Did Roman pagans have a concept of the holy and profane, even if they didn't use those words to describe them?

1 Answers 2015-12-07

Why were machine gun-armed tanks called "females" and gun-armed tanks called "males" during the First World War?

1 Answers 2015-12-07

Books on Muslim Persia

I was wondering if anyone had recommendations for books on:

Muslim conquest of Persia Subsequent Islamisation Persian influence (particularly under Abbasids), until the Safavid era starting 1500

So basically anything from 700-1500 CE

edit: Also welcoming additions concerning modern Iran, preferrably 1950s-2000, particularly focusing on impacts of the Shah and CIA coup in 50s, and the Khomenei Revolution in '79

1 Answers 2015-12-07

Could freed Roman slaves own slaves?

I'm writing a paper, and this little tidbit of info is rather difficult to find.

Edit: I have been advised to offer additional information on what I have researched. This is a Wikipedia page on the rights of freed Roman slaves. I have spent about an hour so far just looking through various websites and books, however I have not come across this particular piece of information. Nearly all sources allude to the fact that a slave can become rather wealthy if set free, and we know that a lot of the wealthy families and persons owned slaves for themselves. I would appreciate any help!

3 Answers 2015-12-07

Is the "Live a good life" quote (so often seen in memes) attributed to Marcus Aurelius accurately?

Here is the text of the supposed quote:

"Live a good life. If there are Gods and they are just, then they will not care how devout you have been, but will welcome you based on the virtues you have lived by. If there are Gods, but unjust, then you should not want to worship them. If there are no Gods, then you will be gone, but will have lived a noble life that will live on in the memories of your loved ones."

Often the meme will say that the source is "Meditations."

Most of my (admittedly scant, internet based) research indicates that it is a misquotation.

3 Answers 2015-12-07

Any military historians out there?

I was looking through my Dad's stuff and found these badges and was wondering what these badges are. he was drafted into the army during Vietnam and I know the one is an infantry badge I believe but if anyone can give me more information on what these are I would appreciate it. i don't know if they are all military or not. One looks like an elephant and the other like a deer or donkey or something. Thanks. All three badges are shown in the link below. http://imgur.com/a/v2aGn

2 Answers 2015-12-07

How effective was the "Ghost Army" of World War II

I've heard about the 23rd Headquarters Special Troops, commonly known as the "Ghost Army," from various amusing sources on the Internet. [Here is a Wikipedia link about them.]( 23rd Headquarters Special Troops) In short, they were an US regiment of artists who used elaborate props to fool the Germans into thinking they were a real army.

However, for all their elaborate work, how effective was the Ghost Army? Did they fool the Germans? If so, did this cause the Germans to make any major strategic error?

1 Answers 2015-12-07

What did Aboriginal Australians call their homeland?

1 Answers 2015-12-07

Regarding history writing - when to use or not use citations

Hey all,

I'm writing a paper which is partly a biography (Sabbatai Zevi, who I highly recommend reading up on if you're into religious history). Part of the introduction is just a quick sketch of his life - birth, family, death, etc - events that are pretty much undisputed. How should stuff like this, for which I have 4 or 5 sources that all agree, be cited? Should I pick one source and go with it, or what?

1 Answers 2015-12-07

Why didn't Japan invade Hawaii on Dec 7th, 1941?

1 Answers 2015-12-07

When was the first heavier-than-air aircraft purpose built for aerial combat constructed?

We all now the first flight with a heavier-than-air aircraft was conducted by the wright brothers in 1903, but when did the first aircraft model made for air-to-surface/air-to-air combat (not modified from a civilian aircraft) first see the light of day?

1 Answers 2015-12-07

How did the public react to the idea of a sequel to the original Star Wars film?

Were there critics who thought that A New Hope was so complete it could not be followed up? The Empire Strijes Back is regarded as one of the greatest films of all time, let alone sequels. Were people surprised that it worked so well?

1 Answers 2015-12-07

Who was the founder of the Aztec Empire?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-12-07

Looking for newspapers that were written primarily for bankers in the 1830s

Hey all, trying to do some research for my term paper and could use some help narrowing my search. I'm trying to find some old newspaper articles that would shed light on what the bankers at the time were saying during the Panic of 1837. If anyone knows of any newspapers publishing at the time whose target audience was bankers, it would elp out quite a bit. Thanks!

1 Answers 2015-12-07

Was the Ottoman Empire at all affected by the Renaissance?

Politically or socially.

1 Answers 2015-12-07

Good translations of Song or Tang Dynasty poetry?

Maybe "good translation" is an impossible task, are there any translations you would recommend for any Song/Tang Dynasty songs or poetry? Preferably with sufficient annotation and the original text included, as I can read a little Chinese?

