I was once told by one professor that many Enlightenment-era philosophers were influenced by Chinese philosophers while another professor said that they weren't. Which one is true?

When I was college, I took a course in East Asian history and I recalled my professor mentioning that many philosophers of the Enlightenment were influenced by ancient Chinese philosophers because around that time Chinese texts were becoming available to Europeans. However, later on in college, my professor who taught a course in critical theory told me that none of the philosophers of the Enlightenment were influenced by Eastern philosophy.

Which of my professors were right? Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2015-07-17

[WW2] Did Sir Robert Gordon Menzies position himself to take over from Churchill during the Second World War?

EDIT:Winston Spencer Churchill, I accidentally left his first and middle name from the question

Historian David Day claims in his book Menzies and Churchill at war that Robert Menzies returned to Australia from England in April 1941 after positioning himself to take Churchill’s job, it has taken root in popular Australian history with even the ABC making it the subject of a documentary. So I ask the historians on this subreddit if Menzies did position himself for the role as stated by Mr Day or if this is a falsehood?

Relevant links http://www.abc.net.au/tv/documentaries/interactive/pms/ep2/ https://books.google.com.au/books/about/Menzies_Churchill_at_War.html?id=Z8BiQgAACAAJ&hl=en

1 Answers 2015-07-17

What is the earliest known use of medicine that is still used today?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

What are the best texts, books or other resources for learning about French History from the French Revolution Through 1914?

I am trying to learn more about French history. Can someone advise some good texts, books or other resources that would be good reads?

3 Answers 2015-07-17

Reading Suggestions for Slovak/Czech History?

I am from Slovakia, born and raised, and have been reading a lot into history these past few years. I am passionate about European history, WW1, WW2, Germany, France, Spain, etc. But my deepest interests are and have always been those of my homeland, Slovakia. I have searched quite a bit for reading material on Slovakia or Czechoslovakia, to little avail. There are some books that I found, but I am not confident of their quality or reputation to pick them up.

So my question is, does anybody have any good reading suggestions or books to recommend for any form of Slovak or Czech history? I'd be interested in anything that could encompass these two entities. A book about Bohemia or Moravia could suffice, as those are technically the ancestors of the Czechs. Even a good reading on Austria-Hungary could do, or a book about an event central to Slovaks or Czechs, like the Prague Spring or Velvet Revolution for example. If it focuses enough on the Czech or Slovak elements, I will read it!

Thank you for any and all readings and recommendations!

5 Answers 2015-07-17

what is the point of leaning about history?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Growing up in the 60s, we would occasionally see the trope of a person who was so broke and possessionless that all they had to wear was a barrel. Where did that come from, and is there any historical or realistic basis for it?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Was Ty Cobb Actually a Racist?

Reading Ty Cobb: A Terrible Beauty by Charles Leerhsen, he is adamant that Cobb's reputation as a racist is unfounded and indeed contrary to the facts. Is he being selective or dismissive of sources otherwise accepted as genuine, or is Cobb indeed a victim of a smear campaign?

(P.S. It seems I hit an /r/AskHistorians bingo! Searched first and there were 0 mentions of Ty Cobb.)

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Was the supposedly vegan diet of the Roman gladiators ever glamourised as masculine and tough among the spectators and society generally?

Follow up questions:

  • To what extent did spectators of fights know about the diet of the gladiators? Was it emulated at all in the same way people might read a muscle magazine today and recreate a diet of a bodybuilder they like?

  • How different was the standard Roman diet different to the diet of the gladiators?

  • Do we have an accurate idea of how muscular the gladiators actually were apart from possibly embellished depictions?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Did the Macedonian phalanx totally eclipse the older greek-style hoplites/phalanxes?

Did the Macedonian phalanx ever totally replace the older greek hoplites/phalanxes, or were various cities/kingdoms in the Mediterranean still using them after if became apparent that the Macedonian phalanx was so highly effective?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

How did sieges in the middle ages work?

So I've been always curious, how did sieges work in, say, 1400? Sis troops just stand around a fort until the defenders gave in? Or did they bash their way through walls with force? And how long would they usually take? I'm talking Europeans, but other parts of the world work, since I would like to know about other siege technologies.

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Why do we have AM/PM?

If you can count to 12hrs, then you should be able to count to 24hrs. So what is the purpose of having the day numeration reset after 12? Military time is 24hrs, so they must have realized something is better/more accurate about it.

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Why is D. Afonso Henriques of the 12th century painted wearing full plate armour?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

How did sohei (Japanese warrior monks) come to power?

Also: Why were they involved with the Minamoto?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Help identify this uniform.

I've been trying to identify this uniform. It appears to be US Army Infantry around the early 1900's. Can anyone clarify the uniform in this pic.

http://imgur.com/NG22iBJ

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Why does it seem that the Japanese were so especially heinous in their actions, in WW2?

Every time I read descriptions of Japanese massacres in WW2, they are more heinous and evil than anything else I've read. It seems as though the Japanese didn't regard other Asians as humans. My main question is why did the Japanese act so unbelievably cruelly?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Are we able to reasonably believe that Moses existed?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

To what extent, if at all, were Germanic Languages spoken in the Novgorad Republic?

I ended up stumbling on the wikipedia page for the Novgorad Republic earlier. In the box that showed what languages were spoken there, it listed "germanic languages" as unofficial languages of the Novgorad Republic. Is this accurate? Also, if it is, what Germanic languages would've been spoken there?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

What popular quotes attributed to historical figures are either wrongly attributed or misquoted?

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Can't seem to find any information on the meaning or Origin of the Family name Lyttaker

Title says it all. Family lore starts it's Scandinavian but I can't find anything about it anywhere.

1 Answers 2015-07-17

Was the civil war started based primarily on states rights?

Growing up in the South i've always been taught that the civil war was not started because of slavery, it was because of states rights. Yes slavery had something to do with it, but it was not the main reason of the war. The states believed the government was having too much control over them the same Britain had before. So when I see the confederate flag, I don't see a symbol of slavery, I see a flag condoning states rights, meaning that they are in favor of less interference from the government. I was also taught that whether or not Abe Lincoln created the emancipation proclamation, slavery was on its way out anyway.

3 Answers 2015-07-16

In Schindler's List, Schindler purposely produces malfunctioning equipment for the Nazis. Is this accurate? Did this occur on a wider scale among war industrialists who opposed the Nazis? Did this form of nonviolent resistance put a dent in the German war effort?

1 Answers 2015-07-16

Tripods

Why did the ancient Greeks and Romans have a thing about tripods? Was there something about the number three being mystic or the stability of the three legged stool?

1 Answers 2015-07-16

How were Jews treated in Japan during World War II?

1 Answers 2015-07-16

WWII: What's the best source to get an overview of it? All I really learned about in school was the holocaust, D-Day, blitzkrieg, and Hitler.

In high school all they really taught us about WWII was that Hitler was taking over countries rapidly until he owned most of Europe (due to an appeasement policy, fearing a second Great War) with Britain being the last hold out, as they got bombed.

While holding Europe, the Holocaust happened (I took a whole class about just the Holocaust, but they didn't give the details of the war).

Eventually the US joins the war after Japan bombs Pearl Harbor, they and Britian do the D-Day thing, and the wars over. (It's obviously not this simple, and I know it, but I don't know the details)

I know nothing about the Russian side, and I know that was a big deal. Stalingrad is a thing I hear mentioned a lot.

But obviously the war isn't just that... Can someone recommend some documentaries, websites, or books that I can look at?

EDIT: I'd really like a timeline style view. Like "this is what happened around the world in March 1942"

2 Answers 2015-07-16

5177 / 7255

Back to start