Day of Reflection | December 01, 2014–December 07, 2014

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2014-12-07

How much were the Orthodox involved in the crusades?

As an Orthodox i'm curious to know how much did the Orthodox do in the crusades. I know that they asked for help from Rome against the Seljuk empire but did they do any fighting against the muslims or give other kinds of support to the crusaders?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

Was Erwin Rommel a Morally Just Man

2 Answers 2014-12-07

When and how did crossing our fingers become the symbols for both luck and lying?

It seems strange to me that it's the symbol for luck and when we cross it behind our back to hide a lie.

1 Answers 2014-12-07

What happened to the German military after WWII?

What happened to their equipment?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

What is the origin of judaism?

Why did this group of people decide to worship a s single god while most of their neighbours were polytheists? What was the origin and purpose of Torah with all of its complex rules?

3 Answers 2014-12-07

Did the British Empire feel threatened by growing American power in the late 19th and early 20th centuries?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

Why do men only wear black and white to events where a formal dress code is required?

In big formal events such as a wedding, charity dinner party etc, men always wear identical tuxedos or suits of black and white, while women wear dresses of different designs and colors. Why is that? Looking at paintings of 18th century parties, the men, like women, all wears formal clothings of various style and colors. Is there a reason for the dress code to change among men?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

What's a small decision that significantly changed the course of history?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

Why was General McClellan so convinced of the numerical superiority of the rebel army during the American Civil War?

Was it just his nature, or was he misled by bad advisers or counter-intelligence?

EDIT: Thanks for the answers and reading recommendations.

3 Answers 2014-12-07

In the future, how will history describe us and our era?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

Since tomorrow is the 73rd anniversary, I was wondering: Why did Japan attack Pearl Harbor?

Why did Japan attack Pearl Harbor? What did they hope to accomplish? It seems like just about the stupidest tactical decision they could have made. Help me understand.

Bonus Question: How did the Nazis react to news of the attack? Did Hitler know about it in advance?

2 Answers 2014-12-07

How prepared was Japan for a land invasion in 1945?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

Why is it excepted by everyone that the Nubian Pharaohs were black, but there is a debate about the skin color of older Egyptian dynasties?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

What kind of cake would Marie Antoinette have eaten?

I have read that Marie Antoinette did not actually say "Let them eat cake." But I wondered what kind of cakes were being cooked in pre-revolution France. I'm looking to make an old-style cake but I don't really know what kind they had. Any ideas?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

How Accurate are the Dates of Reigns of Ancient Kings?

Specifically, Roman emperors; however, other ancient cultures are applicable. Since the Julian calendar only had ten months, how can we be sure of certain dates that far back? Wasn't our current Gregorian calendar instituted in the Middle Ages? That's about a thousand years of back tracking to figure out how many months were left out. I'm sorry if my question is a bit sloppy and ambiguous.

1 Answers 2014-12-07

Are the cartoon/media depictions of revolutionary war era military campaigns (Where soldiers line up and shoot each other) accurate? How did this strategy come to develop?

It just seems silly to have a bunch of men marching, with a drummer to alert the enemies that they are around, and to just stand still while they fire at each other.

I'm guessing there's a good reason for it, and that strategists and tacticians at the time were probably limited technically to any kind of guerrilla or modern war tactics.

1 Answers 2014-12-07

During the Arab Muslim conquests, why did some peoples become Arabized while others didn't? For instance, why did Persians not come to be considered Arabs, whereas the people of much of North Africa did?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

Were the three wartime conferences considered huge risks?

I was thinking about the Yalta conference that is an extraordinary journey for the Americans and British to take. I know the Luftwaffe was largely defeated by that time, but it seems like so many things could have gone wrong in transit and two war time leaders could have been killed or captured. Even Mechanical problems, was there opposition to the meeting, and what type of precautions were taken to keep the leaders safe?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

Why is the Middle East so unstable?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

Are permanent land grants still valid?

4 Answers 2014-12-07

Can someone explain what this history essay prompt is asking for?

"To what extent did American independence bring about a revolution in the United States in its first two decades? In your response, discern between the structures of government, the social order, popular ideology. To highlight the American case, make relevant comparisons and/or contrasts with the revolutions in France and in Haiti."

It's the first sentence that's confusing me a lot. I don't get the revolution after independence part of the question. I thought gaining independence was a revolution?

3 Answers 2014-12-07

What does feudalism mean?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

The British were brilliant, innovative thinkers during WW2 why did their tanks have no sloping armor when it seems like a simple concept? see comments

The Cromwell looks like a brick with treads.

The Churchill is like a land-battleship.

The German Tiger was a beast but it was up to the task. Even the American Sherman had sloped armor.

Angled armor seems like common sense?

2 Answers 2014-12-07

What things can be used as proof that a nation existed?

I was reading through the wiki about no evidence of the exodus out of Egypt by the Israelites. What evidence would be used by historians of proof of the israelites? Writings, goods, campsites?

1 Answers 2014-12-07

6027 / 7255

Back to start