The Red Army raped 2 million German women according to Wikipedia. Do we have any testimonies from the soldiers who did it, especially regarding how they viewed their actions later in life?

8 Answers 2014-03-26

Most Badass Person in history?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

What do modern Greek historians call the "Hellenistic" period?

How do Greek people refer to the Hellenistic period today? It seems like "Hellenistic" wouldn't make as much sense in Greek, right? Or am I over-thinking this?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

Why is their a difference on how many continents there are in different places in the world.

I've lived in America my entire life and in school I always learned that there are 7 continents (North America, South America, Europe, Asia, Africa, Australia, and Antarctica) but my mother from Italy always argued that there are 5 continents (America, Europe, Asia, Africa, Oceania) she uses the example that there are 5 Olympic rings for each continent which makes sense but I was wondering why there's a difference in different places on earth.

1 Answers 2014-03-26

How did Roman shield walls deal with phalanx formations?

I can't quite wrap my head around how the Roman's could deal with this match up from a hand to hand perspective. Greek style phalanx pikes seemed to have significant reach over the simple Roman gladius'. Aside from running in and impaling themselves on a wall of pikes, I don't see how the Roman formations could have even gotten close enough to Greek troops to cause any damage. Was there some special tactic the Roman's developed to deal with these formations?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

The 20th century saw drastic social, cultural, and technological change from its beginning to its end. Did this happen in other centuries?

We view the 1920s as completely different from the 1960s, and the 1970s as completely different from today. How did this work in say, the 16th century? Was the 1660s seen as completely different time from those in 1680? Or were things fairly stagnant up until the 20th century?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

How historically accurate is the video game Victoria 2?

Especially how historically accurate are the

•Game Mechanics

By Victoria 2 all the expansion pack including the main game are meant.

1 Answers 2014-03-26

What's a good book to read that discusses the American West sometime between Lewis and Clark and the Civil War?

I've been reading a lot of biographies lately, and find they're a great way to learn a bit of history (my history classes in school were pretty bad). I recently finished "Undaunted Courage," which is a biography of Meriwether Lewis, and am currently reading Dorris Kerns Goodwin's book about Roosevelt, Taft and the muckrakers, and I was struck by the yawning gulf between knowing nothing about anything west of the Mississippi at the beginning of the 18th century, and to having everything settled at the beginning of the 19th.

I've obviously heard about "the wild west" in pop culture, but is there a good book or biography that you'd recommend that would give me a sense of that time period?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

I keep reading about generals "meeting" for battle. Why did generals do this?

Ill explain myself; I heard how Hannibal or Scipio "waited" for the other side to assemble their troops. What's the point of this? Wouldn't it be better to attack the other guy while he's organising? Or is this a case of "getting more by licking rather than biting"?
Also, people seemed very eager to go to war back in the day. Wouldn't they have more or less a clear idea of who was going to win before hand, or this is a hindsight trap?

2 Answers 2014-03-26

How did Judaism's 'Satan' (Heaven's Attorney-General) become the evil ruler of the world in Christianity? (X-post from DebateReligion)

(I have posted this in DebateReligion first but have been advised to put it here. I am subscribed to r/AcademicBiblical but the community on there is very small and I figured you guys might also be able to help).

Hello, I would like to ask anybody who knows about the history and theology pertaining to the existence of the devil in Christianity and specifically how the concept of a malevolent supernatural evil ruling the physical world superseded the portrait of 'Satan' in the Hebrew Bible as a heavenly prosecutor who presented sinners before God to accuse them. I've read much of The Birth of Satan but I am still at a loss to how the Jesus movement in the 1st century CE, from the apostles to the Gospel writers and Paul's Gentile converts, came to believe in an 'evil one' who opposed everything God did and actively fought against the work of the Lord. The idea of the devil is so central to Christianity that one may say that as one must believe in Christ in order to be saved, one must also believe in (the existence of) the devil as an evil being in order for the entire narrative to make sense. I know some Christians have reinterpreted the devil to be an allegory for personal temptation and shortcomings, but ultimately the New Testament is very clear: the devil is real, the source of everything that is evil, the 'father of lies' and he will eventually be destroyed in the Lake of Fire. This picture seems so contradictory to everything about 'Satan' in the Old Testament/Hebrew Bible that it defies belief. The amount of projection involved in reconciling the two pictures does little service to Christianity, in my opinion. How many Christians believe that the serpent in Genesis is the devil or a servant of him based on a single vague reference to 'the ancient serpent' in Revelations? The Lucifer/king of Babylon/Satan elision is a similar problem. The amount of reinterpretation involved almost resembles retconning in fictional canons and for me, it presents great difficulty in believing the central tenets of the Bible. Popular folk beliefs that the devil 'rules hell' or will be responsible for torturing sinners himself are rooted in mythology and popular culture and are of course not in line with Christian orthodoxy. But then again, are these popular folk beliefs really that out of tune with the original role of Satan compared to Christian orthodox understanding of him? The 'movie Devil' who torments sinners in hell is at least serving a purpose for God in punishing the wicked, closer to his original Jewish perceptions than the world-ruler presented in the New Testament. If anyone can shed light on this it will help a lot. How common was belief in the "devil as evil world-ruler" before the ministry of Jesus? Had Second Temple Judaism produced a wider new understanding of 'Satan'? How influential were books like Enoch and the Life of Adam and Eve on the early Christians and the Gospel writers (bigger question I know but if it helps what I'm looking for)? And why didn't this understanding of the devil emerge earlier in the Hebrew Bible, if it is the correct understanding? I am seeking dates, places, books, specifics of who believed what and when. I read the Epistles and the Gospels and they seem to presume prior knowledge of the devil and what he does. Thanks for any and all perspectives

