How did Stalin manage to gain a foothold in Soviet leadership when the government was run by a clique that had rampant nepotism?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

How much money did various medieval nobles make?

I know "various medieval nobles" is vague but i would just like to know as much as i can.

I would prefer later periods (14th/15th centuries), preferably english or western european nobles.

I of coure know that there would be plenty of variation due to differances in population, teritory, income, prosperity... but would still like to know.

2 Answers 2018-02-24

Why is one-wall handball so popular in New York City but practically non-existent elsewhere?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

Security clearance for Presidents?

Hello presidential historians - first a couple questions about the US:

  • Are presidents required to get background checks and top secret security clearances from the FBI before they take office?
  • If its not a requirement now, has it ever been in the past?

And for a global perspective:

  • How does the policy in the US compare to other countries, from a historical perspective.

Thanks!

2 Answers 2018-02-24

What caused the spread of anti-Semitism in Europe?

I recently learned that Hitler didn't exactly decieve people into hating Jews, but rather used pre-existing beliefs in his favor. People already generally didn't like them, and using them as a scapegoat for more issues helped fuel his campaign. Why did so many people already feel this way?

I'm also curious about why he took certain positions. I find it odd that he was so pro-Aryan and a German nationalist, when he wasn't really either. Did any citizens pick up on him not being Aryan? Did his government or group or whatever try to explain this?

Edit to add another detail. One claim I've heard (though only through media so I don't know if people believe/believed it) is that Jewish people 'killed Jesus'. I don't know, however, if the Nazi party cared strongly about Christianity. I believe I read that Hitler didn't care but Himmler was interested in the occult or something. I also don't know where the claim came from, as the Romans killed Jesus on the cross (if I remember correctly).

1 Answers 2018-02-24

Looking for resources on Nazi Party misuse of history

I'm getting ready to start the WWII era with a class of High School sophomores. One of the things I am emphasizing throughout the course is responsible use of primary sources and critical inquiry to cast doubt on outlandish historical claims. Basically, I'm trying to inoculate my students against the worst of Youtube-style thinking by providing some tools for them to be able to think like historians.

I'm aware of some critiques of Fascism and Nazism regarding how fast and loose they liked to play with historical fact, and I would love suggestions to go deeper into that as I prepare this section of the course. While it's about Holocaust denial, I considered using this video from Deborah Lipstadt as a student-facing resource. Unfortunately I've got to be careful, as I'm teaching in a quite conservative area and I feel I'll have more success with my students if the material I'm using doesn't take thinly veiled swipes at the President. As a result, this one is off the table.

So, is anyone here aware of a concise source to give an overview of Nazi abuses of history in their rise to power? (I'd love any longer, more in depth reading recommendations as well, for my own benefit!)

1 Answers 2018-02-24

How did the 12 hour clock come about?

It’s not divided into night and day like early cultures would divide time. Midday seems like the reasonable time to make the midpoint of your clock. Wikipedia says early clockfaces were 24 hours but “During the 15th and 16th centuries, the 12-hour analog dial and time system gradually became established as standard throughout Northern Europe for general public use”. Why was that?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

After Shakespear's Caesar came onto theatres of the day, how did 16th-17th century people react to the notion of a republic or voting?

Greetings,

from what I see, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar has many connotations one could view as quite dangerous for not just the monarchies of the day, but the very structure of society of many areas in Europe at the time.

Was the play suppressed by the ruling classes anywhere?

How did the general public react to the notions of a government formed from voting in representatives? Or even the notion of someone refusing a crown being a virtue as presented in the play?

4 Answers 2018-02-24

How did people buy airline tickets before the internet?

Commercial airlines started in the 1920s and the Internet didn't really take off until the 2000s. How did people buy airline tickets/pick seats? Did they go to stores or directly to the airport?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

Elevators in Weimar Germany

In the first episode of Babylon Berlin, which takes place partly in the police headquarters of the City of Berlin during 1929, the elevators seem quite unsafe. They don't seem to halt between floors, don't have doors, and people just have to quickly jump off at what would be their stop.

Is this simply the makers taking an artistic liberty or did at lest some elevators actually at one time work like this? If so, is this contextually-accurate?

2 Answers 2018-02-24

What does Ancient Greece refer to?

I am looking into Ancient Hellas and its history for final exams. The sources I'm reading seem to skip dates and I cannot grasp the periods especially when it comes to Athens and Sparta.

So far this is what I found:

Bronze Age

Minoan civilization: Lived on the island of Crete, flourished around 2000BC. This was the first "advanced" civilizations in Europe. Peaceful people, they were traders on the sea. Due to natural disasters and Mycenaean Greeks, it was destroyed.

Mycenaean Greeks: Lived in during 1600-1100BC. They were the first civilization on mainland Greece. The made up the last phase of the Bronze age. These guys had bronze weapons, they waged wars against each other for land and the built big fortresses. These were the guys who destroyed Troj. During the wars, they weakened and their civilization crumbled.

Dark ages

Dorians, Ionians: Time: 8th century BC. These greek tribes migrated through Greece and settled. They created poleis and instead of a kingdom, they formed an aristocratic republic.

