When Stalin initiated the Great Purge, did he know that a million people would end up being killed? Or did the purge snowball out of control?

2 Answers 2014-01-19

Had America stayed out of WWII, would it have had the same victors?

2 Answers 2014-01-19

[Homework] My AP World History Exam is coming up, and I'm lost on how to go about an essay for it on Han China and Maurya India

So our essay questions is to compare and contrast the political institutions in these two states, and I have no clue how to really go about this or what to say. Usually for history test essays I organize it in a five paragraph style, with a simple thesis but I'm not sure what mine should SAY. Here's what I have so far:

Thesis: The two states shared a similar governmental structure, bureaucracy, and internal/external policy, but despite these similarities differences in philosophical and social outlook caused these aspects of political institutions to widely diverge.

Things I talk about:

Same: -Gov: Absolute rule, Decentralized 'federations' -Bureaucracy: Scholarly class administration, advanced bureacracy performing public works, influenced by philosophical traditions, codified laws (Ashoka's edicts and Legalist influenced Confucianism) -Internal/External policy: Relative decentralization due to diversity, use of regional princes and vassals, powerful militaries.

Diff: -Gov: Han China was more homogenized, Maurya was more tolerant of other beliefs. -Bureaucracy: Meritocracy in Han China -Internal/External policies: Maurya played major international role, Han are isolationist (due to lower position of merchants). Maurya engaged in diplomatic maneuvering to 'annex' territory, Han relied on outright conquest.

The problems I have right now are a lack of things to say about the government in similarities and differences, differences in bureaucracy, and similarities in policy. I'm also not sure this is the best way of comparing political institutions. Any help available?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

Major differences between the Antiquity and Medieval eras?

  • Technology wise? (Eg: I've seen it said that medieval stonework was much better.)

  • Structure wise? (Eg: It feels like that there were more republics in Antiquity, although I may be wrong, and the Feudal System seems to have been a Medieval invention.)

  • Otherwise? (Feel free to chime in.)

Answers to any or all of the above welcome.

1 Answers 2014-01-19

Why did Botswana not experience the late-20th-century cycles of nationalist/populist uprisings and subsequent dictatorship that most countries in Africa experienced?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

How did the word "Latin", come to define a culture or race(i.e. Latin American, Latino)?

I have been searching around and I have found that "Latin" also means a native where their country's language developed from latin, so does that mean that people from Italy, France, Romania etc, are considered latin?

3 Answers 2014-01-19

Were there any prominent anti-slavery groups/activists in ancient Greece or Rome?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

How effective were flaming arrows, and was their use as prevalent as modern pop culture (Gladiator, Game of Thrones, Total War videogames etc...) would have us think?

In many works of historical and fantasy fiction, arrows doused in some flammable substance are set alight before firing at the enemy. How commonplace was this tactic in real life (if it was used at all) and if so what advantage would it confer? I have a hard time imagining a burning arrow actually setting anything on fire or having any practical use, were they used purely as a "shock and awe" tactic, to inspire fear into the enemy or were they more effective than one would think?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

Looking to pursue a PhD in History; am I crazy?

Hey r/askHistorians!

Over the last few months, I have been contemplating going back to school and going for my PhD in History. I have a Bachelor’s in History that I got 10 years ago, and been in the work force ever since (in an unrelated field.) I am embarking on a major change in my life (moving to New Zealand with my Husband) and am seeing this as an opportunity to pursue a life-long goal of mine.

I am posting because I worry about career opportunities after I get out of school. At a minimum, I will be in school for 4-6 years (either a 1 year honors course, then 3-4 years PHD, or a Masters, then a PHD) and when I finish, I will be in my late 30’s and out of the work force for that long. I also know that the History field (especially teaching) is competitive, and small. It also will be tough as I will be in New Zealand… not the best place to get a University level job. I know I could write books, textbooks, or other things, but I want to see… What can a historian actually do other than teach at a University?

However, I want to do this. I really want to pursue this, and not just because I can… but because I want to do something with it. I have a passion about history that I want to push further, and while I am hesitant, I want to do this so badly…

It is just the pragmatic part of me that needs reassurance.

I would love to teach, but I would love to explore other things: archives, research, writing… I just need some perspective, and some honesty… is it worthwhile to get my PHD? What should I expect the market place to be when I get out, and is it worth it?

9 Answers 2014-01-19

How important was the Aleutian Islands Campaign in World War II?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

Medieval Theatre

What was theatre like between the fall of Rome and the Renaissance? Was it open to everyone? What were some famous plays of the time period?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

I've heard that the South Afriance Apartheid Law was loosely based on Canada's Indian Act. Is there any truth to this rumor?

Title says it all. I did some googling around but couldnt find anything.

cheers!