EDIT: Wow, was not expecting this level of a response, thanks everyone!

5 Answers 2014-03-26

Why was a revolver type mechanism never adopted for military rifles?

After seeing this video on the front page, I couldn't help but wonder why this type of gun was never adopted. I can't imagine a muzzle-loaded weapon being more efficient at putting rounds down range. Was it money or lack of craftsman able to create the mechanism? Thanks!

4 Answers 2014-03-26

Did the U.S. states that ratified the Constitution understand the government as a perpetual union? Or, did they feel that they had the right to withdraw from the Constitutional union if they felt it no longer served their interests? This is a repost from /r/USCivilWar

I suppose my question is did the states that ratified the Constitution feel they could leave the Union if they felt it no longer served their interests? I am thinking of the Nullification Crisis here. Though the Nullification Crisis didn't have anything to do with secession per se, it set a precedent for Southern states to feel as if they had a degree of sovereignty that they could exercise at will against the desires of the federal government. Was this idea of state autonomy a holdover from the times of the Articles of Confederation when they held a great deal of power, or was it brought along later with the Nullification Crisis?

2 Answers 2014-03-26

In the ancient world the valor of enemies was celebrated, how did it change to trash talking and demeaning the enemy?

How did "If our foes are noble and great, full of valor, and we defeat them, how great does that make us?" change into demeaning the other team/people/culture?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

Why didn't the residents of Hiroshima hear a noise when the bomb exploded?

In the book "Hiroshima" by John Hersey, he tells that no residents remember hearing a noise of an explosion, despite seeing a massive flash of light and being thrown across the room. An explosion that big should have made an unbelievable noise, right?

3 Answers 2014-03-26

Are there any good books written by Japanese WW2 veterans?

I'm looking for something from WW2 from the perspective of a Japanese soldier. Specifically something I can read in English.

2 Answers 2014-03-26

Are there any historical examples of an army causing a man-made "natural" disaster to attack the opposing side?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

Why was the Metropolitan Police Force established by Peel in 1929?

I'm just wondering why it was deemed to be necessary, didn't they have volunteer police forces? Why would the government decide they wanted to pay for a police force?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

Economic History books about the US Civil War?

I have a big interest in economic history and I'm really curious if there is a one volume work that provides a reasonably detailed look at the economic history of the US Civil War.

1 Answers 2014-03-26

How the flag bearers, standard bearers etc. fought in battles? What was their role in battle? Where in formation were they positioned? What happened when they were killed?

Some examples of what I mean: 1, 2, 3

5 Answers 2014-03-26

Has anyone calculated what the respective casualty rates for all wars would be with modern technology/medicine and vice versa?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

What were the Soviet "Shock Armies" and how were they used?

2 Answers 2014-03-26

How did the handedess of a warrior affect their fighting ability?

I assume most warriors with swords or shields were right handed, but I imagine a left-handed warrior would have a more difficult time during combat. Were there any advantages to being a different handiness that the majority? Or was life generally more difficult?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

Has there ever been a lifetime (say 65-80) years or so) of global peace?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

Wednesday What's New in History

Previous Weeks

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

2 Answers 2014-03-26

How did antebellum living conditions and treatment of slaves in rice-planting areas, like South Carolina, compare to those of cotton-planting regions, like Mississippi?

1 Answers 2014-03-26

6936 / 7255

Back to start