What are some of the greatest imbalances between modes of warfare in history?

2 Answers 2014-07-13

How Accurate is this "Debunking WW1 Myths" Article?

Although it came out a while ago, I was re-reading it today, and was quite curious how accurate these debunking myths could be. I'm vary wary of just accepting a BBC historian right off the mark, and was hoping someone could come in as a third-party and perhaps debunk, some of his debunking myths.

Here is the article:

http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-25776836

3 Answers 2014-07-13

How different was the dark ages, as compared to modern conceptions? What do I assume as correct, that I did get correct, and what do I assume as correct that is incredibly wrong?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

How were British Intelligence Services seen by the Soviet Union or United States during the cold war? Were they seen as equally competent to the CIA or KGB?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

Has there been an outright sale of national territory in the recent past? Why was the transfer of territory (allodial title) between sovereign entities via financial purchase more common in the past (no large scale examples I can find within the last 25 years)?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

At what point did the nobility in England stop speaking Norman French and why?

As a follow up, where there other dialects kicking around other parts of France and England at the time that have faded into obscurity (other than old English)?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

Were slaves allowed to participate in ancient Olympic Games?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

What really happened to Hitler's body?

I've heard a lot of mixed information, could some clear it up for me?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

Is there an example of a successful people which refused to trade with other peoples?

I was wondering if in recorded history, there was a respectable people who were doing well, yet refused to trade with other peoples.

Because in all of history, it is clear that trade is always of the upmost importance, yet I don't see many examples of anyone refusing to trade. I'm sure there must be some group out there who refused to trade for whatever reason, and I was wondering how they did.

1 Answers 2014-07-13

How would an individual in the Civil War era United States convert $100,000 of gold coins into "usable" currency?

I watched The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly yesterday, and at the end of the movie (SPOILER) Clint Eastwood's character rides into the sunset with $100,000 of Confederate gold in the form of coins. This inflation calculator indicates that this would equate to approximately $1.5 million today (using the dollar value rather than the gold value).

How would an individual in that era go about converting that into usable currency? Could he just take it into a bank and get a letter of credit? How accessible were banking services of that value to the average person in the street? Or was gold readily traded in its natural form? I presume that even in that case he would have to melt the gold down to disguise it's origin. Would it be suitable for large transactions, for example a property purchase, without drawing undue attention?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

Is the term "Middle Ages" contested or discussed?

As far as I can tell, the term "Middle Ages" appears to refer to the time periods in between Classical history and Renaissance history, with those two latter forms of history considered to have thematic and academic kinship.

This doesn't seem particularly even minded to me. It defines the period between the fall of the ancient Roman Empire and the fall of Constantinople (if we take the Renaissance as beginning in 1453), and therefore in relation to a different prominent civilisation, rather than defining the period (or periods) by their own traits. If we take the Renaissance as beginning when Constantinople falls, then we're also defining the end of the Middle Ages by the ending of the Eastern Roman Empire... which appears to me to be equally unrelated to what the Middle Ages actually "contained", so to speak.

As a follow-on question:

If there is a school of thought that argues that defining the Middle Ages by the standards of Classical and Renaissance history is incorrect, where does that school of thought place the beginning of the Renaissance? If the notion of judging the Middle Ages by way of different historical periods is rejected, is a period known as "the Renaissance" even a required way to think about immediately post-medieval Europe? Or would it be more correct to say that the Renaissance begins at roughly Time X, but the Middle Ages continue in parallel until Time Y?

Sorry, these are possibly difficult and contentious topics in medieval and Renaissance studies. But the more I read about the late Middle Ages and the Renaissance, the more I find some distinctions arbitrary.

2 Answers 2014-07-13

As an average roman citizen living around 0CE, would I have any ability to chose my religious beliefs?

My question stems from a lack of knowledge of the empire as a whole. In Jerusalem, the Jews seemed to be able to practice Judaism and maintain their temple until it was destroyed in around 70CE. Were citizens in other parts of the empire able to decide which deity to worship?

EDIT: As a followup question, what are my choices of non-emperor worship?