Greek colonization: Time 8-6th century BC. Now we can talk about Athens and Sparta. Also during this time, Greeks started colonization due to overpopulation, not enough lands, political conflicts and for better economy. And also Democracy was a thing during this time.

Is all the above correct? Also when I say ancient Greece, what time period does that include? Everything I just mentioned?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

Saturday Showcase | February 24, 2018

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

3 Answers 2018-02-24

Was it a real thing to give names to weapons?

Or was this introduced by fantasy novels?

If it was a thing, what are some weapons one should know?

2 Answers 2018-02-24

Why where Hitlers speeches and his book "Mein Kampf" succesful in Germany?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

During ww2, the soviets had anti-retreat forces. Why did they use them and were they effective?

I recently watched Enemy At the Gates and they had these units in the film gunning down fleeing men, did this happen like that? I cant wrap my head around that this might well of happened.

1 Answers 2018-02-24

Isn't Pre-columbian trans-atlantic contact confirmed to have taken place?

Heyo! Wanted to ask this question here for obvious reasons :P Basically, I hear a lot of people discussing where contact between Europeans and Indigenous Americans took place before columbus. I remember hearing about an account of an Irish monk travelling to America long before Columbus, and that the Vikings reached the continent as well. I am sure these both happened, yet I see countless debates online whether the Europeans reached America or vice versa. Any confirmation on this?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

Who were the students at pre-modern universities? Were they typically nobles, urban patricians or commoners?

3 Answers 2018-02-24

Why was Ancient Rome so aggressive?

Why did they become empire-builders instead of peaceful traders?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

Book recommendations re: Arditi

"O la vittoria, o tutti accoppati" / "We either win, or we all die"


"Unfortunately, Italian military archives contain very little documentation regarding the Reparti d'assalto. Therefore, it is very difficult to reconstruct a history of their military actions."


I've been searching for books or histortial accounts about the Arditi for around a year now and I've not been able to find adequate works on them. I'm primarily looking for anything regarding their entire history, the roles they played in war and peace time Italy, and ESPECIALLY any by ex-members or that have first hand accounts of their activities.

I was wondering, or hoping is perhaps a better word to use, that someone here may know of any. My next port of call is to start tracking down WWI historians from Italy's universities via phone/email. I am a born and raised Yorkshireman but my old man is Italian. Unfortunately I haven't seen much of him since I was around 10 years of age, meaning I never had the opportunity to really pick the language up - making it an uphill struggle to get in touch with them and have decent communication (exasperated further by a broad Yorkshire accent!!). I am committed to doing so if needs be though.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2018-02-24

In antiquity, an urbanized Italy was sustained by massive shipments of grain from North Africa, Egypt, and the Roman provinces. What did the Mediterranean grain trade look like through the High/Late Middle Ages, that allowed Italy to reurbanize?

Through the 13th, 14th, 15th centuries the cities of Italy, Venice, Genoa, Milan, Florence, Pisa, Naples, Rome, all grew to be cities of 50, or 100, or even 200 thousand people. How were these cities fed?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

How many people living in the U.S. today can trace their lineage to living in the U.S. in the 1700s or earlier?

I hope my title makes sense. I'm not sure if there's a definitive answer for this, but I figured this would be a good place to try. So how many people currently living in the United States can trace their ancestors back to the 1700s in the U.S? I know immigration to the U.S. surged in the mid 19th century, and has always been pretty prominent. By that I mean that a lot of people have immigrated here in the last 200ish years. (please correct me if I'm wrong on that.) I recently figured out that I can trace my ancestry back to person who lived in Maryland in the 1760s, and I think that's awesome. How many people have a similar story as I do? Thank you.

2 Answers 2018-02-24

When was the Bible first split into it's verses? Who decided what constituted a "verse" and why was it determined that way?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

Why were Janissaries obsessed with kitchen-related things?

I've been reading A Military History of the Ottomans by Mesut Uyar and Edward J. Erickson, and it's really interesting. Really helps me understand what the Ottoman Empire was, and what classes of people constituted its military throughout its early history. But then, on page 39, I came across the strangest thing: "The most revered object for entire Janissary corps was the sacred cauldron 'Kazan-ı Serif.'

And later, the book mentions that many junior officer positions were named after positions in the kitchen, because the cauldron was so sacred. So my question is: why?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

Was there a larger debate on whether or not to count southern votes in the election of 1864?

This is something I’ve always been curious about. By this point presumably the Confederacy was definitely considered “out” of the Union, but certain places like Louisiana have records of electoral votes even though they ultimately were not counted. Was there a greater discussion on whether or not to allow these votes? Or was the decision relatively unanimous? Additionally: For the records in Louisiana, how was this information disseminated? Did the Confederacy allow vote information to be easily released to the Union since they voted for Lincoln?

1 Answers 2018-02-24

In the event no candidate for the U.S. Presidency wins the Electoral College, when does the House/Senate vote for the next President elect/Vice President elect? (post-20th Amendment)

I'm aware the Electoral College votes on the first Monday after the second Wednesday in December. Is there a specified time/date for the House and Senate to cast their votes? Does this occur with the current session of Congress, is it delayed until the start of the next session, or is the time left to be decided by the House/Senate?

2 Answers 2018-02-24

⯇ 2799 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start