2 Answers 2015-12-07

Looking for recommendations on old folk/fairy tales and legends in somewhat modern print

I've just about finished reading through the Grimm brothers collection of fairy tales, and I'm realizing old tales and legends are really fun to read. However, I don't really know of many other old stories that I can actually get my hands on.

I'm looking for stories from a pretty much anytime, anywhere, as long as I can actually buy the book in English or Swedish. To give you an idea, here's what I've come up with so far:

  • The Grimm brothers (already read)
  • The Edda
  • Kalevala
  • Bhagavad gita
  • Beowulf

I'm especially interested in old Germanic folk tales featuring fairies (the tales that the Grimm brothers wrote down were surprisingly lacking in this regard considering they are usually referred to as "fairy tales") and other magical creatures.

Maybe this is the wrong place to ask (where would the right place be then?), but I figure you might know some interesting stuff I've never heard of, and it seems to fit with the theme of the week.

2 Answers 2015-12-07

How likely is it that the U.S. would have entered WWII if Japan had not attacked Pearl Harbor?

Its common knowledge that Japan attacked the Pearl Harbor in the hopes of crippling our navy to the point where we had no choice but to stay out of the war, are there any historians that believe that this attack caused their defeat because we might have never entered it otherwise?

If I recall my history correctly, the mentality of the U.S. before that attack was very anti war, mainly as a reaction to WWI? I have read in other places however that the U.S. joining the war was inevitable due to our allies being under attack (by japan? by germany? both?), is this true?

2 Answers 2015-12-07

Why did the House of Habsburg fall?

They had so many titles such as Holy Roman Emperor, Emperor of Mexico, King of the Romans, King of Germany, King of Italy, King of Spain, King of Hungary, King of Portugal, King of England, King of Ireland.

I find it hard to believe that a family that powerful just kinda fell. What where the exact reasons?

2 Answers 2015-12-07

Are "rock stars" historically unique? Are they just a 20th century thing, or has there always been a structure resembling what we now call "the music industry"?

Obviously, something's radically changing today in the way we pay for music, who winds up getting the money, and which performers get rewarded.

But, beyond all the talk about Spotify and copyright and "I didn't learn guitar to sell T-shirts," how unique a case is the contemporary music industry?

Is the idea of having a very few "star" performers and a lot of talented & dedicated amateurs (most with day jobs) really a new way of being, or does it resemble the way things were before LPs? Or printed sheet music? Or some other factor?

Historians, where do rock stars come from?

1 Answers 2015-12-07

What was life like for Europeans living in Ottoman occupied territory, such as Budapest?

1 Answers 2015-12-07

Was the belief that humans were essentially very complex machines ever commonly held?

I had been watching a video on philosophy of mind where one of the speakers says that, in the past, people thought that humans were very complex machines: some sort of automaton theory. Everything we did and how we acted could allegedly be explained by purely mechanistic processes, which I imagine would be things like fluid pressure and muscles acting like pulleys to control our legs. They compared it to how the computational theory of mind has been dying and that it is interesting to see how we have shifted our view about how humans work to our most advanced creations. Similarly to how it was naive to think that a man is not significantly different from a series of gears and pressure valves, so too was it naive to think that the computer is a good analog for the brain.


While I think the parallel is quite nice with the slow death / evolution of the computational theory of mind, was something akin to the described "automaton theory" ever commonly held? It certainly seems reasonable to think that a bunch of DaVincis could create an artificial man out of cogs and Archimedes screws, but I suppose that doesn't mean anyone really thought it was true.

1 Answers 2015-12-07

When measured by GDP, how big was the United States government under George Washington? when (up to 1995) was the United States government biggest? When (up to 1995) and which government was the biggest?

2 Answers 2015-12-07

Murder of John F. Kennedy theories?

I don't really know if this belongs here, but I need som help on a paper that I am writing. It is about the murder of JFK and some of the conspiracies that exist on the subject. While it is easy to find the conspiracy theories, I find it hard to find someone who have some strong arguments against the conspiracy theorists. And also, if you know some conspiracy theories that you find exciting about the murder of JFK, that have some strong arguments, please let me know!

3 Answers 2015-12-07

Monday Methods|Finding and Understanding Sources- Part 4, Troublesome Primary Sources

Following up last week's post on reading primary sources critically, today we will talk about some of the challenges you might encounter when reading said sources.

/u/DonaldFDraper will write about the challenges of dealing with primary sources when you don't speak/read the language.

/u/Sowser will write about silences in the sources, and how to draw informed conclusions about topics the sources do not talk about.

/u/Cordis_Melum will write about inaccessible sources, and ways to work around that challenge.

/u/colevintage and /u/farquier will both write about online research for images and material culture.

3 Answers 2015-12-07

4736 / 7255

Back to start