To what extend did the United States drop the atomic bomb on Japan during WW2 to prevent the USSR from expanding into Asia?

Was America concerned at all with Russia trying to expand into Asia? Was America perturbed by the fact that Russia had growing control over Poland?

1 Answers 2014-03-16

Can someone please explain the concept of 'fundamental law' in the context of 17th century England?

'Fundamental law' is a term that keeps popping up as I read books on 17th century England, but I'm not quite sure what it is or how to place it in the right context. If possible, I would like to know:

  • What is 'fundamental law' (in the context of England)?
  • Where did this concept come from?
  • How did Englishmen in the 17th century utilise this concept in the sphere of politics?
  • Presumably 'fundamental law' is incompatible with the notion of parliamentary sovereignty, so how did the latter theory come to be dominant?

I know this is quite a legal/political question but I'm hoping someone can help me out with the history. Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2014-03-16

What was the Interpretatio Graeca for the Jewish/Christian God?

As Christianity became more popular throughout the Roman Empire, I'm wondering if there was an effort by the Greco-Roman clergy to adapt the Christian God into their pantheon, under the name of one of their Gods or not.

1 Answers 2014-03-16

Why does England have a closer relationship with Wales than Scotland?

Welsh teams play in English soccer leagues while Scottish teams do not. Wales uses Bank of England notes while Scottish banks are allowed to print their own notes. Scotland has independence referendums while Wales has had none that I know of. There must be more examples which I do not know of. I am an outside observer(American) so I do not know all the intricacies of the various Acts of Union in the UK. What would be the closest American concept to think of the various British nations, are they treated like American states or more like the various member nations of the EU?

6 Answers 2014-03-16

WW2 Labor Camp Papers with Nazi Seal. Request for identifying/translating.

I was wondering if I could get more information on this document:

Photo 1

Photo 2

They belonged to my Ukrainian (Orthodox) Grandfather. I was framing these for my Father as it is a valuable piece of family history. The Nazi symbols worry me a little, but I believe they are his working papers from a labor camp (thats what my research suggested so far). His story went something along the lines of needing to hide from both Soviet and Nazi forces, their farm/land was confiscated and they fled the country towards the end of the war. He has long since past, these are stories I was told when I was very young, I wish I could elaborate more.

I have blurred out his last name because I would like to remain anonymous. My last name was derived from his once they immigrated. Internets and all.

Edit: Sorry about the poor quality on the second photo, I didn't want to scan this, the paper is extremely delicate and aged. I'll type out what I can, the characters I can't type are in {}.

{LUU}... Nurnburg Rr...XXIII/29o/543

familie name: [excluded] ... Ruiname: Stefan

(bei Frauenauch Geburtsname):...[???]

Geburtstag. 1914... [unreadable]

Deimatort: Krywe 21... Areis:...Baligrod

Beruf:..1A2o ...landroirtschaftlicher Arbeiter

Urbeitsbuch-Rr:...Arbeitsbuchersatzkarte

Unternehmer (Urbeitgeber):...Babette Muller

Urbeitsftelle (Drt):...Gut Rosenhof... Areis:...Kronach

Des Empfangers ber Lohneriparniffe: Bor und {S}uname

fomie {M}ohnort uno Areis

Uusgeftellt am...18.3. , 194{1} Gultigbis {zy}um...31.1...194{2}

Niunt{zy}utreftenoesftreicben LAA Nbg. Lanbiv Urbeiter (Bol.)

2 Answers 2014-03-16

I from a museum exhibit that there was a Chinese dynasty that was infamous for ruling by creating brutally efficient systems of rewards and punishment.

The example that was given was that they'd pay their soldiers based on the number of heads they brought back on their belts. What was this dynasty? And why did it fail, if its system was so successful?

2 Answers 2014-03-16

Did the formal state of Russia exist prior to the formation of Ukraine as a legitimate independent state?

Many countries claim successorship from Kievan Rus', most notably Russia and Ukraine. The formal origins of Russia or the establishment of a 'true' Russian culture seems to lie within various events between the 12th and 16th century. The defeat of the Khanate by Ivan the Terrible in the 1500s seems to hold the pivotal clues to the origin of Russia as a nation. Although the blurry history has led me to approach this question from a linguistic stance. From a linguistic perspective, the Ukrainian language contains heavy Polish and Russian influence. Subsequently this fact yields another question - did the modern day Ukrainian culture exist before the Russian culture or does Ukrainian culture stem from the original Russian culture?

The Russian word for Ukraine, Украина, is the formation of a preposition + noun, respectively У + Край (У - by, Край - border, edge). Is the 'edge (Край)' in relation to Europe proper or Russia? If the latter is presumed it would be supplementary to establishing the fact that Russia (i.e both the formal nation and culture) preceded Ukraine, in my opinion.

The history is interesting and complex. Unfortunately I couldn't find a definitive or satisfactory answer to this question.

