I won't waste anyone's time by asking of Russian presidents like to get messed up. But I was wondering how the secret service would handle this situation. Were there formal or informal mechanisms in place to monitor or prevent this kind of behaviour?
1 Answers 2019-09-24
It's a very specific question, a friend of mine asked earlier today and 10 minutes of google didn't provide much.
So to be more clear, how much would say a unit of 1000 men from say the era of the Spanish War of Succession cost. And I guess it really doesn't make much sense because I assume not every European power had a unit of 1000 men, but the closest unit to that size would serve my purposes. And most importantly I'm Intrested in the variety in cost between nations
How would the Cost of a British unit compare to a French unit?
Im mainly intrested in France Britain and Spain but the Russian Polish, Prussian and Swedish costs would be good as well.
And I also assume the cost would vary greatly between different types of Infantry, so I'm asking for the "base" Infantry unit each nation.
(Im so sorry if this post violates a rule, I read it over and I think it should be ok, my apologies if Im mistaken)
Edit:
Thx so much for the great reply its so much more then I asked, which is great, and will help alot more :)
2 Answers 2019-09-24
After taking control of Tenochtitlan, Spanish conquistadors faced stiff opposition as they tried to expand colonial control out if the Valley of Mexico. The Mixton and Chichimeca Wars, the centuries-long war in the Yucatán, and the prolonged conflicts in western Mexico cost the empire dearly.
What guerrilla or asymmetric warfare strategies/tactics were used to confront colonial expansion? How did those strategies differ region to region, or change over time?
Thanks in advance!
1 Answers 2019-09-23
I feel like this is a stupid question ("no stupid questions," right?) but we were really baffled by those relatively tiny hilts. In popular media these ancient warriors are depicted as big/tall/muscular but these blades looked crafted for oompah loompahs. Thx!
2 Answers 2019-09-23
I've read an article recently (https://arxiv.org/abs/1805.00463) that claims that computer games are often useful in teaching history courses, and a recent article from MIT Technology Review claims that they may be useful in research, sparing something they call 'computational history'.
How useful are simulations and computational tools in the study of history in general, and these games in particular?
1 Answers 2019-09-23
There's a ton of Shakespeare productions that update the plays' settings, so that the plays speak clearer to more contemporary issues. Some other notable examples include Orson Welles' Voodoo Macbeth (1936, Haitian Revolution) and Julius Caesar (1937; Fascist Italy), Ian McKellan's Richard III (1995, fascist England), Leonardo DiCaprio's Romeo + Juliet (1996, 90s LA), and Ralph Fiennes' Coriolanus (2011, 21st century Europe).
2 Answers 2019-09-23
I've heard it said many times that hoplite heavy infantry fighting in formation was not well-suited to Greek terrain, but I've never heard what a more-logical fighting style would be. It doesn't feel like the terrain would be and more forgiving to cavalry. Is there a more natural way of war and did anyone in the area fight like that? Are the terrain limitations overblown?
1 Answers 2019-09-23
I feel like this MUST have been done before and I’m just not good at googling this kind of thing, but:
I was watching this show on Netflix called Colony, and basically a bunch of aliens enslave the earth and of course there’s a resistance and the resistance steals some form of census data from the aliens and basically when they plotted it over time the human population was falling to 0 on a nice curve like this
Of course this is a tv show, but it got me wondering, what did a similar chart from the time of the Nazis reign look like for the Jewish people? I assumed this had been done before, but I can’t seem to find it. And if somehow this hasn’t been done, anyone know where to find data on this so I can make my own? I know this data would be estimates that could vary wildly, but just curious as to what it would look like.
1 Answers 2019-09-23
2 Answers 2019-09-23
I don't mean what he did, I mean, who was he as a person? I've been poking around just for shits and gigs and there seems to be almost nothing known about his personal life, in fact, there's almost nothing that seems to be known about him beyond his works and accomplishments as a writer, so, who actually was he? what was his early life like? how did he get his education? did he ever have family? friends? was he charismatic and outgoing or more recluse? these are the kind of questions that interest me about famous historical figures
1 Answers 2019-09-23
Coming fresh off the heels of WWII you'd think the U.S. would be poised to win rather easily. Yet most of what I've read on this subject shows of significant problems in the early stages of the war. I know budgets were obviously cut along with considerable demobilization but it seemed far too worse to believe.
