How generally accurate is the new Pompeii movie (not the plot, but the setting)?

Obviously Kit Harington's character is fictional and the whole thing is dramatized, but how accurate is the depiction of Roman society.

  • Was Keifer Sutherland's Senator Corvus based on anybody real? Was this Celtic Rebellion in 62AD based on a real event?

  • how accurate was the depiction of the pagentry surrounding the arena fight?

  • What was that festival they were celebrating? Was it real and did it happen during the eruption as depicted?

  • Were those aerial reconstructions of Pompeii and Londinium accurate? How about the street level depiction of the city?

Were there any other glaring anachronisms that I may have missed, or parts they depicted particularly accurately?

1 Answers 2014-02-24

A question regarding the accuracy of textbooks...

Now this question may come off as a conspiracy, so please tell me and delete my question mods if I am off my rocker.

That being said, I know that in many southern states of the United States history textbooks refer to the American Civil War as The War of Northern Aggression. I also know that states such as Alabama actually publish their own, unique version of American history textbooks.

Now I am from Wisconsin, and my question is are there "facts" taught to me about history of my State, Country, or the World in textbooks that are considered false by the majority of the world?

2 Answers 2014-02-24

What is the oldest historical event that we definitively know when it happened to the day? [cross post from askhistory]

Asked here. Plenty of interest over there, but no answers yet.

2 Answers 2014-02-24

Could Japan have been starved out?

Instead of using the atomic bombs or Operation Downfall, would it have been feasible for the allies to try and starve Japan? They had already cut off Japan's supply lines, would Japan have potentially surrendered if this had been continued?

1 Answers 2014-02-24

How close were the Axis powers to an atomic bomb?

A lot of people who worked on the Manhattan Project (Richard Feynman, for one) justified their participation based on fear that the Nazis would get nuclear weapons first. Was there a Nazi or Japanese equivalent to the Manhattan Project?

Germany was home to the most important scientific developments in early 20th century Physics, so it wouldn't be surprising if the Nazis had a sophisticated program of their own. Then again, a lot of the major scientists were Jewish and fled to the United States before the war started.

Also, when did the Soviets join the race for the bomb? Were they on track to finish before the war ended had the Trinity Test not occurred when it did? Did they start before 1942 when they were still Nazi allies?

On a slightly unrelated note (maybe a bit more speculative), were the Nazis working to get to space? Wernher von Braun, who was arguably the most important single person in NASA history, worked for the Nazi government during WWII. He developed missiles during the war, including the first artificial object to enter space. After it ended he and many other scientists were recruited by the US government and they eventually sent men into space. Did the Nazis have any similar plans, or were they only interested in weapons?

1 Answers 2014-02-24

I'm a wealthy individual in 18th century North America. How do I keep my money and valuables safe?

1 Answers 2014-02-24

Is it coincidence, or is there a solid reason why the fables and imagery of Dragons, ranging from Far Eastern Asia, all the way to Western Europe, are relatively the same (ie breathing fire and flying)?

I'm aware that Dragons are a very old and important creature in Asian culture and myth, but how did this imagery of Dragons spread to Europe? Was it coincidence that both peoples had fables with dragons? Was there knowledge of dinosaurs somehow to spark this idea?

7 Answers 2014-02-24

Why did the Delhi sultanate fall?

Were there internal problems or was it just a matter of foreign conquest?

1 Answers 2014-02-24

In I, Claudius theres a scene in which Tiberius and the senate openly discuss whether to continue the new monarchy or not. Did this actually take place?

1 Answers 2014-02-24

Do we know why or how the Great God Pan died?

I was reading through his Wikipedia page and it states that Pan dies, except the section on it is sort of confusing and has a lot of [citation needed] markings. I was wondering if anyone could shed some light on this.

1 Answers 2014-02-24

Why did no civilization develop along the banks of the Mississippi?

River systems have been the home to many civilizations (Nile, Indus, Tigris and Euphrates) but how come one did not develop along the Mississippi?

