Why did American military tactics change back to more archaic styles (such as standing in rows and shooting) after the success of guerrilla style fighting during the Revolution?

I'm watching a documentary on American history. It said that there was unprecedented bloodshed because they used a new, deadlier type of bullet with more accurate weapons. This was particularly deadly because the tactics they were using hadn't adapted to the new weapons and soldiers did a lot of standing and shooting at one another.

This stood out to me because a decent part of our success against Britain during the revolution was because of hit and run tactics. It also stated that the south was outnumber more than three to one. How did the south deal with being so outnumbered if soldiers were standing and shooting? It seems like those tactics would rely on having more soldiers firing more bullets.

1 Answers 2014-01-11

AMA - Pre-20th Century Western Visual Arts

Welcome to this AMA which today features nine panelists willing and eager to answer your questions on Pre-20th Century Western Visual Arts.

Our panelists are:

  • /u/darwinfinch Greek Art and Literature: My expertise lies in Greek art in general, and I'd be happy to answer questions about Minoan and Classical Greek art, though I'm also able to answer questions about the more popular aspects of archaic Greek and Mycenaean art. I can also talk about archaeology in Athens and have done a good deal of research on some "mystery" items such as the antikythera mechanism and the Phaistos disk. /u/darwinfinch has been unexpectedly detained and will be joining us a lot later.

  • /u/Claym0re Early Roman Art and Architecture | Mathematics in Antiquity:

  • /u/kittycathat Classical Art: My specialty is ancient Roman art, but I can also answer questions on ancient Greek, ancient Egyptian, and Medieval art. The topics on which I am particularly knowledgeable are the layout and decoration of the ancient Roman house, early Christian art in Rome and Ravenna, and medieval manuscript illumination.

  • /u/farquier Medieval and Renaissance Painting and Manuscripts: I am currently finishing a BA in Art History focusing on Armenian manuscript painting. I tend to be more familiar with the Italian Renaissance and English manuscripts. I am also comfortable discussing a wider range of topics in Medieval and Renaissance art in Western Europe, as well as Byzantine art.

  • /u/GeeJo Depictions of Women: The object of my studies has been on how artists have chosen to depict women, and how such images reflect upon their societies' own preconceptions about the role and nature of femininity. My MA in Art History focused primarily on the Victorians and the work of the Pre-Raphaelites in particular, though I'm happy to accept questions from wider afield.

  • /u/butforevernow Renaissance and Baroque Art: I have a BA (Hons) in Art History and am working on my Masters, specialising in 17th and 18th century Spanish art. I currently work as an assistant curator at a small art gallery with a collection of mainly Australian art, and I am hoping to move overseas in the next few years to work with a more internationally focused collection. My areas of interest are Spanish, Italian, and French painting ~1500-1800.

  • /u/Axon350 Photography | Firearms: I study the history of photography. My specialties include war photography in the 19th century, 'instantaneous' photography, and the development of color technology. The oldest camera I own is from 1905.

  • /u/zuzahin 19th c. Photography: My expertise lies in 19th century photography, and in particular the evolution and invention of color photography throughout the 20th century.

  • /u/Respectfullyyours Canadian History l Portraiture & Photography in Canada 1880-1940: I specialize in Canadian portraiture, particularly within Montreal from 1800s-1930s.

Let's have your questions!

Please note: our panelists are located in three different continents and won't all be online at the same time. But they will get to your questions eventually!

16 Answers 2014-01-11

How influential were Armored vehicles (Tanks, Armored Cars, etc) in the outcome and conclusion of WWI?

Obviously this was the debut of a lot of technologies that really ended up flourishing in the Second World War, but my question is whether or not they really played a decisive role in the end of the first one.

2 Answers 2014-01-11

How likely was a Communist takeover in 1960s Brazil?

This year marks the anniversary of 50 years of the military coup that ousted president Goulart. It was alleged that he was a communist sympathiser and that Brazil was in the brink of a revolution. How much of this is true?

1 Answers 2014-01-11

What would the world be like if the revolutionary war in america never happened?

1 Answers 2014-01-11

How come Ireland got christanized so early?

Ho come most of Ireland was christian by the 6th century despite little to none Roman contact, and Irish missionairies had to christianize other parts of Europe (Great-Britain, Low countries, Germania, Gaul) that had more contact with Roman culture and thus christianity?

1 Answers 2014-01-11

What did navels look like on people before modern medicine?

1 Answers 2014-01-11

Has there ever been a movement in the U.S. to abolish the electoral college?

If so could you explain when, why, and what regions of the country it occurred. Any sources on the event would be much appreciated.

1 Answers 2014-01-11

When did we start to associate mint with fresh breath?

I was wondering about this when brushing my teeth this morning. Was mint always associated with fresh breath or is this something recent?

1 Answers 2014-01-11

Saturday Reading and Research | January 11, 2014

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

6 Answers 2014-01-11

Was there was any apparent fear in the Carthaginian senate and the aristocracy that Hannibal winning the Second Punic war would be against their interest, that it would make him too powerful? Was there reluctance on their part to send Hannibal reinforcements and recourses needed to win the war?

Aristotle held the Carthaginian form of government in high regard. But I get the impression that one of the main reasons that Carthage lost to Rome was their government's disinterest in a grand coordinated military strategy. Is this plausible?

Broadly my question is how effective was the Carthaginian government, primarily in millitary matters?

