Pre-PIE Europeans?

What do we know about peoples in Europe before the Indo-European migrations? Were the Minoans IE?

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Faking identities throughout history?

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Are there any examples of micropenises in history?

1 Answers 2014-07-18

What are some good (mostly) unbiased resources concerning the history of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict?

Repost from /r/askhistory since I wasn't getting a lot of response there and there seems to be more traffic here

I've been closely following the story coming out of Gaza in the past couple of days, and I was curious about the historical context of this conflict because, frankly, I'm nearly completely ignorant on this subject. As I've searched through the internet trying to find either texts or videos, all I can seem to find are one-sided accounts either Israel's or Palestine's side of the story and the sources are obviously biased. Does anyone know of some good documentaries, books, or websites that can help shed some light on this issue for me? Anything that gives a historical account of the region or conflict over the past several decades would be great. Or does anyone have a link to a previous thread where this same question was asked? Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Would height ever be a factor of what you did in battle?

A 6'2" soldier would have a greater advantage over a 5'7" soldier. Increased mass equals more muscle, more reach, heavier weapons, and heavier armor. So would a very large person be equipped differently? Such as a long sword and no shield to compliment his arm reach? How would a short person be equipped? I imagine they would strive to be lightly armored and compliment speed and agility.

2 Answers 2014-07-18

What's the story behind SS general Arthur Nebe? Apparently he happily killed thousands of Jews, but hated the Nazis/Hitler...

He just seems to be an odd guy. From what I've read, he was in the SS since very early on and was the head of the Einsatzgruppen. He oversaw the deaths of over 50,000 Jews. But apparently he also had a conscience and hated what Hitler was doing, and tried to assassinate him?

He just seems like a walking contradiction. Could someone explain his motivations and rationale?

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Examples of cities being abandoned in history.

1 Answers 2014-07-18

How accurate is the Book of Mormon in depicting actual events in Mesoamerica.

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Historically, what were public reactions after civilian airliners got shot down by military action?

With the recent MH17 incident and all the TIL's about Korean Air 007 (1983), Iranian Air 655 (1988), etc., what has the public's reaction to these incidents been?

Thanks! First time posting here, so hopefully I formatted everything correctly :)

1 Answers 2014-07-18

How many European Jews survived until the end of WWII?

I have found conflicting numbers regarding this statistic. This source suggests a number of 3 million survivors. This entry (seems more accurate) gives a number of 3.5 million (out of a 1933 population of 9.5 million). Google search didn't have anything definitive.

My question is, what is the commonly accepted number of deaths during the Holocaust, and if it was over 3 million, how did so many survive? If the Nazis wanted to murder every Jew, how did their concentration camps neglect 1/3rd of the target population? Were some individuals not imprisoned, or were there many that hid from authorities? I find it hard to believe that the Gestapo could miss 1/3rd of the group they targeted most severely.

I remember reading that many Jews were deported to or fled to the Middle East, causing riots in Palestine in the late 1930s. How large was this migration, and what made the Middle East the prime destination?

1 Answers 2014-07-18

What's involved in the desanctification of a Catholic church?

1 Answers 2014-07-18

What are some must read biographies about the 3rd Reich?

I just finished what it's considered the most complete Himmler biography by Peter Longerich ( https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/11191214-heinrich-himmler?ac=1[1] ) and I was wondering if there is a consensus on must read books about the 3rd reich personalities.

I'm looking for the best Goebbels's and Hitler's biography I can find, but I'm open to suggestions for later. Is Albert Speer autobiography any good?

2 Answers 2014-07-18

American participation in the 1910 Mexican Revolution.

Hello, /r/askhistorians!

I have been looking for information about Americans joining the Mexican Revolution under Pancho Villa or other revolutionaries. I have read on many websites that a man named Tracey Custer Richardson commanded a squadron completely made up of gringos, but never with sources or even a name for the group he was in charge of.

Does anyone with a knowledge of the Mexican Revolution know anything about my gringo compatriots joining up with Mexican leaders? What would their reasoning be? Money? Glory? Just believing in the cause? And what would their experiences be like when they got to Mexico? Any information about these participants would be very cool.

Thank you!

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Did people ever bury or otherwise inter valuables for protection?

As a general/common practice, the way we keep things in safety deposit boxes today.

Besides pirates I mean (Did pirates even do that?).

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Did any aspects of the renaissance reach the Ottoman empire?

Given their closeness to Italy it seemed that there would be some interaction (especially with Venice since they traded).

1 Answers 2014-07-18

What era of technology could you recreate from scratch?

1 Answers 2014-07-18

What was relations like between the Byzantine Empire and the Umayyad Caliphate?

With the Umayyads conquering North Africa and expansion into Iberia, what was the relationship status between the two Empires?

3 Answers 2014-07-18

which country was the most humanistic?

1 Answers 2014-07-18

When horses were the primary mode of transportation, were travel times in major cities significantly impacted by traffic?

And if so, what did cities do to mitigate this? Was there any kind of traffic control infrastructure? Did the concept of directional lanes exist? Were there traffic violations, and citations?

Edit: I should have been more clear about time period: I'm mostly curious about late 1800's/turn of the century.

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Dr. Richard Jensen, author of 'The Battle Against Anarchist Terrorism' and expert in the development of worldwide terrorism, will be here to answer questions beginning at 4:00PM EST

A conflict came up in the schedule, and we had to push the time back one hour - but we're still on track otherwise! The original post will be updated when the AMA goes 'live.'