5 Answers 2014-07-13

Why did the Clinton administration (and Bush administration) have a policy of regime change in Iraq?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

Why was slavery so important to the economy of ancient Rome?

It seems to me that slavery was prevalent throughout Roman history. Is this so, and when did this begin? And more importantly, why was the institution of slavery so important to the functioning of the Roman economy -- why, for instance, did they not simply utilize wage labor instead, or corvee labor, or what have you? Didn't this institution have drawbacks?

And secondly, When Marx writes about different modes of production, between the primitive and feudal he tends to describe a mode known as "slave society" or sometimes "asiatic". For any who might be acquainted with his analysis, does it hold water? Does ancient Rome and its institutions of chattel-slavery actually represent a distinct "mode of production"? (Edit ~ And to clarify, what exactly is unique about this slave-society as a mode of production that renders it distinct from slave-ownership under Capitalism, such as in the American South?)

3 Answers 2014-07-13

How would the warring of Early Islamic History be carried out?

I'm entirely unfamiliar with the way war was carried out in what we now call the Middle East. I'd like to hear a description of things like: equipment, unit types, formations, generals, etc for the early days of Islam. Thanks for the answers!

1 Answers 2014-07-13

Differences between the Bantu and Indo-European expansions?

In Africa, the Bantu expanded from Cameroon with the edge of iron and agricultural techniques and eventually either displaced or absorbed the native Pygmy and Khoisan people in almost all of Sub-Saharan Africa. In contrast, the Indo-European people are believed to have not genetically replaced the inhabitants of Europe and merely spread their language.

What accounts for the difference in results of the two peoples' migrations? Both had potent advantages over their neighbors and their languages dominate much of their respective continent.

Additionally, I have a question about the Bantu expansion. When the interactions between Bantus and the Khoisan are mentioned, literature often says that the Bantu "pushed" the Khoisan and Pygmies into their current territories. Did the Bantu "push" the Khoisan and Pygmies the same way the Americans "pushed" the Native Americans into reservations?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

What are some unique/interesting examples of Stockholm Syndrome throughout history?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

Does anyone know of a book about the history of Canada, that's written in a similar perspective as Howard Zinn's the People's History of the United States?

3 Answers 2014-07-13

Could a complex civilization grow and exist without metal or abundant food?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

Why was Göring chosen to be first in the line of succession? Why did Hitler choose him above all the other potential candidates?

2 Answers 2014-07-13

Has a Muslim state never existed in the current region of Israel?

I recently watched this video, and the narrator seems to oversimplify everything. How accurate is he? And did there really never exist a Muslim state in Israel?

5 Answers 2014-07-13

Can anyone tell me anything about my family's history? My last name is Cantacuzene

2 Answers 2014-07-13

What was interstate travel like in the U.S. prior to the construction of the Interstate Highway System (Federal Aid Highway Act of 1956)?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

Did anyone predict the Holocaust or something like it?

Did anyone predict the Holocaust or something like it?

The only people I've found that seem to have had some prescience with regards to the fate of the Jews of Europe are Trotsky and Hermann Mann (brother of Thomas Mann).

Trotsky, in December 1938, wrote:

“It is possible to imagine without difficulty what awaits the Jews at the mere outbreak of the future world war. But even without war the next development of world reaction signifies with certainty the physical extermination of the Jews.”

When Hitler came to power, Mann wrote a letter in which he said "that the Jews of Germany will be systematically annihilated, of that there can be no doubt." (This is quoted in Clive James' book Cultural Amnesia) That turned out to be slightly wrong, as Jews inside Germany had a better chance of surviving Nazi power than those in the stateless war zones to the east.

I've tried looking for others, but Google searches turn up a frustrating glut of crap websites dealing with Biblical prophecy and Nostradamus etc. Not the sort of sober information I'm looking for.

So AskHistorians, did anyone else see the Holocaust coming in any palpable sense?

1 Answers 2014-07-13

How did submarines in WWI and WWII navigate underwater and avoid collisions?

3 Answers 2014-07-13

6533 / 7255

Back to start