2 Answers 2014-01-11

In several WWII films and TV series, snipers stay behind in abandoned locations to kill occupying forces. These snipers were always killed after inflicting a few deaths. (1) Was this a common tactic on all sides? (2) How did they get snipers to engage in such suicidal behavior?

I suppose there are three questions:

  • Do films and TV series accurately portray the plight of snipers during WWII?
  • As most WWII depictions that I've seen are from an Allied POV, it's usually German snipers that are left behind in towns occupied by the Allies. Was this a common tactic for Allied snipers as well?
  • If a sniper is left alone in a town occupied by hundreds or thousands of enemy soldiers, he will surely meet his demise if he starts shooting. How did they get snipers to engage in such suicidal behavior?

A fourth slightly related question:

edit: for an example, see this scene from Band of Brothers.

8 Answers 2014-01-11

How did the Romans have enough men to field armies in all the occupied countries?

I was thinking, did the Romans recruit locals or was it a pure Italian army? For example somehow they had enough men to cover all of Europe and even occupy forts in north Scotland.

I assumed they wouldn't recruit natives as they could rebel etc.

1 Answers 2014-01-11

Is there any real difference about "noble blood" that made it such a class separator throughout history?

I think the obvious answer to this question is no, that noble blood has no inherent "better" properties to separate it from peasant blood. That the only really difference is the way different wealth classes are raised and live day to day - that if anything, constant "noble" breeding among a select population had instead lead to matchups within one's own family line, leading to weaker genes if anything.

But there is just such ubiquitous fixation on discriminating for "pure" and "noble" bloodlines throughout history over cultures across the world (still seen even today) that I can't help but second guess myself if there really may have been some special property to noble blood. Mayhaps in the past? Before bloodlines became increasingly mixed over time?

So is there answer to whether or not noble genes/royal blood ever had a difference that legitimized its separation it from common blood?

To expand on this question, I've noticed that in many instances in history, there may often be "take-overs" where one noble ruling power becomes unseated. And what ends up happening is that the take-overs, be they from significant lineage or not, will suddenly be the new "noble" power. I think occurrences like these demonstrate that noble blood has no real difference from common blood (as they can interchange, ie a noble celt would be a common roman), but more revealingly, bring up the question of: why was noble blood such a commonly used claim to legitimacy?

1 Answers 2014-01-11

Were there any proposed Nuclear Weapon tests deemed too dangerous or unpredictable to proceed with? Whether through ambition or eccentricity.

4 Answers 2014-01-11

Who is considered to be the last religious martyr in North America to be executed based on actual religion faith and practices (Note: Non Native American)? When were they executed, and where?

1 Answers 2014-01-11

How did the public view Richard Nixon after impeachment

I'm too young to have been around after he was impeached. How was he seen to the public? I know he was mocked, but for example: Did the country mourn after he died? Was he still viewed as a good political theorist? (If that's the right terminology) Was he still a respectable man? Were people ever excited to meet him?

A google search only led me to information about his impeachment. Nothing after.

1 Answers 2014-01-11

During the middle ages, what was the common way to travel from England to Acre/Jerusalem, and how long did it take?

I've been trying to find out how a small group of individuals would travel in approx. 1190. From my research on Google I've looked at maps from the third crusade which shows both boat and land travel, but I'm not sure if someone not involved in the crusades would take those routes or not. Additionally, I've not been able to discover how long it would have taken, as I've seen sources which say from one year to three.

1 Answers 2014-01-11

France and Israel

Hello

I always think of the USA as being Israels main ally both politically and militarily.

However I was reading some about the 60ties and 70ties wars in the middle east and during this period it seems Israel was largely armed with French advanced planes (Mirages)?

It also seems that France helped with the Israeli nuclear program?

Could anyone explain how this fits together? What French interests did this support serve?

2 Answers 2014-01-11

What was the impact of the East/West split in Germany on modern nationalistic identity and culture? Do people identify as East/West/(region) German or just German?

I've always been interested on the impact that re-unification has had on Germany, rather, the impact of the split. Did people like the split at the time/when they were unified? What was its impact?

2 Answers 2014-01-11

How did the Soviets lose the war in Afghanistan when they were able to push back the might of the German army in WW2?

I've been wondering this for awhile... thanks if you can shed a little light on this for me!

1 Answers 2014-01-11

Did the Allies have a specific plan/protocol for if Hitler was taken prisoner alive in 1945?

Or would he have simply been tried at Nuremberg?

1 Answers 2014-01-11

How did the settlement of western Canada compare with the settlement of the western United States?

Things I'm especially interested in hearing about:

Did Canadians have a narrative comparable to Manifest Destiny?

Did the interactions of westward migrants and natives differ from the patterns seen in the US? If so, how?

Were the economic motivations of Canadian settlers similar to those of settlers in the US?

3 Answers 2014-01-11

In the equal field system in Tang/Song China, who would receive what land upon the owner's death?

This question came up in one of my classes and no one could really answer it.

In the equal field system in Tang/Song China the land was split upon the owner's death among others, that part was clear to us. What we couldn't find though it did the (wealthy) land owner's family inheritor have any say in what land he received during this change, or was in government decided? Surely some land must be more arable then others from all of which that they own, as some would be more preferred to keep than others.

1 Answers 2014-01-11

Was John Brown (abolitionist) a terrorist? If not, why?

2 Answers 2014-01-11

7218 / 7255

Back to start