Congratulations to Andrés Reséndez, Heather Ann Thompson and Nancy Tomes for winning this year's Bancroft Prize!

1 Answers 2017-03-15

Whats the difference between Eastern Roman administration and feudalism?

2 Answers 2017-03-15

What would've happened to Eva Braun if she didn't commit suicide?

I guess it would be obvious why Hitler killed himself. But did his (newly-wed) wife commit any punishable crimes?

2 Answers 2017-03-15

Why wasn't Luxembourg incorporated into the German Empire?

1 Answers 2017-03-15

What historical questions can you ask a 70 y/o American?

A 70 year old guy is coming to my history class next wednesday and we're supposed to ask him questions related to history. Any suggestions as to what I can ask him?

3 Answers 2017-03-15

Are there correlations/predictive factors for fashion cycles?

I remember reading that men's ties tend to be wider in times of more rapid economic growth and I was wondering if there are other noted trends like this.

1 Answers 2017-03-15

Is this type of clothing familiar to anyone?

I'm trying to find out some information about this painting. It's likely European and was restored in the mid-20th century in Boston. (Not signed.) I'm not sure how old it is, but I thought perhaps the clothing might indicate something about this man's position. Any thoughts?

1 Answers 2017-03-15

Why are the colonial British, French, Spainish, and Portuguese empires viewed as so great in comparison to Southern European,Middle Eastern and Asian empires?

For the record I am talking about colonial France, not napoleonic france. So we view the aformentioned empires as some of the greatest in history but is it warranted? Sure they conquered huge amounts of land but they took most of it from weak Native American and African tribes. Are they really on the same level as the Romans ottomans, Mughals , Chinese, Persians, Greeks etc? The latter had smaller empires but they fought against opponents that were nearly their equals.

1 Answers 2017-03-15

Did the potato famine of 1845 help lead to the creation of the Republic of Ireland in 1919?

I've been told that the potato famine was the birth of Irish nationalism, but can this be considered a key factor leading to the cessation of Ireland from the United Kingdom?

1 Answers 2017-03-15

Why didn't the Great Depression balance itself out?

Speaking purely in terms of effects on America (not other nations), I don't see why the Great Depression didn't quickly balance itself out. Both consumers and suppliers were poor, and I can't imagine that the same suppliers (merchants, shop owners) that were selling to the extremely poor were selling to the extremely wealthy. So why didn't the classes, being extreme opposite, divide and balance out? Obviously the upper class needed no help but I don't see why poor suppliers and producers balanced out with the poor consumers to make two balanced classes, and therefore a balanced nation. So what prevented this?

1 Answers 2017-03-15

Was the discovery of Australia and New Zealand kept secret from the general population of Europe, what was to stop anybody from heading there before a colony was formed? Also were there any myths about this new found land that the common person might have heard during the time

1 Answers 2017-03-15

Battle of Cannae research help

Hi all, I'm doing a research question on the battle of Cannae and whether or not after the battle should Hannibal have marched for Rome. I do have some idea of what happened during and after the battle which would help my arguments but do you guys have any other advice of what to do?

heres what i know (pretty sure i know more but cant think right now and need guidance):

  • Hannibal destroyed Rome's army, so lot of Roman casualties

  • some of the allies kinda defected? not sure what word to use

  • one of the greatest military battles but huge disappointment history wise for rome

  • afterwards Rome was like panicing cause they got defeated and loss allies = less numbers for their armies ( this is after the latin alliance citizenship thing where they make other states give troops right?)

  • battle led to the change and reformation of the Roman army

  • something happened and Carthage stopped supporting Hannibal (guess this means lack of resources to march upon rome)

  • at some point after the battle Hannibal did march upon Rome but was unsuccessful

  • this was during the second punic war

  • read somewhere forgot where that Hannibal was like exiled

  • Roman battle formation was so bad that it was why they lost the battle

i apologise in advanced for the shitty grammar i have been awake since 5:30 am on Wednesday and now its 1:40 am on Thursday.

1 Answers 2017-03-15

If Galileo was the first known person to use telescopes in astronomy, how did ancient and medieval astronomers tell the difference between stars and planets?

So as far as I was taught in school, astronomy is a very old field of study and that astronomers have distinguished between planets and stars for a long time. How were they able to do so if Galileo is the first known person to have used telescopes to observe the sky? How did older astronomers know the planets were not stars?