1 Answers 2014-01-19

What do we know about religions in the Iberian Peninsula before Roman conquest, and before Christianisation?

Bonus question: Are there traces of those religions and beliefs that have made it to the present day?

2 Answers 2014-01-19

Can you give me a synopsis of Princess Diana??

1 Answers 2014-01-19

What is this artefact?

To whom it may concern,

I recently began a new project where I was given an artefact and I have to research who made it, why it was made, what was it used for, and learn how it connects to its time period. However, I have not been able to find out what it had been used for and could not find its purpose. I only know its obvious characteristics. The artefact is around 22 cm (8.6 inches) tall and is mainly made of wood. It also contains a spring in a mechanism that enables it to be opened by pushing on its top. On the artefact's circular hollow base with diameter around 9 cm (3.5 inches) there is a rectangular hole. Furthermore, there are two dark brown objects that are visible inside when the artefact is open. These objects are the same shape, but one of them has 8 miniature circular holes on the top and the other just has one large circular hole. They can be removed out of the artefact unlike two other objects inside that are light brown. They cannot be removed. The artefact itself seems completely intact.

Here are the links to several of the photos I took of the artefact:

The whole artefact - https://docs.google.com/a/isp.cz/file/d/0B-c3L1ULdDNMSi02RDdldC14NG8/

When open (from top view) - https://docs.google.com/a/isp.cz/file/d/0B-c3L1ULdDNMSUFsazRfZzNlRDA/

When open (from side view) - https://docs.google.com/a/isp.cz/file/d/0B-c3L1ULdDNMQWJnSDFNaXQzUGs/

The Brown Object with 8 holes from inside the artefact - https://docs.google.com/a/isp.cz/file/d/0B-c3L1ULdDNMUU15bXMxMFZiSXM/

The Brown Object with 1 hole from inside the artefact - https://docs.google.com/a/isp.cz/file/d/0B-c3L1ULdDNMblprSGhhVDlKX2c/

The rectangular opening at the artefact's hollow base - https://docs.google.com/a/isp.cz/file/d/0B-c3L1ULdDNMRGJzMGtWOWYwNlE/

Close-up to patterns on artefact: https://docs.google.com/a/isp.cz/file/d/0B-c3L1ULdDNMY3JZVER5UzZaUlk/

Can you please advise me about what it may have been used for? Nevertheless, any information about this artefact will be very appreciated.

2 Answers 2014-01-19

In WWII, bombers were well-armed with turrets. Why then was the development of long-range escort fighters so important?

I remember reading somewhere that the P-51 was a game-changer because it was able to escort bombers for their entire mission, thus keeping the bombers much safer.

Assuming this is correct, why did they make such a big difference if the bombers already had significant anti-air defenses?

3 Answers 2014-01-19

How many rights and privileges do the allies (especially the US) have over Germany today, if any?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

At what point in history did partitioning Ireland become a serious suggestion pursued by Unionists? At what point did the Irish Free State government accept it was a (or semi) permanent split?

As far as I'm aware the formation of the Ulster Volunteers by Carson wasn't a move to force partition rather it was to be used as a force to resist imposed home rule. At what point did unionist begin to suggest it as an alternative?

Under the Anglo-Irish treaty the Boundary Commission was established which the Free State government were told would involve a redrawn border involving the transfer of large areas of land south. The commission only suggested small transfers and ultimately was rejected by all sides.

But from reading on the issue it seems that many of those in government and civic society in the south saw partition as a temporary inconvenience with unification an incoming eventuality. At what point did this viewpoint change?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

Day of Reflection | January 13, 2014 - January 19, 2014

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2014-01-19

A question about Adolf Hitler and Eva Braun

Why is Eva Braun described as Hitlers 'mistress' and not 'girlfriend' or 'partner'?
I thought a mistress is a woman in a sexual relationship with a married man, but Hitler wasn't married until he and Eva Braun wed just before committing suicide?

3 Answers 2014-01-19

Which medieval castles were the hardest to besiege and what key defensive features did they have?

10 Answers 2014-01-19

I know it is a thorny subject, but if Britain claimed The Falkland Islands (Islas Malvinas) in 1690 (later reclaimed in 1833), and Argentina wasn't a united country until 1853 (facing civil unrest and civil war up to this point). What legitimate claims does Argentina have to the islands

4 Answers 2014-01-19

Why do some people believe the Boston Massacre was an Indirect Cause for the Revolution?

like the title states i'd like to know why modern day people think this and if they don't what their opinion is.

1 Answers 2014-01-19

How often was "The Plank" a mode of punishment during the heyday of Piracy?

Also, what was the most common cause of death for victims of this punishment? Hypothermia, drowning, predators etc.

2 Answers 2014-01-19

During the Middle Age and maybe before, was cannibalism common?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

7190 / 7255

Back to start