1 Answers 2014-08-25
Were they treated the same or less as in neighboring kumpanchea or in Mai's china or what?
1 Answers 2014-08-25
What made people put them on the sides?
1 Answers 2014-08-25
I assume since different events shape countries differently, how are major events addressed differently in different history curricula.
for example communism in russia / america, or world war two in japan / germany
1 Answers 2014-08-24
4 Answers 2014-08-24
1 Answers 2014-08-24
I've heard many times that Yahweh began as a local war/storm god before eventually taking on monotheistic characteristics and becoming God Almighty around the time of the Babylonian captivity, but I'm wondering how well accepted this idea is in Biblical scholarship, and what the arguments for and against it are.
4 Answers 2014-08-24
Just a question that popped into my head, how were the old and new testaments put together with all the different chapters? Was there one specific person that put it together?
2 Answers 2014-08-24
To what extent did ancient Northern European tribes (such as the Angles, Jutes, Saxons, Frisians, etc) contribute to the Western tradition of Self-Governance/English Common Law/Democracy/etc?
http://encyclopediavirginia.org/Jefferson_Thomas_and_Books
Jefferson was admitted to the Virginia bar in 1767 and was elected to represent Albemarle County in the House of Burgesses the following year. As a practicing lawyer and lawmaker, Jefferson found himself at the center of Virginia politics. The overwhelming majority of histories and legal authorities that Jefferson read and consulted held up as the historic ideal the mythic Anglo-Saxon democracy in England prior to the Norman invasion of 1066: a society governed by an elected monarch and a popular assembly, where land-tenure systems were not controlled by any one sovereign or government. Enlightenment philosophers also looked to the golden age of Athens and republican Rome for guidance in their quest for ideas and solutions in facing issues of freedom and self-government. In addition to Greek and Roman historians such as Tacitus and Thucydides, Jefferson also valued the study of modern history, particularly French and British, in addressing the contemporary political and social issues of his time.
It just doesn't seem right to me that the Greeks and the Romans would have such a direct contribution towards self-governance among Europeans and their descendants. Their influence from a removed, academic, "who should I study when making a government" point of reference is undeniable, but I can't help but think that if there wasn't some organic inclination towards self-governance that burbled up through the centuries, things wouldn't be the same.
Basically, the story we learn in school is "The Greeks invented Democracy and the Romans kinda-sorta tried to refine it. Then we decided it would be fun to try, for realsies this time." I'm sure the old Anglo-Saxon tribes have far less influence than white-supremacists might like to think (Enlightenment thought and other factors were kind of a big deal), but I'm also sure the actual influence of those traditions is more than is commonly acknowledged (for fear of stoking the fires of ethnic exceptionalism).
EDIT: If you're wondering what promoted me to ask this question, I subscribe to an email newsletter of sorts on the classical world and the last one had a lengthy article on the Battle of Marathon. Discussions of it, and similar events tend of overemphasize the influence of Greco-Roman forms of government to the western traditions of self-governance, so i was considering other contributing factors. I'd always wondered about this, but it wasn't until now that I've joined Reddit that I realized I know a place where these questions get answered!
2 Answers 2014-08-24
I know that NATO was able to obtain quite a bit of captured Soviet gear, be they tanks, aircraft, artillery, small arms and the like. For example, there was HAVE DRILL and HAVE DONUT, where NATO was able to conduct extensive testing on Mig-17 and 21s captured by the Israelis and there was also an extensive study of a Mig-25 who's pilot defected to Japan.
While I'm sure the Soviets were able to get their hands on NATO small arms easily enough, were there any major instances of the USSR obtaining captured NATO gear for testing and evaluation?
If not, how did they go about gathering their intelligence on NATO weapons? They seemed to have at least a pretty good understanding of how most NATO stuff worked, if their manuals are anything to go off of.
1 Answers 2014-08-24
I'm not so sure about the Abassids (or any of these actually, or I wouldn't be asking) but the Rashidun and Umayyads seem like successive dynasties of the same empire, rather than two separate empires. What gives?
1 Answers 2014-08-24
? The internet is worse than it was for finding anything. Everybody wants to sell me something or join something else. Want to find something on the internet? spend an hour sifting sites before you stopped wondering about your question.
You Historians, educators, well read people of letters- Please don't send me back to the spiders web. Just if you know yes or no (and/or have an insight) -enlighten me.
1 Answers 2014-08-24
I'm embarking on a project about Jewish Partisans in WWII and was wondering if anyone had any suggestions for a book on the topic. I have found a lot of memoirs, but I'm looking for something more definitive and historical. My ideal book would illuminate the place of Jewish Partisans within the greater framework of World War II.
I'm looking for a strong presentation of context, readability, lots of footnotes, and a balance of personal examples with analysis. Any suggestions? Thanks
1 Answers 2014-08-24
I guess I don't know that much about the War of 1812 other than the sacking of Washington DC. How were the British able to do that to the capital of the United States and not retake the former colonies? I guess any and all information about the War of 1812 would be appreciated.
2 Answers 2014-08-24
1 Answers 2014-08-24
When did Bangkok become a "sex capitol"?
2 Answers 2014-08-24
So far the only other tipi like dwelling I've found is the Lavvu, used by the Sami people in Scandanavia. The sheer simplicity and utility of a conical timber frame structure would seem to be an inevitable step in the evolution of architecture anywhere the right kind of raw materials are readily available. Does anyone know other examples of similarly constructed dwellings being used in the past?
2 Answers 2014-08-24
Were these people descendant from the same group and ended up being separated by geography?
1 Answers 2014-08-24
Marx's writings imagine the dictatorship of the proletariat as a transitional phase before the state would wither away and a pure communist society would emerge. Without getting into any debates as to whether the Soviet Union actually was a socialist society or not, it's propaganda certainly thought it was.
However, if the dictatorship of the proletariat is merely a transitional period, how was this reflected in Soviet propaganda if it was at all? I suppose this question would also apply to other Marxist-Leninist states as well, so feel free to post any information on those. It would seem to undermine the near-deistic powers ascribed to the leaders of those states if they were considered transitional, and yet even a cursory familiarity with Marx would force someone to recognise that this is exactly what Marx was saying. How, if at all, did Soviet propagandists reconcile this dilemma?
1 Answers 2014-08-24