What had the First French Republic actually planned to do after its failed invasion of Ireland in 1796? Did they plan to sustain a purely military presence, as allies of the Irish, or were they secretly planning to annex Ireland, to turn it into a French colony?

Long version:

In late 1796, with the blessing of the rebel United Irishmen, the First French Republic launched a failed invasion of Ireland (Expédition d'Irlande), under General Hoche.

The Irish strategy was to remove the British from Ireland and declare a Republic, with the aid of the French. The French sought to deal an ideological blow against the British, and establish a potential base for an invasion of Britain.

It seemed like a mutually beneficial strategy at the time, and I can see how the United Irishmen's Fitzgerald, O'Connor, and Wolfe Tone were encouraged by the promise of French military aid, but I have often wondered whether it would have simply been a case of "out of the frying pan and into the fire". By which I mean, would Ireland have simply changed hands from what was essentially a British colony to a French colony, leaving the population in a similar position to its original predicament.

In other words, how detailed was the agreement between the Irish and the French; was it perhaps shrouded in a fog of mutual idealism?Is there any evidence that the French had plans other than those outlined to the Irish?

2 Answers 2015-04-11

When did European traders, pirates, and sailors become a common sight in the Orient?

I'm re-reading Charles C. Mann's 1493, and he mentions the arrival of a group of "Dutch" (a mix of Dutch, Portuguese, Spanish, and Malays) pirates in Fujian in 1547, where they set up a base on Wu Island. I can't seem to find any other references to this event on the internet, and it is kind of treated as representative of larger trends of the period.

The date seems very early to me for such an unknown event. When did European travels to the orient by sail like this become so commonplace that they wouldn't be noteworthy to put in the history books? As far as I'm aware, Europeans had just discovered Japan at this point, and travel to China was still anything but a common occurrence. Have I wrongly conceptualized the existing trade and contact links of this period?

edit: I realize "the Orient" can mean something different to each person. What I'm really talking about here is the Far East (eg., China, Japan, Korea, Indochina, The Philippines, Formosa, etc.).

1 Answers 2015-04-11

How were people with epilepsy treated in 14th century Europe?

How were people with epilepsy treated in 15th century Europe? Did society consider them to be pariahs or did they understand that their seizures came from a medical condition?

EDIT-I meant 15th century-sorry for bad topic title!

1 Answers 2015-04-11

When and why did Peking change to Beijing?

1 Answers 2015-04-11

Why do Muslims consider dogs to be unclean?

1 Answers 2015-04-11

What was Hitler's cult of personality based on? Was he considered divine? A Messiah Or a political genius? A moral genius?

1 Answers 2015-04-11

Would Nazi Germany be considered a stratocracy?

I'm trying to determine the difference between a stratocracy, military dictatorship, and if Nazi Germany was more of the former than the latter.

1 Answers 2015-04-11

Are there any good free history podcasts?

I've listened to a few of Dan Carlin's, which I love, but most of them are paid. Any good free ones out there?

I love the ones you guys do here, but I need more!

11 Answers 2015-04-11

During WWII, were there any anti-Imperial Japanese resistance groups, specifically within Japan itself?

We have all heard about German, French, Italian, etc. resistance groups forming after the coming of Facism and/or invasions of their countries. However, I've never heard about any real resistance in Japan, China or Korea. It's easy to imagine there were groups in China and Korea, but were there any such groups in Japan?

2 Answers 2015-04-11

How are we able to read the Hurrian Hymns (the oldest recorded melody) and be able to play it?

By looking at the tablets in which it was inscribed, how are we able to read what the melody sounded like?

2 Answers 2015-04-11

Why Didn't the Vikings Spread Disease to the Americas?

If the Vikings made it to North America and interacted with the natives, why did't they spread disease before Columbus?

1 Answers 2015-04-11

A lone T90 MBT vs multiple WW2 Era tanks.

2 Answers 2015-04-11

Did the Italian/Sicilian New York mob have any allegiances during World War II?

If so were there any disagreements between families?

1 Answers 2015-04-11

What city has spent the most total years as a capital city (not necessarily consecutive)?

I was thinking maybe Istanbul/Constantinople or Rome... just curious

5 Answers 2015-04-11

Was city planning common in ancient times? How did people decide where to build stuff?

Did cities grow organically, or was there some sort of master plan? Or maybe somewhere in between?

2 Answers 2015-04-11

Why didn't the USSR launch more winter offensives in WWII?

From what I've read in various places in this sub, apart from the famed Battle of Moscow, the USSR launched few winter offensives in WWII. That surprises me given all the problems that the Germans had in winter, such as tanks as trucks that wouldn't start, the problem of ice in the overlapping bogie wheels of German tanks, artillery pieces that only functioned after hardened grease and so forth had been chipped away, and inferior German uniforms (even after they received their winter gear). It seems like that would give the Red Army a major advantage in winter, so why didn't they launch more winter offensives?

1 Answers 2015-04-11

What events lead to the transition of Britain from an absolute monarchy to the more democratic state we know today?

I've done a small amount of research into it, and my impression is that it was a relatively quiet, very gradual process that occurred over several centuries. However I find it a little difficult to get a succinct, coherent rundown of the events that lead from an absolute monarchy to the system we know today. So what were the major landmarks and/or driving events that led the monarchy to relinquish power?

2 Answers 2015-04-11

Were there American-born British soldiers in the American Revolution? If so, how did they see the Revolution, how were they treated by their fellow soldiers or countrymen back home?

In other words, to what extent was the American Revolution a "brother-against-brother" civil war?

3 Answers 2015-04-11

Soon after humans invented the alphabet, what's the first historical source of someone refusing to kill another out of empathy.

I'm curious along the lines of refusing a military order or something like that. Do we have any such sources in cuneiform, hieroglyphics, phoenician, ancient chinese, or such?

1 Answers 2015-04-11

What is the world's oldest still existing organization?

1 Answers 2015-04-11

How many men did Wyatt Earp kill?

I am doing an assignment for History. I have to do an old newspaper assignment where i am the editor. My dad said to stick to the western theme so now I'm wondering how many men did Wyatt Earp kill? Please let me know.

1 Answers 2015-04-11

What is the earliest reference to Osculum Infame (the Devil's Kiss) and what is the most comprehensive study done on this aspect of the Occult and Witchcraft?

1 Answers 2015-04-11

How important is the recent discovery of a new Shakespeare play?

Heard about his "new" play "Double Falsehood" through the news, and I'm wondering how big of a deal this is? Does it give us any new insight to how Shakespeare worked, given that it's been team-written in parts? As, aside from previous academic speculation that it was his work, it recently was determined to be his work through linguistic analysis, so how distinct was his voice compared to other playwrights of the period?

2 Answers 2015-04-11

Was there any immigration at all in the Third Reich?

I haven't really found anything about this online. Was it only Aryans that were allowed to migrate to Nazi Germany or were the borders shut completely?

2 Answers 2015-04-11

Does anyone have any good academic sources for Nazi Soviet foreign policy in the 1930s ?

Working on an assignment, would be interesting to see what people have found.

1 Answers 2015-04-11

5539 / 7255

Back to start