If Kurds were really the descendents of the Medes, then why do they claim to be indigenous to the Zagros mountains and northern Mesopotamia?

All the maps on the internet show the Medes south west of the Caspian sea.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-Wc9e0RyFORY/VU06jSleWkI/AAAAAAAAUmY/CzjtT2a_4Aw/s1600/ancient-assyria%2B-%2Bmedes.jpg

http://courses.wcupa.edu/jones/his101/web/pix/persia-s.jpg

http://www.historywiz.com/images/neareast/neareastmap.png

(sorry about the horrible english)

1 Answers 2017-01-27

History of Persia

I have been curious for a while now about the history of Persia, but cannot find satisfying books. I'm interested in the continuous history of Persia from antiquity to the 15th century as a civilization and geopolitical entity. An introductory book basically. Preferably written by scholars.

Any suggestions?

3 Answers 2017-01-27

What was life like for Hispanics/Latinos in pre-Civil Rights Act America? Did they suffer the same types of discrimination as African-Americans?

My middle school students asked me this when we talked about the Civil Rights Movement and MLK, and I realized I hadn't been taught much about how Hispanics fit into the white vs black society we discuss in relation to the Civil Rights Movement. I know some about Cesar Chavez and the United Farm Workers movement, but just learning about that piece of Hispanic history suggests that most Hispanics in the US in the 60s were farm workers. That seems too simplistic.

I think the question I'm trying to get at is, in social interactions with white Americans, and in the eyes of the law, were Hispanics considered second class citizens to the same degree as African-Americans during this time period?

3 Answers 2017-01-27

Why Christology was so Important to Byzantine People?

It has never been satisfactorily explained why thousands of ordinary people were ready to suffer persecution, even death, for the proposition that the incarnate Christ was either in (en) or derived from (ek) two natures, but they were certainly convinced that their opponents were gravely in error in either dividing or confusing the person of the one Christ [...]And then, just as mysteriously as theological fervour had started, so it died down. Or so it seems because no more ecclesiastical histories were written after the year 600. Monothelitism, which was but a pale continuation of Monophysitism inspired by political considerations, was laid to rest by the council of 680. That was the last of the ‘noble’ heresies. The issue of Iconoclasm, which was artificially inflated into a Christological heresy, was in reality concerned with observance, i.e. cultus, and that in itself was indicative of a new development: Byzantine Christianity had reverted to being a religio in the Roman sense.

What are some theories that could help explain the question posed in this quote (in italics)?

Also, where intense religious feelings/experiences in general come from? How much truth is in the claim that religion is basically politics in disguise?

2 Answers 2017-01-27

When did Ambulances change from special taxis that took you to the hospital to providing actual care until you arrive? What (Or who) prompted this change?

I was watching the directors commentary on an episode of Mad Men, one where Roger has a heart attack, in the commentary one of the writer said that Ambulances in the early sixties basically hoped you'd still be alive by the time you got to the hospital. Obviously this changed into the kind of care you get now but when was this change made? What was the main cause for the change and who made it?

2 Answers 2017-01-27

I was just watching an interview with Chris Matthews where he said when a new President is sworn in the white house is redecorated almost immediately (at least that was his experience of the Carter to Reagan transfer). Did LBJ do it that quickly or did he wait so as not to appear in bad taste?

according to Chris Matthews he stayed in the white house for lunch after the inauguration and as he was eating people came in and replaced all of Carter's art work, furniture and family photos with Reagan's stuff

2 Answers 2017-01-27

How fast was news of the Pearl Harbor attack communicated to American citizens?

Hi all — my turn to ask a question of you, because I'm not steeped in the Pearl Harbor literature.

Pearl Harbor was attacked by the Japanese starting around 7:45AM Hawaiian time. When did the news agencies on the American mainland start broadcasting information about the attack? (A colleague of mine remembers, as a child, listening to the Jack Benny Show on the radio in 1941, and remembers it being interrupted with news of Pearl Harbor, if that is helpful.)

I am curious about the speed of "major" news information at that time. FDR seems to have gotten news of it around 1:30pm, which would imply a little over an hour after it started (if my time zone math is right). But I don't know when the first broadcasts would have began, and am curious.

1 Answers 2017-01-27

Presidential Financial Well-Being After their Term

Curious if anyone has insight on President's that may have struggled financially post-White House. I'm sure most were rich enough to be living luxurious lifestyles but was wondering if there was an odd man out. This thought was sparked by the Clintons "struggling" relatively speaking according to Hillary. Thanks!

3 Answers 2017-01-27

Friday Free-for-All | January 27, 2017

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

18 Answers 2017-01-27

What are some understudied parts of Hitler's rise to power?

I am looking to do an undergraduate dissertation a certain aspect of Hitler's rise to power. I was initially interested to write about the British press and their reaction to his ascension to the chancellorship 1932-33. However it seems as if this is already covered in: "A Mirror of Nazism : British Opinion and the Emergence of Hitler, 1929-1933" by Brigitte Granzow from the 1960s.

I was just wondering if there are any other niche topics within his rise that may potentially be interesting to study?

Thanks

1 Answers 2017-01-27

Does anyone know of a Dr. B. F. Wilson, MD ?

If this is the wrong sub, please point me in the right direction. Thanks.

The inevitable has happened, the internet has failed me. I've come to you all for help!

Here is what I know, he was running a sugar cane plantation in Anjouan Comoros. I can't find a picture or any information about him once he joined the U.S. Navy. There is speculation he might have began his own postal service while in Anjouan possibly around 1904. I'm curious for any information you can help me find.

