How do Enlightenment ideals hold up throughout the late 19th century and early 20th century? (up through WWII)

What was the fate of these ideals? I know after the French Revolution, there was a period of reactionary conservatism throughout Europe, up until around 1848, when nationalism, imperialism, and a focus on industrialization took hold, but it seems like the rights of the individual took a temporary step aside, as industrialization and capitalism became the name of the game. What was their role, if any, in WWI, when men readily fought for their respective nations at the beginning, and how did they persist through the disillusionment that came at the tail end of the war?

My history professor told my class that our ability to understand and answer blockbuster question such as this one would be on our final, although not this one in particular; so really, I'm asking for guidance in which direction I should focus my efforts to effectively answer a similar question.

1 Answers 2014-04-25

What was life like for the Jewish population in Israel immediately after its declaration of independence?

Were people still going to work and to school? Were shops open? I understand that it probably depended on where exactly and I would like to understand what those differences were.

1 Answers 2014-04-25

Why was Ancient Athenian democracy so successful?

I've heard Ancient Athenian democracy was more succesful because it empowered it's citizens to work harder(because they cared) but what are some examples of this? Battle of Marathon?

1 Answers 2014-04-25

When did the United States become a democracy?

I have two issues here: did it become a democracy before or after the Articles of Confederation? Some say that democracy was born when the America seceded from the British. Others say that not until the constitution. Some say that it wasn't until african americans and women could vote.

Secondly, this question is often deflected with 'America is not a democracy, it's a republic'. Regardless, for the purposes of this question, I'm assuming America's a liberal democracy.

3 Answers 2014-04-25

Excluded religious or ethinic minorities and an association with wealth

I was reading about the Copts in Egypt and i came through this part

"The Copts were severely affected by Nasser's nationalization policies because, though they represented about 10–20% of the population,[30] they were so economically prosperous that they held more than 50% of the country's wealth."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copts

That is similar to jews in some aspects.

So my questions are:

1- Do we have more examples of excluded minorities with more proportionally wealth than the rest of populace?

2- Is possible to these minorities prosperity be associated with they state of exclusion? Just wondering if they were obligated to look for other ways to prosper( since public work is impossible and the discrimination as a regular work would drive then off).

Sorry for my English.

2 Answers 2014-04-25

Has there been a conflict where both sides were armed identically?

1 Answers 2014-04-25

When did the United States become a major player in the world stage?

Basically, when did the US become a "world power," or when did the US start to have a large influence on world affairs? Also, why did it happen when it did?

3 Answers 2014-04-25

What was Jinnah's vision for Pakistan?

As an Indian, I have a fascination with Pakistan. I have read articles by several Pakistani experts, which claim that Jinnah wanted Sharia to be implemented or that he wanted a secular democracy or some other variant. On talk shows, this question frequently leads to violent arguments.

Given that nowadays, all actors in the Pakistani politics, wether the established political parties or Pakistani Taliban or the Pakistani elite, claim their views to be consistent with Jinnah's vision, what exactly was Jinnah's vision for Pakistan?

EDIT : Fixed grammer.

3 Answers 2014-04-25

[Speculation] Russia makes a preemptive nuclear strike to prevent intervention in Ukraine and to protect it's interests elsewhere. Where does it strike?

1 Answers 2014-04-25

At what point did medieval Mongolian war tactics become obsolete?

The Mongolian army such at it was lead by Genghis Kahn in the 13th century appeared rather unstoppable. On flat open terrain, a large force of cavalry archers equipped with the recurve bow destroyed all opposition from Asia to central Europe. In my understanding, the Mongolian empire splinted do to succession strife and ultimately fell due to political and military mismanagement rather than a weakness in the Mongolian war tactic.

So my question is: aside from beating them at their own game, how could a medieval army stop the Mongolians? Was there anything short of sophisticated gunpowder weapons that could defeat them on open terrain?

My first thought would be that the advent of stronger plate armor could make the Mongolian bows obsolete, but then again they will still have the mobility advantage.

1 Answers 2014-04-25

Why do only 43 states in the US recognize the Armenian Genocide? Why not the whole country?

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armenian_Genocide_recognition

1 Answers 2014-04-25

What is the origin of the "high-five"?

Edit: Why did it become so common?

6 Answers 2014-04-25

So a kid just said that the government covered up evidence of giants in our history. Is there any merit to this at all?

My mind went straight "wut" when he said this.

1 Answers 2014-04-25

Is the Black Legend bad history?

