At their heights, did the Allies or the Axis have the more efficient logistical arm during WWII?

1 Answers 2016-03-10

What's with the story of the 8 presidents before George Washington?

I knew once I clicked on it I was gonna fall into some conspiracy claim filled video. I saw Prince (the musician) state that there were 8 presidents before Washington. Google pulls up names but ties them with states.

Who were these people? Provincial governors?

1 Answers 2016-03-10

Suppose I'm an English (white, male, Christian) land owner living at some point between 1066 and today. When is the earliest point in time I’d be given the opportunity to vote on anything concerning government or law (either at a local or national level)?

I don’t mean when was the first general election for parliament held? I mean when was the first time non politicians were given an opportunity to vote on anything concerning how they were ruled?

1 Answers 2016-03-10

Who is responsible for the crucifixion of Jesus Christ?

Is there any historical proof that the Romans or Jews made the decision for the crucifixion? Please help.

1 Answers 2016-03-10

In Japan, only certain classes we allowed to have weapons. Was there a black market for arms among lower class in Japan? Were there similar laws against peasants owning weapons in Europe?

3 Answers 2016-03-10

How did the Christian world approach the concept of the 'Crusade' during the 16th/17th centuries?

A book I was reading made brief mention of French noblemen who left France to join the Crusades during the mid-16th century, implying I presume, that they joined the Knights of Malta. But at least in pop history, we think of the Crusades as a thoroughly medieval phenomenon, and Wiki at least defines ,"the Crusades were a series of intermittent military campaigns in the years from 1096 to 1487", so again not a phenomenon of the Early Modern Era.

So, the main thing I was wondering then is how the idea of a continuing Crusade against, presumably, the Ottomans, was conceptualized in that period. I'm especially interested specifically in the French perspective, as it was also noted that France itself maintained relatively good relations with the Sublime Porte, so while individual Frenchmen might be heading off to fight the heathens, it seems that France itself was not a part of this. But France aside, I'm also quite interested in the concept as a whole within the Christian world of the time.

1 Answers 2016-03-10

Ugandan military unit under Idi Amin

I've recently been reading up on infamous Ugandan leader Idi Amin. (Excuse the Wikipedia link, it's included for those who may not know of Amin but want a brief overview.)

In biographic depictions of Amin there are descriptions of his personal life, including his five wives and ~40 children. His fifth wife, Sarah Kyolaba, is often cited as having the nickname of 'Suicide Sarah' 1 2 3 4.

The nickname is explained as being derived from the military band she was a dancer for, variously: the 'Revolutionary Suicide Mechanised Regiment Band' or the 'Suicide Mechanized Jazz Band'.

However, I can't find an explanation of the band or regiment itself. Was it a military unit tasked with suicide missions; was it the name of the band; was it fictional; is the name a mistranslation? Any help or recommended reading would be appreciated.

1 Answers 2016-03-10

Just as there are Biblical Archaeologists in the Middle East, are there Mormon Archaeologists in America?

I understand that there is a certain degree of taking things as a matter of faith, but there is generally a desire to "prove" the truth of one's religion. Are there any Mormon archaeologists seeking out "prove" the stories in the Book of Mormon?

2 Answers 2016-03-10

Was Germany moving from an empire towards a constitutional monarchy at the end of WWI?

2 Answers 2016-03-10

Has the idea of an 'established oligarchy' within a democracy been around since it's conception or is it a relatively new idea? And has there ever been a concentrated effort to 'overthrow' it.

Was reading some comments and I saw this post

I'm not sure most people understand yet that the Oligarchy has been in power since the dawn of time....and that this is the first time in history that the people are truly rising up against the right FOE. This is some serious shower thoughts shit.

(i am not sure what FOE means)

I'm wondering, have people always thoughts like this even within a democracy?

Clearly it's not the first time in history people have risen up (so that statement is either hyperbolic or just wrong) but within functional democracies, it seems like the push for Trump and Sanders love is something unique.

Are there historical parallels?

Were there similar sentiments toward high powered families and industries in the past?

1 Answers 2016-03-10

What is the difference between a Kingdom and an Empire?

2 Answers 2016-03-10

Given the many conquests of Carlemagne, why isn't he considered a great military commander?