Is it true that when Truman called for a blockade of North Korea the navy told him I'd only be possible on paper? The US navy literally fielded 24 Essex Class Carriers, along with Midway Class Carriers being built. Not to mention the other carriers of various configurations...
2 Answers 2019-09-23
During air battles like the Battle of Britain, and aerial combat in general, the vast majority of rounds fired missed. What happened when they fell to the ground?
1 Answers 2019-09-23
By which I mean influential in internal Soviet politics and decision-making
1 Answers 2019-09-23
I've read that coffee was an old person's drink in the 70s and 80s, but by the 90s more young people were drinking it.
Why did younger people during that period not embrace it? What were they drinking instead?
What happened in the 90s to turn things around?
1 Answers 2019-09-23
I know that Italy used gas against Abyssinia before WWII, but I haven’t heard of gas being used in combat during WWII. If Hitler had no problem using gas on civilians during the Holocaust, why didn’t he use it in combat? Also, German was developing nuclear weapons, I find it hard to understand why they wouldn’t implement other WMDs.
1 Answers 2019-09-23
I’ve heard about this but I don’t actually know if this is true.
1 Answers 2019-09-23
My understanding is that prior to the Renaissance, the world was fairly equal. There were people living feudally and tribally. The feudal system (in its various forms) was practiced in many parts of Europe and Asia, but I don't know if it really existed elsewhere. I don't think any particular group of people had vastly different ideas around the time of 700-1400 CE.
Why did the renaissance spring up in Europe in particular and not elsewhere (or am I wrong, and it did happen elsewhere)? Why did the enlightenment springup in Europe? How are these events connected?
I'm just going to spitball a response, and you can correct me wherever you like.
1 Answers 2019-09-23
I'm writing a book with pseudo-historical elements and I'm looking for detailed answers and/or good resources which cover relevant topics.
The scenario is as follows:
The band consists of 3–5 people who are skilled archers, good at climbing and decent at sneaking (they are hunter-gatherers). They have access to rope; possibly a grappling hook.
The city they have to infiltrate would be somewhere between Uruk, Akkad (so, old cities) and perhaps Ancient Rome (forgive the vast time differential here) in terms of fortifications and military technology. Basically, they'd have walls, possibly the odd watch-tower/turret and may have guards patrolling the wall.
Would it realistically have been feasible to at all infiltrate a city like this without getting spotted, or would you have gotten noticed and instantly captured or killed?
Many thanks for your time!
1 Answers 2019-09-23
1 Answers 2019-09-23
3 Answers 2019-09-23
I've heard people say he did or that he didn't rape her, or that it was consensual etc but no one has ever provided sources/evidence for their claims; so I was wondering what proof there is that he had sexual relations with Hemmings (or any of his slaves)
1 Answers 2019-09-23
Hi Guys!
I’m involved in a book-project. And we are wondering wether or not one Can find lists of prisoners from the Meppen-Dalum camp. And my google-fu has Met it’s limit here.
Thanks!
1 Answers 2019-09-23
Hello Everyone!
I am Alexander Burns, a historian who studies late-seventeenth and eighteenth-century warfare in Europe and North America. In addition to writing my dissertation I run the historical blog Kabinettskriege, one of the largest sites dedicated to the study of this era of warfare.
So far, my publications has examined the British, Hessian, and Prussian armies during this time. My dissertation specifically examines the armies of the British Empire and Prussia, from 1739-1789. I am the editor of a forthcoming volume or Festschrift, which celebrates the career of noted historian Christopher Duffy with new research on this period of warfare.
Since folks are still commenting, I am going to extend this AMA until 12pm EST today, September 24, 2019. I'll be in and out, responding to your comments as best I can.
If you have further questions on this era of warfare, check out my blog at: http://kabinettskriege.blogspot.com/
You can also reach out to me via twitter @KKriegeBlog and via email at kabinettskriege@gmail.com if you have pressing questions which you need answered!
134 Answers 2019-09-23