Many Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2017-01-27

I found a 1940 Nazi Newspaper in Poland. What should I do with it?

It's in german and headlines Hitler's visit to Paris. https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/0B6FHiaB_VEukdHhrai1uZXBiWmM?usp=sharing I'm not sure what I should do with it. Is this something that a museum would want or is it too poor of quality?

1 Answers 2017-01-27

What was the actual difference in governance of states and territories during the days of Old West Frontier?

Were territories not subject to federal law and constitution?

1 Answers 2017-01-27

Did King Henry VIII have any curiosity about the New World? Do we know if he wrote or said anything about it?

Did he, or the other Tudors, ever plan on sending explorers there to compete with Spain & Portugal?

2 Answers 2017-01-27

Why were no ships ever named "HMS King George VI"?

Edward VII had a battleship, King George V had two battleships named after him, and HMS Prince of Wales and HMS Duke of York were named after the future King Edward VIII and George VI, and were completed under their old names during the reign of George VI. It feels strange to me to break this pattern with George VI. I understand that Battleships and Fleet Carriers were constructed during World War 2, but why were none never named HMS King George VI?

1 Answers 2017-01-27

To what extent was Syria under Haffez Al Assad secular?

1 Answers 2017-01-27

Did the U.S. actually send fighters armed with Nuclear missiles into the Soviet Union?

I found 2 sources here and here that say on October 26, 1962, a U-2 flying in the arctic, navigating with a sextant, accidentally flew over Northern Siberia. According to both sources, the Soviets sent up MiG fighter aircraft to shoot it down. Apparently, the U.S. Air Force sent in F102-A fighters, armed with nuclear missiles, into Soviet Airspace to escort the U-2 home. The part I'm curious about, because it seems so incredibly horrifying, is if the decision to use those nuclear missiles was left to the pilots or not. Both sources say it was the up to the fighters discretion.

1 Answers 2017-01-27

How could Philip II (Philip Augustus) order flemish peasants to be sold into slavery at the battle of bouvines, if they were christian?

From wiki article on Philip II of France in the section 'Battle of Bouvines, 1214'. Full paragraph given for context.

Basically, Count of Flanders refused to join Philip in his war against King John of England, and so Philip was given papal permission to punish Flanders (ironically, after the papacy had said it would be a sin to declare war on King John).

"The French fleet, reportedly numbering some 1,700 ships,[25] proceeded first to Gravelines and then to the port of Dam. Meanwhile, the army marched by Cassel, Ypres, and Bruges before laying siege to Ghent.[25] Hardly had the siege begun when Philip learned that the English fleet had captured a number of his ships at Dam and that the rest were so closely blockaded in its harbor that it was impossible for them to escape. After having obtained 30,000 marks as a ransom for the hostages he had taken from the Flemish cities he had captured, Philip quickly retraced his steps to reach Dam. It took him two days, arriving in time to relieve the French garrison, but he discovered he could not rescue his fleet. He ordered it to be burned to prevent it from falling into enemy hands, then he commanded the town of Dam to be burned to the ground as well. Determined to make the Flemish pay for his retreat, in every district he passed through he ordered that all towns be razed and burned, and that the peasantry be either killed or sold as slaves.[25]"

1 Answers 2017-01-27

Is there such a thing as "history repeating itself"?

Is there some kind of a reliable field that studies history comparatively or as a way of prediction?

Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2017-01-27

Did Nixon really threaten to unleash a nuclear holocaust at the height of the Watergate Scandal? Is there any check on the President's use of nuclear weapons?

I recently listened to Dan Carlin's Hardcore History episode about nuclear weapons. In it, he mentions that Nixon once said this during the Watergate Scandal:

"I could leave this room, and in 25 minutes, 70 million people would be dead."

What is the context of this quote? Could a President give the order to unleash nuclear weapons even if there was no threat to the United States? What if a President is not in his right mind?

1 Answers 2017-01-27

Why is the First Reich HRE and not the Roman Empire?

So as far I understand, the term third Reich comes from

1st Reich: Holy Roman Empire

2nd Reich: German Empire

3rd Reich: Nazi Germany

 

But how does it make sense to count HRE as 1st of anything? Wasn't the whole point of HRE to claim the prestige and legitimacy of the original Roman Empire?

You could say that they are only counting German Empires, but HRE was a Charlemagne's creation, and hence at least partially French, whom Germans saw as a natural enemy. Not to mention the Italians and Czechs who were at times part of the empire.

 

I get that Nazis had very selective, flexible, and delusional understanding of history. But their choice of 1st and 2nd Reich makes no sense.

1 Answers 2017-01-27

Professional historians, what is your job ?

2 Answers 2017-01-27

I'm looking for a pre-war German man who piloted a Horch or Auto Union car through Africa and wrote a terribly offensive and inaccurate book about his experience. Anyone in history fit that profile? I read about him somewhere but now I can't find him.

I wish I could get more specific, but if I could I probably would've found him myself. I have a lot of maybes that may help someone find him or remember him: -May have been a Nazi -May have driven a Horch car through Africa (This one is the one I know is the most important piece of the puzzle) -May have written a misguided book about Africa and Africans in general

Anyone have any names for a guy like this? It's not Rommel and its not Paul von Lettow-Vorbeck. Im very frustrated here.

1 Answers 2017-01-27

Did the Nazis rise to power because the Germans didn't "Bash the Fash" enough?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2017-01-27

What did Mussolini do in his first week of power?

1 Answers 2017-01-27

⯇ 3647 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start