Reading his biography on Wikipedia, he seems to have personally led many expeditions to the South and to the East with considerable success. Why isn't he considered in popular history like Caesar, Napoleon or Frederick the Great as a great military commander? Did he have very good generals to do the job?

Edit: Damn it ... Charlemagne*

1 Answers 2016-03-10

Were the other countries of the world aware of the Trinity test during WWII?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-03-10

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in March 10 2016:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

1 Answers 2016-03-10

Why were there so many Scandinavian and German immigrants in the American Midwest?

8 Answers 2016-03-10

Explanation for this bizarre threat by the kushite King piye?

"I shall make lower Egypt taste the taste of my fingers!"

Can someone explain this threat to me?

1 Answers 2016-03-10

Did all ancient Greek city states speak the same version of Greek?

I'm curious if the Greek spoken by someone from, say, Thebes would have been intelligible by someone from Sparta. How distinct were city states' versions of Greek? When did these dialects coalesce into one standard version of Greek?

2 Answers 2016-03-10

What was the extent of Persian influence on the Deccan Sultanates?

2 Answers 2016-03-10

From where did Ahoms originated from?

Were they Chinese or Mongolians?

1 Answers 2016-03-10

Biographies of Tito

Can anyone recommend a good in-depth biography of General Josip Broz Tito? Thanks

1 Answers 2016-03-10

How did Alexander's army transport sarissas long distances?

This is a question that arose for me a few years ago when reading the Engels book on the logistics of Alexander's army, but I ended up forgetting about it because it was grad school and I had other shit to do.

Basically my question is this:

Given that a sarissa is about six meters and extremely unwieldy to just be carrying around all the time when you and several thousand of your best friends are walking from Pella to India and back, including down the godforsaken Makran coast, you probably don't want to have it in your hands all the damn time.

But you still want to have it when you need to kill pesky foreigners who don't realize yet that their land now is your land.

So, you could pack a bunch of them onto horses, but they still are probably a little too big for that. Wagons might work but the ancient Greek words Arrian used for the animals in the baggage train indicate the army didn't have wagons. It might work to split the shafts down the middle for travel, and maybe screw them back together when it's time to kill people, but we'd have found like a bajillion little metal pieces that screw together, and somebody would probably have mentioned it, right?

How did they get thousands of eighteen-foot long spears from one place to another? Did individual soldiers seriously just carry them all damn day?

1 Answers 2016-03-10

First hand accounts/memoirs by Japanese veterans of WW2?

I'm eager to do some reading on the Pacific theater of the war, but I really want a Japanese perspective on it, especially from a common infantryman. I'm happy to hear any recommendations.

2 Answers 2016-03-10

Does anyone know this french 17th/18th century general?

I want to to identify the French general on this portrait at the french embassy in London.

Pic: https://cf.geekdo-images.com/images/pic2918769.jpg or here: https://pmchollywoodlife.files.wordpress.com/2015/11/kate-middleton-prince-william-pay-respect-victims-paris-attacks-lead.jpg?w=600

or search for "Prince William French Embassy"

The picture was taken shortly after the terror attacks in paris, when Prince William condoled at the embassy. Next to this picture was a portrait of Paul Cambon, French Ambassador during WW1. So i assume this general was also ambassador, envoy or some kind of diplomat in the UK.

Checking some french marshals and ambassadors of this time, didn't give me a good result

Also checked portrait lists of Rigaud without success.

If i had to guess, i would say, he's maybe duc de tallard, because of his special relationship to GB or Vauban, because of the defensive symbolism.

So please help me to identify this french general?

thanks s.

ps. hope i didn't violate any subreddit rules, but i'm new to reddit and didn't know where to post it else.

4 Answers 2016-03-10

Why did the United States never develop a national health scheme like Canada, the UK or western Europe despite it's economic prosperity?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-03-10

Why is China named after the Qin when in Mandarin they refer to themselves as 'Han people'

Thanks for reading.

One of my favourite films is 'hero' and I got sucked into delightful research into early China.

So fascinating, and if someone can answer he title question with a bit of an explanation I would be grateful.

I've read stats saying upwards of 80% in China are Han, so why the name?

Is it different in Mandarin? What's the name in Cantonese?

Any interesting alternative names in minority languages?

Thanks so much for reading and any responses.

3 Answers 2016-03-10

4454 / 7255

Back to start