Dr. Jensen is one of the leading historians of political violence in this era and spent about 10 years composing his latest work. He has published several articles (and one book) in public security/terrorism in Italy during the 19th century, as well as several manuals for instruction of history in the modern world. Some of the issues he is prepared to discuss are:

  1. Diplomatic, police, and wider socio-economic and political efforts to fight, repress, and prevent anarchist terrorism, 1878-1930s
  2. Anarchist terrorism: its causes and history, 1878-1930s
  3. The question whether the present Al-Qaeda/Islamic extremist associated terrorism of today is closely comparable to 19th century anarchist terrorism (as has often been alleged).

These obviously don't limit the extent of the AMA, so feel free to ask away!

25 Answers 2014-07-18

What was the naming culture of the Carthaginians (Or Phoenicians)?

How were names chosen? What kind of meaning did they hold, and what kind of honorifics or titles existed? What were some common names?

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Is it really fair to label Abraham Lincoln a racist?

Speaking as a british black person, Abraham Lincoln is definitely one of my favourite US presidents. It's not just simply for me: "Well he freed the slaves". I feel this way due to his incredible drive, him being ahead of his time and most of all that he was a genius. I say this as he was smart enough to control his strong will to change what he saw as injustice by not acting out of emotion but by looking to strive for the best possible outcome even if it does not seem like enough. I felt he recognised what was possible in his lifetime and strived towards that, rather than doing a John Brown.

I'll try and be concise but it's hard for me, I'm not a good writer. I've read a lot of American History for fun and out of interest on the internet and on a few books. What people often say is: "He was a racist, he said blacks are unequal" and usual talk about the quotes that are described as racist. And the people that fight back simply say "He was a man of his time."

I argue against labelling him racist a different way, I think it needs to be remembered how good the man was at playing politics and remember his time. Part of me thinks you need to understand that you cannot know what he said to just appease people and what he actually believed. Some were worried he would "hand over the country to negro rule". To actually come out and say "blacks and whites are equal" was extremely radical and would get him nowhere, he had to be the fox about it. People saw egalitarians as straight up madmen who would ruin the country. And people still feel like that today, they are just secretive about it and post mainly on the internet.

I think he had to say those things because even though he said them people would still say things such as "Lincoln the white nigger", "Lincoln likely beds negro women" "Lincoln will make white men slaves". And a lot of white people saw what he was doing as "oppressing white people". I know it sounds ridiculous to us. Is it not reasonable to accept that Lincoln would have to play some major southern strategy? My main point is what things he claimed can we really be certain he felt. The man did everything possible he could for black folks without being seen as a madman like others such as Thaddeus Stevens.

Here's some info on how even fellow politicians reacted to people pro-civil rights long ago: Decades after James K. Vardaman referred to Theodore Roosevelt as "little, mean, coon-flavored miscegenationist", and the man was not even that outspoken for black civil rights and this was decades after the time of Lincoln (this gave an idea of how uneasy people were about advancing negro rights).

Tillman in reference to Booker T being invited to the white house be Roosevelt "The action of President Roosevelt in entertaining that nigger will necessitate our killing a thousand niggers in the South before they will learn their place again", same time period.

And at present day, let me explain something: Do you really think there are people alive that are not doubtlessly far more racist than Lincoln ever was.

I was watching a video on Youtube of Gorillas fighting in a zoo, it had nothing to do with black people. The top comments at +65 and +119 were " Typical black domestic violence" and "Niggers gonna nig". Let that sink in, casual hardcore racism like that which is totally dehumanising is widespread on the net where people say what they really feel. There's a difference between people who even today, just straight up hate all blacks, don't want to give them a chance or access to do well from their own work and are pro eugenics or segregation e.t.c and people like Lincoln or Roosevelt who judged people more by merit.

There is no evidence of Lincoln being anywhere near that racist and hateful. I think the man had the heart of a lion and not just for the issues of black folk, he showed a lot of compassion and way more than he had to and did as much as he could, using his immense intelligence to do so.

I give this info not to try convince anyone, just to let you know what I believe and why I believe it. If I'm very ignorant, it might help to know the true extent of my ignorance.

What I admit is that I am an amateur and not a proper historian.

What I would like is if you wise and true Historians could answer this question so that I maybe more knowledgable, how I feel is that if I'm wrong about this, I'd rather find out sooner than later.

I'm very thankful if you read all , most or enough of that to understand what I'm saying. I'd really appreciate responses to this.

I'm not a good writer and apologise for any poor composition or some grammatical mistakes and of course the length of my post.

Edit: I've come to realise after being given advice that at the very least my submission is very poor quality compared to the other submissions in this sub. I apologise for the quality of my post and how bad my title is. I know that this sub is generally well regarded and subscribers and mods pride that it has good content. I really didn't mean to just create more rubbish for the mods to clean up. I fully understand if my post is deleted. I should have lurked more.

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Before the invention of radio communication, how did a country at war communicate with their navy while they were out at sea? (Xpost from /r/explainlikeimfive)

I saw this question in that subreddit and I found it interesting. However, both top comments say opposite things

One says that they were "delivered to other ports and to ships via Packet Ship" , while the other answer says that "they largely didn't" and "That's why ships' captains had such insane amounts of authority over their crew".

How did ships communicate with the mainland then? I hope that I can find a good answer here. Thanks.

EDIT: I forgot tho add the link to the original post. http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/2b1ilq/eli5_before_the_invention_of_radio_communication/

1 Answers 2014-07-18

Why are the Nordic countries social democratic countries?

Hi!

I was thinking about this today. Why did the Nordic countries turn out Social democratic countries and liberal?

Is there something particular in their history that would explain this?

2 Answers 2014-07-18

Have white Western or Northern Europeans ever been enslaved by foreigners?

4 Answers 2014-07-18

6512 / 7255

Back to start