So a couple days ago I wrote this comment in a thread about Spanish Imperialism. I got a number of responses referencing the Black Legend, something I had never heard of. I've never studied this subject especially deeply, but I don't want to spread any misinformation. As I understand it, the early colonization of the New World was a singularly important point in the way it helped establish they way future generations looked at race and ethnicity. So it would seem I have a rather large hole in my education. I plan to try and rectify this when I can, but I'd appreciate any resources you can give me.

2 Answers 2014-04-25

Why did the Soviet Union stop trying to get to the moon?

Once the United States made it why did they stop? I would have thought at that point that they had to get there or admit defeat.

1 Answers 2014-04-25

why has Northern Ireland been more violent than Scotland, Wales, or Quebec?

Why has Northern Ireland had more of a history of violent conflict in the last few decades than Scotland, Wales, or Quebec, even though those last three have all had sometimes-acrimonious nationalist disputes?

1 Answers 2014-04-25

Why weren't the Indians satisfied with Government of India act 1919 ?

What were the first elections after the act like?

and why didn't this satisfy the people who were fighting for freedom given this actually grants them representative form of government?

What motivated them to strive for "greater" independence?

1 Answers 2014-04-25

How did medieval European city planning work?

Hi,

I'm trying to create a procedural medieval city generator (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procedural_generation), so I'm trying to understand how medieval cities were planned.

I'd like my generator to be able to grow cities organically. I.e. I'd like to run the simulation for 100 years and see a small settlement with a few basic industries and then continue for 1000 years to see a huge metropolis. I want to capture the way in which medieval European cities would have developed.

At the highest level I want to know How did medieval city planning work? (Was there any or did people just build where they wanted?)

Specific Questions:

  • Who got to decide where people built houses/shops? Did the owner of the castle sell plots off with more expensive plots being closer to the castle?

  • Were streets planned before there were houses? Did any building regulations exist about how wide the streets had to be?

  • Was the location of the market planned? Or would traders just put their stalls near major thoroughfares?

  • Why did houses become more packed towards the walls?

  • How did neighborhoods develop?

I have a bunch of assumptions that I would like to make. I'm not sure these are correct and I'd like some feedback on

  • The city was centered around a castle/fort with a nearby water and food supply

  • Richer people lived towards the cent e in large houses, whilst the slums were towards the walls and undesirable locations (ports etc).

  • Houses became smaller and more packed towards the walls.

Finally, can you suggest any reading material?

I'm aware that this might require quite an involved answer so thanks for your time.

1 Answers 2014-04-25

When was the last time heads of state actually fought in battle?

i find it interesting that what are now inbred royals stem from actual fighting nobles who earned their prestige on the battlefield.

4 Answers 2014-04-25

Was there any ancient conspiracy theories like there are in the 20th century?

Basically I mean were there any conspiracy theories like there are on the JFK assassination, Sept 11th, and so on?

3 Answers 2014-04-25

When Kublai Khan founded the Yuan Dynasty, did he see himself as a Chinese Emperor or a Mongol Khan?

I know that Kublai Khan was fond of Chinese culture, but was he aware that he will go down in history as the Chinese emperor who founded a new Chinese dynasty rather than the Mongol Khan who assimilated China into the Mongol Empire?

3 Answers 2014-04-25

After 1066, what did the Anglo-Saxons think of their new Norman rulers and vice-versa?

I'm curious as to if there are any historical texts which describes the relationship between the Anglo-Saxons and their new masters. Were they resented? Were they accepted? Similarly, did the Normans regard the Anglo-Saxons as inferior and barbaric?

And ultimately, when did the line between "Anglo-Saxon" and "Norman" disappear to make way for an "English" identity?

3 Answers 2014-04-25

How far in advance did people see the American Revolution coming?

Was it something that slowly built up over time? Was it all at once? Were people talking seriously about revolution 20 years in advance, or would such ideas have been dismissed as ridiculous?

I'm interested in the same for other major revolutions as well, if someone feels more qualified to answer on those fronts.

2 Answers 2014-04-25

Friday Free-for-All | April 25, 2014

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

24 Answers 2014-04-25

Historians, what do you think about Terry Dreary's history books?

TIL that Deary is a very popular author. He has a series called Horrible Histories. I never heard about this series before.

When asked about the radical undertones of his work, he told the newspaper: “That’s the way snaky propagandists do it. I’m poisoning the minds of children…yes!” (telegraph.co.uk)

Terry Deary has said of historians: "They are nearly as seedy and devious as politicians..They pick on a particular angle and select the facts to prove their case and make a name for themselves... They don’t write objective history... Eventually you can see through them all. They all come with a twist." (wiki)

1 Answers 2014-04-25

6819 / 7255

Back to start