Thank you

2 Answers 2014-03-16

I'm a veteran of the Roman legions living in a colonia on the Rhine in the 2nd century AD. There are lots of old Army pals around. Then I die of a sudden. Which funeral and memorial services would be conducted by my Army friends if I was very esteemed by them during my life?

1 Answers 2014-03-16

Why do conservatives like conserving old social traditions?

1 Answers 2014-03-16

What are the best books on eastern Asian anthropolgy or history in general.

All I can seem to find are World War 2 accounts and I'm interested in the Nara period into the Heian period. And maybe some other books about the feudal era. Geographically my university doesn't have any professors that are familiar with this and I want to get a jump on learning this material before starting to study it. Many thanks in advanced!

1 Answers 2014-03-16

How should I introduce John F. Kennedy's 1963 speech in West Berlin ("Ich bin ein Berliner") to a group of teenagers?

I'm about to show this speech to a group of boy scouts, ages 11-17, and I'd like to provide them with a brief introduction.

I don't mind being a bit dramatic about it -- after all, it is a dramatic speech and I want to set the tone appropriately. I'm just wondering if you have some good advice on which historical points I should touch on to provide the best possible context.

I also need to guide them through a discussion of the following:

"Explain the importance of the speech at the time it was given, and tell how it applies to American citizens today."

What are some things I should make sure to touch on?

Thanks for all your help!

1 Answers 2014-03-16

How was Purim celebrated in medieval European Jewish communities?

Was it anything like today, with the dressing up and the rattles and the candy?

1 Answers 2014-03-16

Why did the living conditions of the British working class improve after industralization?

How did the British working class manage to leave the state of pauperism? I know about the importance of friendly societies, trade unions, and the agricultural revolution in England that went along with industrialization, but I don't quite know what the actual importance of any of these were. Can anyone explain? Also, I'd be incredibly happy if you could provide me with any good sources or further readings on the topic. Thanks a lot!

2 Answers 2014-03-16

Was one of the end episodes in LotR novel based on real events?

1 Answers 2014-03-16

What was the extent of the Scots-Irish influence on the Blues?

2 Answers 2014-03-16

What connection is there with ancient Greek gods and the Egyptian pantheon of gods as well the ancient near Eastern gods (Babylonian, Assyrian, ect.)?

I would love to get as close as possible to a common origin if possible.

1 Answers 2014-03-16

What did the Phoenicians call Africa?

From what I understand, the word Africa comes from the word Afri, meaning Carthaginians. However, what would they, the Carthaginians, have called it?

I am assuming this would be a better place to ask this as opposed to /r/AskLinguistics due to the historical nature and obscurity of the question, but please if I am wrong tell me.

2 Answers 2014-03-16

What happened to Jewish POW's in Nazi Germany?

1 Answers 2014-03-16

Could anyone here recommend me a book that explain the Vikings and everything about them?

This might be a long shot, but i am looking for a book that have their history, faith, culture, weapons and enemies explained. I have been dreaming for such a book for a long time, but it's hard to find a book that covers all or most of those things.

Thanks in advance.

2 Answers 2014-03-16

Day of Reflection | March 10, 2014 - March 16, 2014

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2014-03-16

Can any recommend any books to do with US economic development in the late 19th century (Gilded Age)?

I've had a look at /r/AskHistorians recommended reading list and used the search bar but I've mainly been finding more social or political histories. I was wondering if anyone could recommend any books which focus on the economic.

Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2014-03-16

What did Nazi Germany do with legitimate criminals such as rapists and murderers?

3 Answers 2014-03-16

Why was gold chosen as the main currency? Where did all the European gold come from originally?

1 Answers 2014-03-16

Is there a website like Khan Academy for history? Could there be?

Someone asked /r/history why there isn't a website like Khan Academy for history?. For those who don't know, Khan Academy started off as a YouTube channel of maths tutorials, and has grown into one of the biggest educational websites in the world. It's expanded from maths to the physical sciences and economics, but its coverage of history and the humanities more broadly (and social science for that matter) is rather patchy.

Some people in the /r/history thread pointed out various things around the web that are similar; someone just hasn't brought them all together in one place for history (yet). Others suggested that history is too subjective, broad and/or holistic for the Khan Academy model.

I thought I'd throw this question out to /r/AskHistorians too to see what you, as historians interested in public engagement, think. Is it possible to teach history in bite-size video tutorials? Has somebody already tried? If so, why hasn't it taken off as much as Khan Academy has for maths and physical science?

8 Answers 2014-03-16

What were the Italian governments type and policies during WW2

It is often overlooked that Italy were allies with Nazi Germany in WW2. I actually until recently totally forgot this was the case. I was never taught anything on the subject matter about Italy at that time except that my grandfather was a PoW in Italy until he escaped.

Hope this is acceptable to the admins but this is a link to a published copy of his memoires of his time as a soldier.

Were the Italian government complicit with the Nazi party, how much did they know about the atrocities towards the Jewish population? Did they share the same racial purity beliefs of their German allies?

1 Answers 2014-03-16

6978 / 7255

Back to start