3 Answers 2014-02-24

Are there any recorded instances of homosexuality among indigenous tribes in Africa or the Americas?

2 Answers 2014-02-24

To what extent was Congress's declaration of war on Germany in 1917 a reflection of American public opinion at the time?

I know during WW2 America's declaration of war on Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany was (for the most part) supported heavily by the general public. I was simply wondering if this was the same way during WW1.

1 Answers 2014-02-24

Martial Races

1 Answers 2014-02-24

True or False?: Russia can either be an empire or a democracy, but not both.

1 Answers 2014-02-24

Why is there no unclaimed land (Exempting Antarctica) any more and when did it become unacceptable to just have areas independent of a national entity?

Looking at maps or globes today, every inch of land is directly controlled by one country or another. The vast emptiness of the Sahara is claimed by a handful of countries even though the benefits to their country the desert brings is negligible. This goes hand in hand, I think, with the ideology of solid borders overtaking that of a march or neutral zone.

5 Answers 2014-02-24

how dangerous for the empire were the barbarian invasions of the third century?

1 Answers 2014-02-23

Resources on Persia

Hello, I took a class last semester on the Ancient Near East, and was interested in looking into the Persians a bit closer. However I noticed there weren't any books on them on the booklist, do you guys have any good starting points for it?

1 Answers 2014-02-23

Question about sailing in the 18th Century.

I watched a video that was on the front page today of a guy sailing through twenty foot seas on a cargo ship of some sort. I am wondering if there are any good sources on what it was like for naval or merchant vessels during the era of wooden sailing ships to go through massive ocean storms. It's hard to believe the scale of the storms and waves even seeing them in comparison to large tankers. I can't imagine what it would have been like on a smaller wooden ship.

Edit: Here is a link to the aforementioned video if anyone was curious http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/1yppe6/i_work_at_sea_this_is_a_video_of_a_storm_we_were/

1 Answers 2014-02-23

At what point did the German people really distance themselves from Nazism?

I've tried googling this and searching this board, and can't really find a discussion of this. Maybe it's very widely known and I'm just searching incorrectly. Was it a gradual waning of support, and did it start to wane before the end of WWII or only afterwards? I guess I'm just curious as to how it got to the point at which the population that had supported it in such huge numbers ultimately came around to recognizing its having been so horrific.

1 Answers 2014-02-23

How did ancient seafaring peoples of Melanesia find remote islands like Easter Island, yet miss the Americas?

EDIT: I'm told Polynesians are the ancestors of native pacific islanders, not Melanesians. My mistake - and thanks for the correction!

I guess two parts to my question.

First, how did ancient peoples of the Pacific Islands travel? What were their boats like? Could they survive at sea for extended periods of time, and if so, how? How did they find so many small isolated sets of islands they ended up settling, like Easter Island?

Second, if they could locate and colonize Hawaii and all these small remote places islands in the Pacific, how could they miss colonizing North and South America? I get they could miss something like the Galapagos Islands, but the Americas are rather large. My understanding is the ancestors of the Native Americans in both South & North America is they came across a Bering Strait land bridge.

Thanks!

4 Answers 2014-02-23

How did European powers view the American Civil War? Was there a possibility that any countries would intervene?

3 Answers 2014-02-23

I'm a blacksmith in London, ca 1400. How much money do I make? How educated am I? What kind of goods do I make most often?

In historical fiction and medieval fantasy, blacksmiths are shown to really only make armor and weapons, along with the occasional horse shoe. What would blacksmiths really make, and what techniques would be used? Would the average London blacksmith ever make armor?

8 Answers 2014-02-23

What did China trade for?

I know that throughout its history China was a valuable trading partner for a lot of other places. I understand why the tea, the porcelain, the silk and so on that came from China was valuable. But what did the Chinese get in return? What did the non-Chinese world produce that the Chinese wanted?

3 Answers 2014-02-23

Monarchy or democracy?

Which would be better, an ideal monarchy with a good king or an ideal democracy?

1 Answers 2014-02-23

7062 / 7255

Back to start