1 Answers 2017-03-15

When did doctors in the US stop making house calls? And why?

At what point in US history did this shift take place and what were the economic and/or sociological forces that prompted this shift?

1 Answers 2017-03-15

Wednesday What's New in History | March 15, 2017

Previous weeks!

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

1 Answers 2017-03-15

How has the historiography of the First World War changed over time?

When I was learning about WWI in high school (mid-2000s) I was taught that the War was inevitable. Going off my history textbook, a global war was pretty much bound to happen due to things like the overlapping network of alliances, great power competition, and technological change.

Has this always been the narrative surrounding the First World War? For example, would textbooks in the 1920s or 1930s have portrayed the war as the "inevitable" result of European international relations? Did the Second World War change how the causes of the First World War were viewed?

I'm not asking whether or not the "inevitable" view is "correct", but rather has that always been the main way of presenting the narrative.

2 Answers 2017-03-15

How reliable was pilot kill counts during WW2? What kept pilots from inflating their scores for personal gain, or countries from doing the same for propaganda purposes?

6 Answers 2017-03-15

During the Civil War, the Union Navy included a large number of escaped slaves and freemen serving in integrated units, while the Army only included a fairly limited number of African American soldiers, serving in segregated units. What factors explain these differences?

What was it about the histories, missions, and leaders of the Northern Army and Navy that lead them to handle this issue quite differently?

1 Answers 2017-03-15

I want to learn about the middle ages

I want to learn about the medieval era, as well as the ancient (with romans and greeks) and the renaissance, but mostly middle ages. For the time being, I am just interested in Europe.

My question is: Do you know any good books or websites or other sources to learn about this?

I want to learn both the fun stuff and the mundane things, ranging from

  • How did a regular day look like for a lord or peasant

  • what food they ate

  • housing, a commoners house and a castle

  • the feudal system

  • a lot of terminology

all the way to

  • warfare and weaponry (apparently sieges were popular and so were polearms)

  • armor (studded leather seems to be just fantasy)

  • some interesting wars

So I would be very appreciative if someone would help me. I want to learn about these eras but I don't know where to begin, and if it is not a war it is pretty difficult to look up (especially when I don't even know what to search for).

2 Answers 2017-03-15

Would a slash across the chest with a longsword kill you?

It seems as if in most film a slash across the chest is an instant kill. Is this historically accurate?

1 Answers 2017-03-15

As an amateur, what are my best resources for learning more about the history of my city?

I am from Minneapolis.

What are the best resources I have, from my city, that I can use to learn about its history?

I'm interested in materials that are beyond just "books about Minneapolis" at a library.

Are there departments at local universities I should look at? Which ones are the best to pursue?

I've been making it my goal to learn as much as I can about Minneapolis history. It was never touched on in my public schooling, but I want to learn more.

Any general tips on where to get good information on one's city would be greatly appreciated.

3 Answers 2017-03-15

Any Ideas for a topic on my history paper?

Here is my prompt for the paper

Soviet History in 10 Objects: A Gallery The result of this collaborative project will be a veritable museum of your own creation. In groups of two or three, using the TimelineJS online slideshow creator, you will create a multimedia slideshow that narrates something compelling about Soviet history using images of ten objects of your choosing from the region. Each slide/object should be accompanied by a short paragraph (4-5 sentences) of description. Tell us what the object is, when and where it is from, and why it is on display in your gallery. What does the object tell us about Soviet history? How does it relate to the gallery’s overall theme?

Any Ideas?? something that I could find a lot of sources for?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-03-15

Why did Hitler choose to rebuild Germany, instead of trying to rebuild the Austro-Hungarian Empire?

Hitler was born and grew up in Austria, so why did he choose to rebuild Germany, instead of Austria-Hungary, his home country?

2 Answers 2017-03-15

Why weren't Guam and the Northern Marianas just grouped into one territory following the latter's acquisition?

They're part of the same archipelago; did being colonized by different powers following the Spanish-American War really result in such a distinction worth maintaining?

1 Answers 2017-03-15

Where did the English royal family (i.e. King, Queen, etc.) live during WW2? How were they kept safe from German bombings?

Hello, I was just wondering if the British royal family was living in Buckingham palace during WW2, as that would seem quite dangerous due to German bombings.

1 Answers 2017-03-15

⯇ 3542 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start