agriculture goes?

b) How many people could a man working on the field support with the output? How much place was he able to work on? How much time did it consume?

c) How good was hunting as far as food yield went? How many people was a hunter able to support on average?

d) What happened in case of a catastrophic harvest? I am sure hunting/gathering was a thing but could it put an isolated village through entire season if the fields yielded poor/no harvest?

e) How long could they store the harvest before it went bad? In what form did they store the harvest?

f) As far as i.e. vegetables, apples and other products went how were they stored/consumed as they are seasonal food? Did they have any during late winter-spring?

g) As far as dietary habits go how big was a role of for example fishing, gathering etc. around year 1000 for the people?

h) Anything specific that I didn't think about that I should know about?

I am of course aware these are quite broad topics so if there are some good books/online sources please point me towards those first. Plus I won't mind shorter answers with suggestions where to look for broader explanations. I just have problem finding more about this in any books that deal with medieval life. They all explain feudalism and basic things about what they worked with and the fields but not about the above :/

Thank you in advance for any reply! I really appreciate this reddit being in existence :)

Thank you in advance for any reply! I really appreciate this reddit being in existence :)

1 Answers 2015-02-04

What did ancient people think about static electricity?

When the room is completely dark and you move under a blanket, you see the little electric sparks. I'm guessing ancient people encountered this phenomenon at times and I wonder how they accounted for it...

2 Answers 2015-02-04

Were WW2 tanks as maneuverable as shown in Girls Und Panzer?

I just finished the anime series Girls Und Panzer. Barring the absurd premise, the show seems to have paid a lot of attention to detail in its tank designs and tactics. But the speed and maneuverability of the tanks seems implausible and likely due to artistic license.

Some examples:

  • Tanks drift Tokyo-style through tight turns

  • The Italian tanks zip around like go-carts and if knocked over the drivers can simply roll the tank back upright and start driving again

  • A single tank disrupts an enemy tank formation by weaving in-between them so they can't shoot without risking friendly fire

  • A tank column charges straight through a a gap in a line of enemy tanks without holding still to fight, leading to a dramatic chase across the Russian steppe.

  • Tanks get into one-one-one duels. In one duel they circle each other trying to get a shot at the other's flank. In another duel the tanks are bumper to bumper trying to stay too close to be shot and sometimes resort to 'sword-fighting' with their barrels to disrupt each other's aim.

  • Small tanks driver under and on top of larger tanks to immobilize them

  • Tanks drive on, stop, and fire on sloped surfaces.

  • Seeing an enemy tank fire in the distance, and tank can swerve to the side to dodge the shot.

Are any of these feats even remotely plausible?

Have any military historians here watched the series? What were your general impressions?

1 Answers 2015-02-04

Bachelor project

1 Answers 2015-02-04

What are the best texts to read when studying the Inquisition?

Greetings folks. I submitted a similar question weeks ago to no avail.

Be assured I have perused your Book List, but when looking through [Religious History](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/books/culturalhistory#wiki_christianity on Christianity, I found nothing specific to the study of the Office of the Inquisition. In European History (the Middle Ages), I found nothing particular regarding the Inquisition.

In my own research, I have found Dr. Ed Peters' book, Inquisition which I am anxious to read.

Through the recommendation of a friend, I have also found Cullen Murphy's God's Jury: The Inquisition and the Making of the Modern World, but the book is terrible history. It reads far more like an op-ed written to a distinctly American audience. Murphy spends far more time bragging about his travels than discussing real history and he is prone to inject irrelevant opinions into his commentary. It is not unusual for him to write in such a manner that compares the current "War on Terror" to the Inquisition.

Any help in gathering relevant (and reputable) sources to study the Office of the Inquisition - from its inception in the Middle Ages to its close (or re-branding) in the 20th Century - would be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2015-02-04

5816 / 7255

Back to start